Jump to content

Bearstronaut

Members
  • Posts

    275
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Reputation Activity

  1. Upvote
    Bearstronaut got a reaction from BeondTheGrave in The Liebstandarte - New youtube documentary   
    When we're talking about the 1st SS Panzer Division, yes we do. The Waffen SS was an integral part of the Nazis' racist and genocidal warmongering. I am deeply, deeply suspicious of anyone who makes a hobby of dressing up like these guys (especially if you are an American, which this guy's accent tells me he is). The Military History Visualized guy has made dozens of videos about the WW2 German military but never felt the need to dress up as an SS soldier while doing so.
  2. Upvote
    Bearstronaut got a reaction from Warts 'n' all in The Liebstandarte - New youtube documentary   
    When we're talking about the 1st SS Panzer Division, yes we do. The Waffen SS was an integral part of the Nazis' racist and genocidal warmongering. I am deeply, deeply suspicious of anyone who makes a hobby of dressing up like these guys (especially if you are an American, which this guy's accent tells me he is). The Military History Visualized guy has made dozens of videos about the WW2 German military but never felt the need to dress up as an SS soldier while doing so.
  3. Upvote
    Bearstronaut reacted to Sgt.Squarehead in The Liebstandarte - New youtube documentary   
    In general I'd agree with your comments, but the SS (and those who idolise them) get a lot less slack from me than others. 
  4. Like
    Bearstronaut got a reaction from Bubba883XL in 2022, the Year In Preview!   
    If you are still unsure of what to focus on for the CMFI battle pack may I make a suggestion? I would like to see it focused on some of the Allied nations who aren't very well represented. Most of the game's stock scenarios are either the US or British armies. The Brazilians, French, Canadians, and Indians only have 2 each I believe. The New Zealanders only have one (very small) scenario. I would love for the focus to be on these guys. Other than that, thanks for making a great product and providing me with hours of entertainment.
  5. Like
    Bearstronaut reacted to fireship4 in The Liebstandarte - New youtube documentary   
    'We don't have to see nazism and racism in every little thing do we?'  No, indeed.  But if we can't at least suspect nazism in a guy dressing as an SS guy all the time and enjoying it, not to mention all the people in the stream mentioning the letters A and H, then we might as well be blind.  There are those who over-react to certain things, indeed.  I am simply making the observation that you have to be seriously lacking in human sympathy to dress up and enjoy playing a member of such a famously murderous organisation.  There are people here who remember those killed in the name of the ideology whose badge he wears for fun.  Him saying he has no political agenda is nonsense, at some point you cannot separate the two.  The uniform means nothing without the ideology.
  6. Upvote
    Bearstronaut reacted to fireship4 in The Liebstandarte - New youtube documentary   
    I won't directly accuse this man of being a neo-nazi. 
    He seems to be entirely uncritical of the SS, even recanting his earlier view that they were 'just a bunch of murderers forced to fight' in another video: apparently 'things are not always as they seem', as he has learnt they were not forced to fight.  In apparently ignoring the political, idelogical, and genocidal side of the organisation and the war, instead of solemnly and soberly decrying it, or reflecting on what it means for whatever honour or virtue the members believed themselves to have, he does a disservice to their victims. 
    I am deeply suspicious of anyone who takes such an interest in roleplaying as a member of such an organisation, other than for precisely the length of time necessary for a documentary, film or reenactment, before taking the uniform off for fear of being sullied by it.  The live stream seems well attended by neo-nazis.  I wouldn't be inclined to give this channel time or views.
  7. Like
    Bearstronaut reacted to silverstars in 2022, the Year In Preview!   
    Woohoo! Early D-Day! Here's hoping for DD tanks! Assault Team organizations! And an awesome OOB remake of The Road to Montebourg! Or some 22nd Infantry Regiment WN clearing! And Ernest Hemingway as a playable unit. 😛
  8. Upvote
    Bearstronaut got a reaction from Aragorn2002 in Geo-Strategic Crisis Over Ukraine Happening Now?   
    That is all incredibly wrong. Ukraine isn't massing for an attack of the eastern territories and Crimea which were illegally stolen from them in 2014 by the original Russian invasion. Russia has gathered over 100,000 soldiers on the border and are the ones who initiated and continued this crisis. 
  9. Upvote
    Bearstronaut got a reaction from LukeFF in Geo-Strategic Crisis Over Ukraine Happening Now?   
    That is all incredibly wrong. Ukraine isn't massing for an attack of the eastern territories and Crimea which were illegally stolen from them in 2014 by the original Russian invasion. Russia has gathered over 100,000 soldiers on the border and are the ones who initiated and continued this crisis. 
  10. Upvote
    Bearstronaut reacted to evilman222 in Geo-Strategic Crisis Over Ukraine Happening Now?   
    Thought I'll chime in here. I wouldn't go as far as to call myself an expert, but I am about a semester away from an MA in International Relations with a focus on Eastern European security, so I'm not exactly talking out of my ass here.
    First off, Hal Turner is a bumbling idiot. That's probably the least credible source out there. If you see anything by him, COMPLETELY disregard it. He peddles in conspiracy theories, instead of doing any kind of "analysis".
    With that out of the way, what's going on in Eastern Europe right now is still concerning, and I would go as far as to say that this is the most dangerous crisis that we've seen since Able Archer. Even if we strip away the whole NATO-Russia angle, there is a realistic chance of war between the two largest military forces in Europe. If that turns into a full on conflict it would not be crazy to imagine a six figure death toll. That said, I am growing increasingly convinced that this is just Russia trying to increase pressure on the West and roll back their expansion to a state that Russia would feel more comfortable with. In fact, I don't think the Russian buildup has as much to do with Ukraine as it does with Belarus. One of the main areas where Russian equipment is being stockpiled is Yelnya. Most analysts that I've seen works from or talked to personally agree that Russian forces in Yelnya (even prior to this current buildup) serve two purposes: for a rapid drive on Kyiv should the situation in Ukraine devolve into open warfare, or to transit through Belarus and cut off the Baltic states in the event of hostilities with NATO. Given the fact that most of the rhetoric from Russia about this mess has been about NATO (instead of Ukraine), I find it hard to believe that they'd build up forces there, then use them to attack Ukraine, removing one of their main assets in conflict with NATO from the board, so to speak. Instead, I think they're building up forces so that they can establish a military presence, including a large portion of the 41st CAA as well as ballistic missiles, in Belarus should this week's talks fail. This isn't necessarily a preparation for war, but is instead Russia's way of saying "NATO expanded uncomfortably close to our borders, so we'll do the same thing and send our troops uncomfortably close to your borders as well". They could also up the intensity of their efforts in Donbas, but the most aggressive move I can see Russia making in the near future would be a move for Mariupol, MAYBE Kharkiv, but the latter is incredibly unlikely.
     
    A couple other notes about crap from the Turner piece
    I have not seen any good evidence for a Ukrainian buildup in preparation for a military operation to retake the Temporarily Occupied Territories. Can't say 100% that it doesn't exist, but I suspect that at least someone I know would have heard about it. Plus it Zelensky has been fairly passive regarding the war, and such an operation would be out of character for him.
    I have also not seen any evidence that the mess in Kazakhstan is related to the Ukraine/NATO-Russia situation. Timing seems to have been a coincidence. That said, Central Asia is a bit out of my wheelhouse so I can't comment much beyond that.
    The whole "NATO missiles in Romania" thing is mostly BS. The US Army has been developing a ground-launched version of the Tomahawk, possibly to be deployed to Europe, but those are not yet operational, and despite all the complaints from Moscow, there is no good evidence that the Aegis Ashore system in Romania is anything but defensive in nature.
    There is also no evidence that the US has deployed tanks to Europe (Moving that number of vehicles without somebody noticing is nearly impossible), nor is there evidence of American aircraft being moved to Ukraine. Russia would be publicly freaking out if either of those happened.
     
     
  11. Like
    Bearstronaut got a reaction from rtdood in New Campaign Released: First into Antwerp   
    Yeah, I’ve already replayed it and progressed in the campaign. I hunted down the German HQ and got enough points to win. First time I played it I just secured the park and didn’t advance any further. I’m really enjoying the campaign BTW.
  12. Upvote
    Bearstronaut got a reaction from Warts 'n' all in Rollbahn D - Day3 and beyond.   
    At least you only lost two. In my game those P-47 pilots were really gunning for the AAA and killed every single one of my flak vehicles and lost no aircraft. They didn't go for the tanks or grenadiers at all.
  13. Like
    Bearstronaut reacted to Simcoe in Agenda / Handguns.   
    This guys is a top tier troll. You have to respect the game.
    Imagine spending this much time on a game you don't like lol.
  14. Upvote
    Bearstronaut got a reaction from Rinaldi in Ride of the 120th, victim emotional support group [SPOILERS]   
    That mission is kinda broken. There is no Soviet air controller to call in the two SU27s you have for air support.
  15. Upvote
    Bearstronaut reacted to Halmbarte in Ride of the 120th, victim emotional support group [SPOILERS]   
    I dunno, it's typical Soviet life.
     
    When you have ration coupons for meat, the store does't have meat. When the store has meat, you're out of meat coupons...
     
    Welcome to the future, New Soviet Man!
     
    H
  16. Thanks
    Bearstronaut reacted to The_Capt in Ride of the 120th, victim emotional support group [SPOILERS]   
    Fixed for next patch, hopefully on Steam release.
  17. Like
    Bearstronaut got a reaction from RescueToaster in Reforger Nostalgia   
    That's not that strange. I spent 2012-2015 and all of 2019 with USFK in the Republic of Korea. The average resident of Seoul doesn't think about the thousands of heavy artillery pieces aimed at the city and the million man army less than 40 miles to the north. After my first couple months I didn't really think about it either unless I was at work. 
  18. Like
    Bearstronaut reacted to mjkerner in Fire and Rubble   
    So, what is it with you guys who complain that there aren’t enough bones or information given out, but when Steve and Elvis are all over it with posting after posting, with eye candy and explanations what’s going on(!) and yet you complain about the release being “late”?  
    Sorry, I just don’t get it (and it is exactly the main reason BFC has given for not giving us deadlines). Complaining about one or the other I understand, but both??
     
    Forgot to add: Rant Over, and I love all yuose guys anyways!
     
  19. Like
    Bearstronaut got a reaction from Kraft in September is coming   
    Russia blaming Ukraine for provocation after invading Donbass and annexing Crimea is some Orwellian ****.
  20. Upvote
    Bearstronaut got a reaction from Rokossovski in September is coming   
    Russia blaming Ukraine for provocation after invading Donbass and annexing Crimea is some Orwellian ****.
  21. Like
    Bearstronaut got a reaction from Modernrocco in Fire and Rubble   
    I'll buy anything you guys make. Your games are probably my favorite games of all time.
  22. Like
    Bearstronaut got a reaction from Artkin in Fire and Rubble   
    I'll buy anything you guys make. Your games are probably my favorite games of all time.
  23. Like
    Bearstronaut reacted to fireship4 in September is coming   
    You missed one:
    2014 - Russia did invade Ukraine.
  24. Like
    Bearstronaut got a reaction from mjkerner in Fire and Rubble   
    I'll buy anything you guys make. Your games are probably my favorite games of all time.
  25. Like
    Bearstronaut got a reaction from Anonymous_Jonze in Fire and Rubble   
    I'll buy anything you guys make. Your games are probably my favorite games of all time.
×
×
  • Create New...