Jump to content

Eddy

Members
  • Posts

    264
  • Joined

Reputation Activity

  1. Like
    Eddy got a reaction from JonS in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    Put it this way, I wouldn't google it at work!
  2. Like
    Eddy reacted to dan/california in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    HR would ever believe you...
  3. Upvote
    Eddy got a reaction from Artkin in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    Put it this way, I wouldn't google it at work!
  4. Thanks
    Eddy got a reaction from Raptor341 in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    This from a Guardian reporter. Could be about right, could be inflated. Time will tell. Would explain why Ukr have decided to stay there tho.
  5. Like
    Eddy got a reaction from JonS in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    I believe they are launched from Sicily. At least whenever I've looked on Flight Radar that's where they came from. Haven't checked in months though
  6. Like
    Eddy reacted to cesmonkey in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    Kofman gave a talk with a few PowerPoint slides looking back at why the Russian invasion plan failed. It was for a Canadian security conference. I find this to be fairly coherent presentation in which he doesn't try to predict the future.  The first part is a long introduction of Kofman, which I skipped. It was uploaded 3 days ago but I don't know when the conference occurred.
     
  7. Like
    Eddy reacted to Grigb in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    Let's talk about the Russian economy. The following are notes from an interview with RU economist Milov. This is the point of view of the RU Liberals, but it is backed up by proof.
     
  8. Like
    Eddy reacted to Grigb in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    While I'm here, the Russian economy is literally dying. Due to skyrocketing prices and their reserve fund, they were able to weather the initial storm until Mobilization. But, with mobilization and the implementation of price caps, the RU economy became a sick man with no hope of recovery. Most likely forever.
    I'll provide some notes on the health of the Russian economy soon.
  9. Like
    Eddy got a reaction from A Canadian Cat in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    A response from Mick Ryan regarding the reports of the Russians modifying their assault tactics
    Basically, he's comparing it to the German Stormtroopers of 1918 and positing that without changes to the operational level it won't make that much of a big picture difference. If there is no capability to exploit, then 'chopping a hole' as Ludendorff called it will lead to nothing. And he doubts that RA will be able to create the capability as it's not just equipment that would be needed, but training, changes to doctrine etc, etc. which is difficult at the best of times, let alone in a war. And of course the Ukrainian have a say as well.
  10. Like
    Eddy reacted to cyrano01 in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    I read Aimee Fox's book after hearing her speak at a Western Front Association meeting and found it similarly recalled to mind during current events; in the context of just how hard it is to change your doctrine on the fly during a shooting war.  It's also worth noting that, in the end, the BEF and French armies pretty much gave up on trying to bring about deep strategic breakthroughs, recognising that logistics and technology didn't permit them. They got their late war results by breaking into the defences while staying within their own artillery range  and leaving the Germans the options of retreating or making a costly counter-attack. I don't think the Russians have the capability even  to do the break in bit. I suspect their operational art has regressed to about 1915.
  11. Like
    Eddy got a reaction from cyrano01 in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    Good point. I hadn't even considered the strategic level as I don't think the RA will be able to do the learning at the operational level. Not necessarily because 'Russia sux' but because it is so difficult to do, especially while fighting a war. 
    I recently re-read Dr Aimee Fox's Learning to Fight about how the British & Dominion armies went about learning in the FWW and the complexities of it - vertical vs horizontal, formal vs informal, Western front vs other fronts, exercise vs pamphlet etc. They had to try to overcome pre-war prejudices, snobbery between fronts (Western Front thought they had nothing to learn from other fronts), snobbery from British towards Canadian and Australian, traditional vs modern, learning the wrong lessons etc. They just about managed it but it took four years. And despite what can be garnered from Blackadder, those armies were open-minded, keen to learn organisations (well most of them). 
    The long and short of it, I got from that book that learning on the job in a war is bloody difficult and complex. 
  12. Like
    Eddy got a reaction from paxromana in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    A response from Mick Ryan regarding the reports of the Russians modifying their assault tactics
    Basically, he's comparing it to the German Stormtroopers of 1918 and positing that without changes to the operational level it won't make that much of a big picture difference. If there is no capability to exploit, then 'chopping a hole' as Ludendorff called it will lead to nothing. And he doubts that RA will be able to create the capability as it's not just equipment that would be needed, but training, changes to doctrine etc, etc. which is difficult at the best of times, let alone in a war. And of course the Ukrainian have a say as well.
  13. Like
    Eddy reacted to kevinkin in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    This is correct. It took the widespread integration of vehicles with the internal combustion engine to exploit tactical gaps in the Allied lines. Not ready in WW1. But in WW2, they brought German troops and supplies forward to critical points faster than the enemy could by foot, rail or horse. This is one key component of 'blitzkrieg". However, this could be defeated by strategic depth even by less mobile forces like the Soviets in 41-42. So even if the RA today can modify its tactics, it still has to maintain momentum into the strategic depth of sector they intend to capture. Fortunately, the RA lack the logistic robustness to do so and Ukraine has plenty of strategic depth to utilize in parrying offensives should they breakthrough.  
  14. Upvote
    Eddy got a reaction from Bil Hardenberger in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    A response from Mick Ryan regarding the reports of the Russians modifying their assault tactics
    Basically, he's comparing it to the German Stormtroopers of 1918 and positing that without changes to the operational level it won't make that much of a big picture difference. If there is no capability to exploit, then 'chopping a hole' as Ludendorff called it will lead to nothing. And he doubts that RA will be able to create the capability as it's not just equipment that would be needed, but training, changes to doctrine etc, etc. which is difficult at the best of times, let alone in a war. And of course the Ukrainian have a say as well.
  15. Like
    Eddy reacted to billbindc in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
  16. Like
    Eddy reacted to dan/california in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    It has the best rundown of the state of Russia's forces, and force generation efforts that I have seen. I think the best way to watch it would be with Jomni's latest set of maps in another window. Thet seem to generally agree, and Jomini has lot more detail on the map.
    They are also in full agreement with my ongoing rant that Ukraine needs more help, and faster to win this thing this summer, instead of giving Putin eighteen months to find and train some semblance of a competent army.
  17. Upvote
    Eddy got a reaction from dan/california in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    It's also available on YT here if that's more convenient:
    I'm about half way through but so far it is well worth the watch
  18. Like
    Eddy got a reaction from Billy Ringo in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    Not sure if this has been posted yet but I found this a fascinating read about the build up and first few days from within the US administration (plus some little bits from the UKs worst ever Prime Minister) in their own words
    ‘Something Was Badly Wrong’: When Washington Realized Russia Was Actually Invading Ukraine - POLITICO
  19. Like
    Eddy got a reaction from Sekai in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    To add to the discussion on Russia's economy:
    Starts with a short discussion of the Chinese FM visit to Moscow and Putin being forced to use the 'small table'! Then goes on to the Russian economy, before the war, during and what's to come.
    Worth watching it all I think but the interesting points for me are:
    Around about May and June Russia was raking it in because the energy shock pushed prices so high but this has now stopped. Russian exports of oil now have a price ceiling and the buyers have no incentive whatsoever to pay more than that ceiling. Russia is not making any money i.e. it's not covering it's costs and the price of a barrel of Ural oil is 35% down on a barrel of Brent. And it's not selling hardly any gas to Europe anymore so that income stream has dried up. So in effect there is no income and Russia is relying on it's savings account i.e. the National Wealth Fund. So Russia is tapping into it's national wealth fund. This has fallen since the start of the year from 12% of Russian GDP to 7% If that carries on Russia Govt. completely runs out of money in 3.5 years (I don't follow his maths here. To me it's sooner than that) But that's only if the events are linear, could burn through the fund faster )or slower I guess) Like I say, don't understand how he got to 3.5 years before that fund runs out.
  20. Upvote
    Eddy got a reaction from Kinophile in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    Correct. The only currency that could possibly rival the dollar as the reserve currency in the near future (like years away) is the Euro and for a number of reasons that's not going to happen. As for the Yuan, it's not traded enough, CCP have this big sovereignty control thing over their currency and there are trust issues.
    As for crypto, it's an asset class similar to gold not a currency.
  21. Like
    Eddy got a reaction from LuckyDog in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    Not sure if this has been posted yet but I found this a fascinating read about the build up and first few days from within the US administration (plus some little bits from the UKs worst ever Prime Minister) in their own words
    ‘Something Was Badly Wrong’: When Washington Realized Russia Was Actually Invading Ukraine - POLITICO
  22. Like
    Eddy reacted to sburke in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    the problem there is no one trusts the Chinese gov't regarding their currency and willingness to alter valuation.  Russia might conceivably buy in for lack of choice, but no other sane currency manager is going to.
  23. Like
    Eddy reacted to Dmytro Gadomskyi in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    1 year of the war is passed. From the start of the invasion and to the huge count of air and missile strikes. One of my friends has been killed by wagner artillery in Bohorodichne village near Bakhumt. My father-in-law has been killed by storming the defensive enemy positions in the Kherson region 1st of October. I gave 3 of my salaries (all what I have)on the first day of the war on the military budget. Thanks to all of you, thanks for your help. Taking carry of our refugees, helping our soldiers to destroy enemy forces with AT weapons, artillery, APS, AFV, and Tanks, peoples who served in foreign legions. Thank you for giving billions of money to support our economy. Special thanks to battlefront for small support for me, when I asked about a discount, they gave me 2 games with all DLCs for free - I didn't expect this. Some of my relatives were in Kherson in occupation, and all high-value electronic and expensive things were looted from them by Russian forces. And now we don't fear rocket strikes (10 times they exploded 700-1000m from my house) we don't fear nuclear threat, we don't fear the second army in the world and you shouldnt. Sorry for we English would that what I want to say for all of you, I can tell you many things about the war but first i will try to improve my language knowlages.
  24. Like
    Eddy reacted to Haiduk in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    Second time for three days explosions heard in Mariupol. Allegedly Russian ammo dump was hit in the port area and the enemy base or storage on "Ilyich" steelworks. No information about what weapon was used. Some Russian propagandists claimed these were GLDSB
    Today Ukrainian MoD press-secreter made a statement that "the time is came, when enemy military targets in Mariupol are no more unreachable place for Ukraianian strikes"
    Recently there were several strikes on Berdiansk area with usage of probably long-range kamikadze-drones and several unsuccessful strikes with Tochka-U (all were intercepted)
    In theory, UKR HIMARS could hit "Ilyich" steelworks, firing from Vuhledar - Novomyhailivka section, but already port is out of range. UKR also could use upgraded "Vil'kha-M" missiles, but since its didn't pass tests in 2021 there wasn't any info about them. UKR episodically used only first version of Smerch upgrade - "Vill'kha" missile (without "M") with range in 70 km.
  25. Upvote
    Eddy got a reaction from Kinophile in How Hot is Ukraine Gonna Get?   
    Just listened to the often excellent Ukraine: the Latest podcast. They are quoting a Western defence official (probably British but that's just my guess) stating that the casualty figures are at least 100K Ukrainians, 200k Russian. Those figures are comprised of killed, missing, wounded and taken prisoner. 
    An important bit is the mortality rate. The official stated (according to them) that the mortality rate for Ukrainian is between 1 in 10 and 1 in 20, whereas the Russian mortality rate is 1 in 3.
    So according to the quote that would be between 5k and 10K Ukrainian dead versus approx. 66K Russian. 
    Must admit I'm taking the 1 in 20 with a pinch of salt but what do I know?
    Can be found here (I've copied at the time they're talking about this so you don't have to wade through an hour!) :
    First reporter fluffs his numbers at first btw
×
×
  • Create New...