Sombra

Wow very nice AAR keep it going please

The AA defense value of cities , mines fortresses. IT protects your unit but doesnt increase damage on the stuka trying to hit the city for example

Simply my comment shows taht I think with the overblown (IMO) importance of the aircraft the game gets to dependend on luck...good weather STukas will blow away everything...with bad weather well you are stuck

With good weather advantage Axis..raining advantage Ally...

Konigs nice to see you enjoy the game. We will see if you like the Stukas if they wipe out HQ after HQ later in the game is you have skilled opponent ... or are used as the main "city assault weapon" or simply replace archangels as the "fist of god"

SC2 is a very good game and in the end nearly perfectly balanced regarding units and game mechanics. WAW introduced new units, concepts etc. unfortunately for multiplayer its IMHO not as well balanced as SC2. Is WAW finished or will there me more balancing done? Foremeost in my mind is the building of "Wunderwaffen" aka Stukas which take away the fun of the game if they reach a certain level. For example I would like to see to take away from the power of Stukas: - AA technology would work against Sukas too. - Stukas could not be escorted by fighter - AA cannons could fire more than once What are your worst nightmares in WAW?

Well I hope for some balancing in the next patch. The Stukas are muc to strong for exmaple.

Perhpas I have not played many games where rockets have been used against with much effekt. I have much more problems with the huge damage "Stukas" can deal in this game. To get rockets to be effective you need to build them ...invest R&D and protect it against airstrikes or commando raids ... its role is strongly limited to bombard Londress as it is hard to moce rockets around...

Hexes...movement and distance feels more natural to me.

I am glad that Seamonkey brought up this point. Yes from the game balance point of view the "capital transfer"works but froma realistic point of view? Its not that only a small bunch of high politicans have to flee to Canada or Egypt its about the ability to maintain an army. Evne if Canada formed an excile government who pays the bills...same goes for Egypt why suddenly does all the supply goes up...have they suddenly better logistic abilities than before? I think the main problem is : - In SC2 the german fleet is still to strong. I no way Germany was able to challenge the RN in any meaningful way besides a hit an run tactic with teh subs. - SC1 IMO got the balance right regarding a Sealion...You could do it sometimes with tremendous risk if your enemy made mistakes..otherwise you would fail. - The reaction of America could be stronger. - A samll home defense force could help...but IMO it should be really small...England was already fully armed. ...hard to find more "ghost" armies...

The opion to build railroads could be nice to prepare in advance "escape routes" for the battles in Rusia. Unfortunately As I know human players they would build an extensive railroad net all over france as well and destroying the point of "critical railroad centers" as PAris etc.

--- [ November 28, 2007, 09:53 AM: Message edited by: Sombra ]

After a fw games I would like to ask for some reconsiderations - Nerf the TacBombers at least why are they so damm effective aginst soft targets too? Please give HQs a higher air defense - Norway: England cant take Norway anymore without severe "script" /diplomatic consequences . Unfortunately this has been a real option for the the WW2. IF you would like to make it the historical race simply increase the corps in Norway to 8-10... not an easy knock out for Germany and England either both have to work to cature the country if they want it. - AS the things get worse for Germany this way perhaps lower the research in place by the UDSSR [ November 24, 2007, 01:13 PM: Message edited by: Sombra ]

Persoannyl I think that the concept of naval battle in SC2 WAw works quite well. It only needs a little fine tuning. @Liam I agree that the sub vs battleship in WAw would signify that 70% of all surface battleships would ahve been sunk by subs. @Stalin Organist yes most important is the game aspect still I dont know any turn based strategy game which does a better job as SC2 in WaW

thx hubert. very much [ November 22, 2007, 11:56 AM: Message edited by: Sombra ]

do you play only against the aI or sometimes against other humans SEamonkey?

Well a good axis player will hunt the destroyer with its surface ships and use its subs to sink any surface vessel to threaten his battleships... [ November 22, 2007, 11:03 AM: Message edited by: Sombra ]

- "Never walk alone" - "In a pack we are strong" - Silent is our way to move - A big brother on our tail to surprise sub hunting destroyers is our life insurance. -Having a technological edge helps a lot

thx that helps a lot

I would like to know if you like the new subs in WaW. Personally I have a slight problem with 2 ablities of the subs: - 1st is that a sub is a great killer of surface ships like battleships etc. but that the battleships are more or less helpless against it. - 2nd the new dive away abilty its fun but that afterwards after found one time the sub is able to do a surprise contact anew is really annyoing becauyse it can and from my expereince does screw up the battles in the Atlantik. In my exp. the game follows now many many times the following sheme: - Germany builds up its sub fleet... US and England its destroyers... GErman surface ships try to take out the destroyers and the subs go for the battleships. IF the subs dives good they take out most of the surface allied surface ships. Combine it with subs diving away and away again being able to do new surprise contacts the desteroyer groups getting hurt badly even finding the subs again and again... In SC" the german combined with the italian fleet can build uop an amazong presence in the Atlantik still teh best ships are the subs.

I

as the eleite replacemetns are so incredible powerful I think the current system works as you have to carefully groom your real elite units.

Bug or feature ... In a current game a task force of rusians/americans fight in turkey together to take the country back. Afterwards I would like to operate my troops back rusia. Surprise no american nor rusian, nor english troop is able to operate back to Rusia. All railroad tiles are in my hand but pachted..some bleong to America..some to GB..some to rusia...

[ November 17, 2007, 05:29 AM: Message edited by: Sombra ]