Jump to content

LongLeftFlank

Members
  • Posts

    5,365
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    15

Reputation Activity

  1. Like
    LongLeftFlank got a reaction from cesmonkey in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    https://www.spglobal.com/commodityinsights/en/market-insights/latest-news/oil/022224-feature-russia-defiant-two-years-into-war-reshaping-global-energy
    Nice infographic, for those interested:

    Interesting that in spite of its stated intent to remain neutral in the conflict (partly in gratitude to Russia for its past support), energy-hungry Vietnam is not a significant importer of Russian oil.
  2. Like
    LongLeftFlank got a reaction from kimbosbread in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    Ha ha, no. They might possibly be, if China wasn't sitting on the Spratlys.
  3. Upvote
    LongLeftFlank got a reaction from dan/california in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    https://www.spglobal.com/commodityinsights/en/market-insights/latest-news/oil/022224-feature-russia-defiant-two-years-into-war-reshaping-global-energy
    Nice infographic, for those interested:

    Interesting that in spite of its stated intent to remain neutral in the conflict (partly in gratitude to Russia for its past support), energy-hungry Vietnam is not a significant importer of Russian oil.
  4. Upvote
    LongLeftFlank got a reaction from zinz in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    https://www.spglobal.com/commodityinsights/en/market-insights/latest-news/oil/022224-feature-russia-defiant-two-years-into-war-reshaping-global-energy
    Nice infographic, for those interested:

    Interesting that in spite of its stated intent to remain neutral in the conflict (partly in gratitude to Russia for its past support), energy-hungry Vietnam is not a significant importer of Russian oil.
  5. Like
    LongLeftFlank reacted to Grigb in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    We have GrigB Intelligent Translation Services. During next week, the Russian Statistical Service will release a fresh report. Over the weekend, Russian opposition economist Milov will assess the campaign's strategic impact. If nothing bad happens on my end, we'll have a summary by Sunday night.
  6. Like
    LongLeftFlank reacted to Grigb in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    The artillery situation there is not as dire as we believe. Agent 13th reported three days ago.
    At the very least, UKR CB has been successful there.
     
    I watched a new RU video regarding FPV drone suppression. The most fascinating remarks, however, are those concerning the current situation:
    UKR took Million Drones program seriously Reports from different [front] locations say that life of RU fighters is getting worse and harder [due to FPV drones] [Situation] is getting hotter [for RU troops] Unlike RU, UKR regularly suppresses control of RU drones because RU drones en masse are not prepared to counter EW. UKR drones are prepared [RU FPV programs are seriously lagging behind UKR]   
     
  7. Like
    LongLeftFlank reacted to Zveroboy1 in What WW2 hex wargame/map is best to reuse for the current Ukraine War?   
    A new WIP wargame:  Miracle on the Dnipro covering the initial phase of the war and the assault on Kyiv.

    The designer's diary might be of interest to some:
    https://sdhist.com/first-draft-of-history-russo-ukraine-war-d-b-dockter-mark-herman/
  8. Like
    LongLeftFlank reacted to The_Capt in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    I don’t think anyone of serious power in the West wants a full Russian collapse.  The overall Western grand strategy since the end of the Cold War has been “stable status quo”.  We have spent the last 33 years pretty much working on all fronts to sustain “the system”.  We toss scarfs and hats on it but at its core is a central unchanging stability.  Why?  Because stability is good business.  The West, with the US at the centre built the scheme that “won” the Cold War and want that party to keep going because we get very rich off it.  The rest of the world makes our stuff for cheap, while also buying our other stuff.  
    But pretty much from Day 1 “the others” pushed back.  First was the intra-war years, interventions and then terrorism.  Now this has upscaled to “revisionist states” and “power competition”.  Russia invaded Ukraine for several reasons but one of them definitely was to demonstrate that they are not going to be bound by western rules (Hell, Putin said exactly this in that speech back in Sep ‘22).  This puts the West in a dilemma, they can either do too little and Russia threatens the system, or they crush Russia…and it threatens the system.  So they appear to have chosen the middle path, which of course is getting hijacked by the internal movements who want to…wait for it…change the system.  MAGA, alt-right, nationalists, whatever, all disagree with “the system” even though it has made everyone richer.  The reality is that it did not make everyone equally rich so discontent is natural.  Worse, power spheres exploit this so they can get more powerful (and richer).  So Rust-Belt yokels eat this stuff up and start to dismantle “the system”, which includes democracy apparently.  The reality is Trump is a symptom, not a cause and I am not sure even they realize how dangerous this game they are playing is.
    So Ukraine happens and becomes a symbol of a “war for, and against, the system.”  It isn’t about the fact that killing innocent Ukrainians is wrong - hell if morales like human life mattered we wouldn’t have Gaza.  No, Ukraine is all about “the system” and both sides appear to be waging it viewed through that lens.  Russia needs to show that they are going to play by their own rules, but not completely break themselves.  One could ask “why is Russia fighting this war by half measures?”  Do they enjoy a quagmire?  No, Putin understands what he has gotten himself into and is adopting a slow burn strategy, hoping we will get distracted and caught up in our own nonsense…and he might be right.
    The rest of the West is trying to step up, but frankly we have grown awfully fat, dumb and happy on the back of the US - who now is having a bipolar fit.  In the end, we can live with a fallen Ukraine.  We can shore up the borders and lock Russia out.  We can live with a partial victory in Ukraine, do we really care about Crimea, LNR and DNR?  No, we did not in ‘14 and we don’t now.  We can’t live with a completely imploded Russia.  Those are where the real risks lie.  Too many unknowns that could really break the system.  So we wind up with a half hearted war designed to punish Russia for challenging the system but not destroy them.  Ukraine is, and I am being brutally honest here, is almost secondary to the entire conversation.  It was simply a very unfortunate country where both sides could try and prove a point.  We love Ukraine all of a sudden because they are an opportunity to show that 1) Russia was wrong to challenge the system, and 2) the system still works.  
    I strongly suspect this is why this war is also so muddled in military circles.  We are watching a war to defend the system..that is demonstrating the weaknesses of our own military system at the same time.  So we put blinders on and try to pretend it isn’t happening.  Our military power has to still be relevant…otherwise how can we defend the system?
    So to answer your question, “yes, the US and the West know exactly how important Ukraine really is and are fighting this war based on that calculus.”  The answer however is “somewhat important”.  We care and feel bad, but care much more about our own issues.  Putin read the short game about as wrong as one can.  He may have read the long game extremely well.  The way to beat the West is not outright confrontation, it is apathy.  2 years is forever for a culture addicted to clicks and flashing lights.  Putin’s off ramp is being able to draw a victory line somewhere of his choosing and he is shooting for that.  And we might just let him get there.
    Now I would not start freaking out and worry about a second attack on Kyiv.  Something that dramatic might actually get our attention again.  No, this needs to become a boring war - I am starting to think Putin’s Tucker Carlson interview was smarter than we thought.  What better way to get Western audiences to yawn and start to change the channel than a history lesson?
  9. Upvote
    LongLeftFlank got a reaction from quakerparrot67 in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    Yeah, I was enjoying a beautiful clear night last summer on the Mediterranean coast of Spain, only to see a line of 5 satellites ascending, all in perfect line.
     
  10. Like
    LongLeftFlank got a reaction from Probus in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    @Grigb is one of the best contributors to this thread. Just sayin'.
    ****
    VERIFICATION REQUEST. Is it true Russia only has one more A50 AWACS?  Or is this yet another Sushko disinfo special?
     
  11. Upvote
    LongLeftFlank got a reaction from Reclaimer in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    Thanks for the clarification, but you might consider thumbing down the ad hominem attacks a bit.
  12. Upvote
    LongLeftFlank got a reaction from MOS:96B2P in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    @Grigb is one of the best contributors to this thread. Just sayin'.
    ****
    VERIFICATION REQUEST. Is it true Russia only has one more A50 AWACS?  Or is this yet another Sushko disinfo special?
     
  13. Like
    LongLeftFlank got a reaction from paxromana in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    I agree. There's zero likelihood that NATO splashed an AWACS in Russian airspace, cuz WW3.
    You and I are much of the same mind, it seems as I composed this before I read your post....
    The Russians don't necessarily *know* that their manifest destiny and grand strategy is built on a tissue of lies and self-delusion.
    1. The Russians (and their overseas amen corner) have always preached that all the major Western weapons systems in AFU use (Patriot, HIMARS, etc.) are crewed by NATO mercenaries and technicians.
    2. Same 'reasoning' at root: hohol pig farmers and Eurof**gy cosmopolitans can't possibly be cleverer or tougher than Great Russians. Like most bullies, whose behaviour is rooted in a need to prove their superiority (to suppress insecure feelings that they actually aren't), they deeply need to believe that.
    3. By corollary, they also 'know' that once T shuts off the tap and recalls the mercs, 'so-called Ukraine' will collapse like a rotten log, the NATO-backed civil war will end and restore the Greater Russian Union State from Zhitomir to the Dnistr, with only Polish- and Hungarian-controlled rump provinces remaining as a buffer.
    ...So in short, all the US wingnut mouthing is putting the 'comfort' in 'aid and comfort to the enemy'.
  14. Like
    LongLeftFlank got a reaction from danfrodo in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    Yeah, I was enjoying a beautiful clear night last summer on the Mediterranean coast of Spain, only to see a line of 5 satellites ascending, all in perfect line.
     
  15. Like
    LongLeftFlank reacted to zinz in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    I recommend ublock origin 
  16. Upvote
    LongLeftFlank got a reaction from MOS:96B2P in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    Thanks for the clarification, but you might consider thumbing down the ad hominem attacks a bit.
  17. Like
    LongLeftFlank reacted to Letter from Prague in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    Yeah, no way it was West.
    I think this really really shows the disconnect in thinking between Russia and the West.
    Putin is already saying this is existential war for Russia, he is already saying his objective is to destroy the West, and his people - whether random Russians or weirdos and traitors and useful idiots everwhere in the world - are already believing it. He is already doing everything in his power to do that too - from propaganda to interfering with elections to financing fascist parties to helping Hamas to working with Iran and China to assassinating people in other countries to attacking food to cause famine in Africa because refugee crisis empower Western Fascist to whatever else I have lost track.
    Russia already escalated as high as they dared. If they could do worse, if they could do something more despicable, if they could do something more monstrous, they would have done it years ago.
    I remember all these red lines - nuclear war if West gives Ukraine Javelins, nuclear war if West gives Ukraine tanks, nuclear war if West gives Ukraine planes, nuclear West gives Ukraine gets HIMARS, nuclear war if Ukraine attacks Russian warships, nuclear war if Ukraine fires missiles into Russia ... So really I think if West shot down Russian plane they would do nothing like every time before.
    At the same time, the Western decision makers think (or behave as if they thought) that Russia is a country and not a mafia, and that they are not actually at (hybrid) war with us, and that they can be reasoned with and that keeping some kind of "civilized behavior" with Russia is something that makes sense. This is of course wrong - Russia only understands strength and considers humanity a weakness to be exploited - being civilized or nice only makes you hurt.
    So no way it really was West - if West had balls to engage Russia directly, our current conversation topic on this forum would be "do you think the warlord Ivanov will also take south of Moscow?" and not "it's not good that Ukraine is losing ground and people because West decided to not supply them with enough ammo but what can you do, it could be worse".
    ...
    Anyway, one thing I wanted to say: This actually is an existential war for Russia in a way. It is existential for Putin, sure, but as we came to understood during the war and as we discussed a few times, the common (but by no means only) mindset in common Russians is "things are ****, they used to get better and now they don't, but you know what, at least we are a badass empire". They might be even deluding themselves into thinking that things being bad is a voluntary sacrifice for that badass empire. Lot of people are willing to suffer a lot for being part of something they consider greater than themselves.
    Being decisively shown that Russia is not in fact a cool badass empire they be proud of even if they don't themselves have indoor toilets might really break their worlds. Whatever comes out of that would not be Russia as we know it anymore. This is not existential war for Russia because they will end up in mass graves or enslaved if they lose (like it is for Ukrainians), but it is existential for the Russian imperial mindset.
  18. Like
    LongLeftFlank reacted to Grigb in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    RU Nats says there are 6 remaining, however it appears they are referring to the total number. According to UKR Mashovets' UKR colleague:
     
  19. Like
    LongLeftFlank got a reaction from sburke in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    Thanks for the clarification, but you might consider thumbing down the ad hominem attacks a bit.
  20. Upvote
    LongLeftFlank got a reaction from quakerparrot67 in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    Thanks for the clarification, but you might consider thumbing down the ad hominem attacks a bit.
  21. Like
    LongLeftFlank got a reaction from Fernando in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    @Grigb is one of the best contributors to this thread. Just sayin'.
    ****
    VERIFICATION REQUEST. Is it true Russia only has one more A50 AWACS?  Or is this yet another Sushko disinfo special?
     
  22. Like
    LongLeftFlank got a reaction from Monty's Mighty Moustache in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    Thanks for the clarification, but you might consider thumbing down the ad hominem attacks a bit.
  23. Like
    LongLeftFlank reacted to Offshoot in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    This is the best article on the A-50 situation I saw (it was written after the mid-January downing of one) - https://breakingdefense.com/2024/01/after-historic-shoot-down-why-russia-will-struggle-to-replace-its-a-50-aewc-plane/
    According to it, the loss of the specialist personnel could be as significant as the loss of the plane.
  24. Like
    LongLeftFlank got a reaction from G.I. Joe in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    @Grigb is one of the best contributors to this thread. Just sayin'.
    ****
    VERIFICATION REQUEST. Is it true Russia only has one more A50 AWACS?  Or is this yet another Sushko disinfo special?
     
  25. Upvote
    LongLeftFlank got a reaction from TheVulture in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    Thanks for the clarification, but you might consider thumbing down the ad hominem attacks a bit.
×
×
  • Create New...