Jump to content

womble

Members
  • Posts

    8,872
  • Joined

  • Days Won

    12

Reputation Activity

  1. Like
    womble got a reaction from paxromana in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    What are the chances of the transport system actually delivering a viable nuke to whatever target the Russians pick, given the ABM/AD capabilities currently deployed in Ukraine? Less than 100% I'd suggest, and sending a city-killer and it not going off gets them the same international response as if it detonates, with no intimidation effect whatsoever, just anger and determination turned up from 11 to about 200 on a scale of 1 to 10.
  2. Like
    womble reacted to billbindc in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    If Russia drops a city killer on Lvov, it faces an overwhelming conventional response that would drive it out of Ukraine forthwith, a sanctions regime upped to an out and out embargo and abandonment by China, India, etc. And, of course, the full panoply of American nuclear retaliatory capabilities if it went further up the escalation ladder. 
    It could happen. It's very unlikely. 
  3. Like
    womble got a reaction from A Canadian Cat in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    You misunderstand. It's not about what you're fighting for, it's what you're fighting with. There are a hatful of reasons for the west to arm you against Russia, but "They're Naxis! Look at their unit patches!!"  is just a gimme own goal for Russian propaganda to add to the reasons to not arm you.
    Don't get me wrong, I'm 100% behind Ukraine and understand that you're absolutely not trying to be the reincarnation of the Third Reich. But I was never going to vote for Trump, even if I had the right to do so. You'll beat the Russians in the end, for sure, because you're better, and more determined. The timescale and casualty toll though, if you throw away Western support for some frat-boy humour would look even more grim than they do currently.
    I know you can't stop them, but I hope you can see that it's Bad PR and that currently you're winning the war at the rate you are because you have Good PR. And then there's post-war reconstruction to consider. That's an even softer target for propaganda.
    There was great work done by UKR around the time of the Azovstahl siege, debunking the "neonazi militia" thing. I think it's a stupid risk to undo that when there are powerful lobbies looking for reasons to get our governments to shut down the aid to your country, military, humanitarian and, in the future, for reconstruction.
  4. Like
    womble got a reaction from Centurian52 in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    I understand that "Marine" is actually an acronym: 
    Marines
    Always
    Ride
    In
    Navy
    Equipment

     
  5. Like
    womble reacted to Baneman in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    Ha !
    Forming special extra-good "elite" units when you really need a ton of "good enough" resonates so strongly with the "Germany losing" phase of WW2 that my teeth ache ! 🤣
  6. Like
    womble got a reaction from JonS in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    I think dust is a pretty broad spectrum obscurant. Probably because it's suspended solids rather than vapours and droplets constituting a large part, as is the case for smoke.
  7. Like
    womble got a reaction from sburke in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    Wot? Just?
  8. Like
    womble got a reaction from kluge in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    I understand that "Marine" is actually an acronym: 
    Marines
    Always
    Ride
    In
    Navy
    Equipment

     
  9. Upvote
    womble got a reaction from Huba in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    I think this is a good point. The troops that have crossed the border are, I would gather, pretty battle-hardened. They don't know the terrain as well as Ukraine's defenders in the early days did; the local territorial units have the home ground advantage. And all the airpower Russia's got hanging about can be brought to bear largely unopposed, so it'll be as effective as the Russian ISR can permit. But I wouldn't be surprised if some of the locals get a serious beating if the raiders decide to. So long as they don't hang about too long to take pictures with NLAWed BMPs, they should be able to slip away ahead of any CAS response. I don't think they can sustain their presence for long, but they have the potential to do some acute propaganda-worthy combat damage.
  10. Upvote
    womble got a reaction from Harmon Rabb in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    I understand that "Marine" is actually an acronym: 
    Marines
    Always
    Ride
    In
    Navy
    Equipment

     
  11. Like
    womble got a reaction from Chibot Mk IX in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    I understand that "Marine" is actually an acronym: 
    Marines
    Always
    Ride
    In
    Navy
    Equipment

     
  12. Like
    womble got a reaction from Splinty in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    I understand that "Marine" is actually an acronym: 
    Marines
    Always
    Ride
    In
    Navy
    Equipment

     
  13. Like
    womble got a reaction from sburke in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    I understand that "Marine" is actually an acronym: 
    Marines
    Always
    Ride
    In
    Navy
    Equipment

     
  14. Upvote
    womble got a reaction from A Canadian Cat in The deep pond   
    As far as I'm aware, it's an engine limitation that you've encountered. There is only one level for water.
  15. Like
    womble reacted to Chibot Mk IX in Halftracks with panzerfausts   
    Yes, and assign a team to be the ammo bearer always help. 
    In CMBS I usually put the Inf plt HQ team as the ammo bearer. Inf squad/team take one to two Javelin missile, HQ stay behind, on their back there are additional 2-3 missiles. Besides perform their commander role, in case an Infantry team depleted their Javelin, the HQ team will rush forward share the missile with the Infantry team.
  16. Like
    womble got a reaction from The Steppenwulf in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    You misunderstand. It's not about what you're fighting for, it's what you're fighting with. There are a hatful of reasons for the west to arm you against Russia, but "They're Naxis! Look at their unit patches!!"  is just a gimme own goal for Russian propaganda to add to the reasons to not arm you.
    Don't get me wrong, I'm 100% behind Ukraine and understand that you're absolutely not trying to be the reincarnation of the Third Reich. But I was never going to vote for Trump, even if I had the right to do so. You'll beat the Russians in the end, for sure, because you're better, and more determined. The timescale and casualty toll though, if you throw away Western support for some frat-boy humour would look even more grim than they do currently.
    I know you can't stop them, but I hope you can see that it's Bad PR and that currently you're winning the war at the rate you are because you have Good PR. And then there's post-war reconstruction to consider. That's an even softer target for propaganda.
    There was great work done by UKR around the time of the Azovstahl siege, debunking the "neonazi militia" thing. I think it's a stupid risk to undo that when there are powerful lobbies looking for reasons to get our governments to shut down the aid to your country, military, humanitarian and, in the future, for reconstruction.
  17. Like
    womble reacted to Heirloom_Tomato in Combat Mission is so addictive!   
    This but more. I was playing a massive PBEM many years ago and noticed I had a whole platoon routed and couldn't figure out why. I loaded up the last few turns and watched just that platoon until I could see what happened. 
    I had smashed one of my opponents units and then sent in a whole platoon to go clear them out. Rookie mistake but I sent them all to move at once figuring they would cover each as they ran, no need to area fire to keep the fleeing enemy fleeing. As my platoon was filtering into his postions, the squads got a bit bunched up. One enemy stopped fleeing turned and fired a single shot. It hit one of my guys who was about to throw a grenade. He falls, the grenade bounces into the pile of friendlies. It goes off and down go a bunch of my men, including two others who were also just about to throw grenades. As they fall, their grenades also land at the feet of their comrades and a bunch more guys drop. One single bullet and he took out half a platoon.
    I watched that single turn so many times because I just could not believe what I was seeing. Had we been playing real-time I would have missed it but instead I was able to go back a few turns and see what I had missed. WEGO only ever since.
  18. Like
    womble got a reaction from quakerparrot67 in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    You misunderstand. It's not about what you're fighting for, it's what you're fighting with. There are a hatful of reasons for the west to arm you against Russia, but "They're Naxis! Look at their unit patches!!"  is just a gimme own goal for Russian propaganda to add to the reasons to not arm you.
    Don't get me wrong, I'm 100% behind Ukraine and understand that you're absolutely not trying to be the reincarnation of the Third Reich. But I was never going to vote for Trump, even if I had the right to do so. You'll beat the Russians in the end, for sure, because you're better, and more determined. The timescale and casualty toll though, if you throw away Western support for some frat-boy humour would look even more grim than they do currently.
    I know you can't stop them, but I hope you can see that it's Bad PR and that currently you're winning the war at the rate you are because you have Good PR. And then there's post-war reconstruction to consider. That's an even softer target for propaganda.
    There was great work done by UKR around the time of the Azovstahl siege, debunking the "neonazi militia" thing. I think it's a stupid risk to undo that when there are powerful lobbies looking for reasons to get our governments to shut down the aid to your country, military, humanitarian and, in the future, for reconstruction.
  19. Like
    womble got a reaction from cyrano01 in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    That, Mr Burke, is because, for all your protests about senescence setting in, you remain sharp-minded. There are a lot of dullards out there* who will not look past what they're told, by people who have myopic vision themselves whose interests do not align with those of Ukraine.
    * By "out there" I mean "beyond this forum".
    p.s. While I'm addressing the point directly, this isn't really aimed at sburke, more as a hopeful dig to remind others that not everyone sees things the way "we" do, even as generally as that can be a true statement, and that those people have, or seek, with some prospect of attaining, power.
  20. Like
    womble got a reaction from paxromana in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    So a "Prigozhinic Victory"? Has Pyrrhus been overtopped sufficient in the "victory that cost more than it was worth" stakes to have his name replaced?
  21. Like
    womble got a reaction from LuckyDog in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    You misunderstand. It's not about what you're fighting for, it's what you're fighting with. There are a hatful of reasons for the west to arm you against Russia, but "They're Naxis! Look at their unit patches!!"  is just a gimme own goal for Russian propaganda to add to the reasons to not arm you.
    Don't get me wrong, I'm 100% behind Ukraine and understand that you're absolutely not trying to be the reincarnation of the Third Reich. But I was never going to vote for Trump, even if I had the right to do so. You'll beat the Russians in the end, for sure, because you're better, and more determined. The timescale and casualty toll though, if you throw away Western support for some frat-boy humour would look even more grim than they do currently.
    I know you can't stop them, but I hope you can see that it's Bad PR and that currently you're winning the war at the rate you are because you have Good PR. And then there's post-war reconstruction to consider. That's an even softer target for propaganda.
    There was great work done by UKR around the time of the Azovstahl siege, debunking the "neonazi militia" thing. I think it's a stupid risk to undo that when there are powerful lobbies looking for reasons to get our governments to shut down the aid to your country, military, humanitarian and, in the future, for reconstruction.
  22. Upvote
    womble got a reaction from Kinophile in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    You misunderstand. It's not about what you're fighting for, it's what you're fighting with. There are a hatful of reasons for the west to arm you against Russia, but "They're Naxis! Look at their unit patches!!"  is just a gimme own goal for Russian propaganda to add to the reasons to not arm you.
    Don't get me wrong, I'm 100% behind Ukraine and understand that you're absolutely not trying to be the reincarnation of the Third Reich. But I was never going to vote for Trump, even if I had the right to do so. You'll beat the Russians in the end, for sure, because you're better, and more determined. The timescale and casualty toll though, if you throw away Western support for some frat-boy humour would look even more grim than they do currently.
    I know you can't stop them, but I hope you can see that it's Bad PR and that currently you're winning the war at the rate you are because you have Good PR. And then there's post-war reconstruction to consider. That's an even softer target for propaganda.
    There was great work done by UKR around the time of the Azovstahl siege, debunking the "neonazi militia" thing. I think it's a stupid risk to undo that when there are powerful lobbies looking for reasons to get our governments to shut down the aid to your country, military, humanitarian and, in the future, for reconstruction.
  23. Like
    womble got a reaction from JonS in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    So a "Prigozhinic Victory"? Has Pyrrhus been overtopped sufficient in the "victory that cost more than it was worth" stakes to have his name replaced?
  24. Like
    womble got a reaction from CAZmaj in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    You misunderstand. It's not about what you're fighting for, it's what you're fighting with. There are a hatful of reasons for the west to arm you against Russia, but "They're Naxis! Look at their unit patches!!"  is just a gimme own goal for Russian propaganda to add to the reasons to not arm you.
    Don't get me wrong, I'm 100% behind Ukraine and understand that you're absolutely not trying to be the reincarnation of the Third Reich. But I was never going to vote for Trump, even if I had the right to do so. You'll beat the Russians in the end, for sure, because you're better, and more determined. The timescale and casualty toll though, if you throw away Western support for some frat-boy humour would look even more grim than they do currently.
    I know you can't stop them, but I hope you can see that it's Bad PR and that currently you're winning the war at the rate you are because you have Good PR. And then there's post-war reconstruction to consider. That's an even softer target for propaganda.
    There was great work done by UKR around the time of the Azovstahl siege, debunking the "neonazi militia" thing. I think it's a stupid risk to undo that when there are powerful lobbies looking for reasons to get our governments to shut down the aid to your country, military, humanitarian and, in the future, for reconstruction.
  25. Like
    womble got a reaction from PEB14 in The deep pond   
    As far as I'm aware, it's an engine limitation that you've encountered. There is only one level for water.
×
×
  • Create New...