SS_PanzerLeader
-
Posts
1,067 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Never
Posts posted by SS_PanzerLeader
-
-
I and many others belived in CC2 that the only way to go was with point battles. I also think it is going to hold true here - Otherwise its just potentially a screwing
I think pregenerated scenrios should be rated for fairness by a panel and/or the players
Point matches will allow dbl blind and you can view the map prior to playing to evaluate terrain
The points will eliminate getting stuck with crappy troops and reinforcement schedules and elimiante this AUTO SURRENDER problem (provided you buy intelligently anyhow
)So far I see no other way to ensure a fair match -
Playing both sides of a scenario is simply not fair and I stated why on anotehr thread
------------------
SS_PanzerLeader.......out
-
Not sure about CMHQ but I'm sure other sites will have a system for catagorizing Scenarios along with some Ratings for playability
------------------
SS_PanzerLeader.......out
-
Kraut what are you talking about ?
This thread is referring to multiplayer games
------------------
SS_PanzerLeader.......out
-
BTW do you realize how long its gonna take to go through a good sized scenario to see that this doesnt happen
At least if we could play to the end if ya made it to get your reinforcements even if morale sucked you may still be able to turn it around - as it stands it's unlikely to happen before morale collapses
yet I havent seen the gold so hopefully this isnt as easy to manipulate as it appears to me
------------------
SS_PanzerLeader.......out
[This message has been edited by SS_PanzerLeader (edited 04-20-2000).]
-
Ok here goes:
here is one way I see that an unscrupulus player could pull this off
1. slighty tweak terrain in favor of desired winning side
2. slightly tweak ammo loadout in favor of desired winning side
3. pick better quality units or adjust morale to favored side
4. set up a reinforcement schedule to coincide with morale collapse
5. Then simply throw em a bone to offset any questionability (ie cover tracks)
VIOLA instant setup
------------------
SS_PanzerLeader.......out
-
Well As far as not playing people goes thats great - but ina ladder you usually have to play everybody like it or not
, and there are genreally rules regarding refusal to play or meet challengesWith regards to manufacturing slanted scenarios that isn't actually cheating _ Its TOTAL BULLS@#T but Technically it aint cheating - and I've yet to see anybody try to implement it as such or find someway of montioring it and/or enforce it
------------------
SS_PanzerLeader.......out
-
thre was an MP40 Colin that is allso known as a SCHMIESSER
------------------
SS_PanzerLeader.......out
-
hehe but of course
------------------
SS_PanzerLeader.......out
-
I never really worry to much about reinfocements in CE because the game doesnt HINGE around them in this scenario as in LD
If you are in such trouble you need your reinforcements at an early stage
You got your work cut out ------------------
SS_PanzerLeader.......out
-
While the idea definitely has it's merits TOm had my opinion pegged with regards to unscrupulous players and scenario design. The ramifications of not knowing the terrain you are about to play on at a compteitive level would really be bad
As an option for single player that would be kool with me - but for multiplayer It would really be the basis for alot of problems
------------------
SS_PanzerLeader.......out
[This message has been edited by SS_PanzerLeader (edited 04-20-2000).]
-
Hmmn < I'm not sure altering the points in the alogothim is the best way to handle the scenario situation . i thought you had something separate in mind
------------------
SS_PanzerLeader.......out
-
Scott - the HELLCAT I had was firing jsut fine
As far as the manipulation goes I answered this in a thread to moon - If ya scroll up you will see what I had to say
------------------
SS_PanzerLeader.......out
-
Kraut said:
Quote:
Hey bloody guts ... don't worry about PanzerGlieder. He seems like the type who would want to press his morals and views on someone (if you don't apologize RIGHT NOW, you'll get your knee-caps shot off, your nuts roasted on an open fire, the IRS will come and take your house, dog, TV and computer, but leave your wife and kids to nag you all day long, and god will make you kiss his dirty, crusty feet for eternity. That is if you even get to heaven ... rofl) . If you wanna bitch about a game, even if it's free, hell, go ahead. I personally view it all as first class online entertainment Besides, if the makers of any game can't handle a little online bitch-o-rama they should find new jobs ...
Lol sorry i'm not pushing anything on anybody _ I just made an observation, and since I was brought up to have some common courtesy I stated what I thought. whether he does it or not I could care less I never actually told him to I just stated my opinion - it isn't like hes never addeed his, or you, yours for that matter
------------------
SS_PanzerLeader.......out
-
Well,
I still hold my position even though Steve has posted his support for it the way it is, i can respect that its his game
But that doesnt mean I like it
I think anyone that would let you chase units around the board is a jerk anyhow - and I wouldnt play him either
But.. If that person is doing damage to me then He should have the right to see what happens and being denied that right is sucking some of the fun right out of the game IMHO
I guess since there will be no modification, the selection practices for competitiive play will become extremely Slow due to scenario scrutinization
Even as it stands I still love the game _ jsut finnaly found an element I REALLY dont like
Oh one other thing the AI will NEVER be able to accurately tell how efficient I can play When Backed into a corner, or on the ropes _ it is a shame this cannot be an option for two agreeing parties
------------------
SS_PanzerLeader.......out
[This message has been edited by SS_PanzerLeader (edited 04-20-2000).]
-
Eriani
This this is one area Fionn and eye don't see eye to eye evidently
I feel the sceanrios are going to need to be rated in some sort of format for fairness.
I am very much interested in hearing your suggestions _ email them if you would rather
------------------
SS_PanzerLeader.......out
-
Well CM trashing aint kool at all
But.... they are giving away a game that Will probably be extremely enjoyable for alot of people so I still think an apology would go along way
But thats just my opinion 
------------------
SS_PanzerLeader.......out
-
Well the fact that these guys have put all thiis effort into this and arent asking a dime for a WELL KNOWN and sucessfully titled game is astonishing> I am not afan of the game but did enjoy SP1 - I was considering looking in the bargain bin cause i thought this was an add on-
At any rate For them to do this for free is was kool , and for you to have anything over there to say that they felt needed to be censored is pretty bad IMO. How can you trash something that someone is giving to you - talk about ungrateful
Personally I think you owe them all a hell of a big apology INCLUDING the administrator, but I will be suprised to se it happen.
I guarantee I will download it sen them a thank you email for their efforts, whether or not It stays on my drive for years to come!
------------------
SS_PanzerLeader.......out
-
Ok eridan You are on
Send me the setup I'll get to it tommorow _ although RON IS the true master of the germ attack in LD ------------------
SS_PanzerLeader.......out
-
Man - you mean to tell me you were giving them a hard time and they were GIVING away the game _ way UNKOOL
------------------
SS_PanzerLeader.......out
-
Ok man let me know if ya come up with some ideas _ I'd really like to hear them
------------------
SS_PanzerLeader.......out
-
IF you mean the MG 34 yes If you actually mean an MG 38 I've never heard of it but if it exists I'm sure others have
------------------
SS_PanzerLeader.......out
-
Ithink you are gonna have to elaborate on this _ rating scenarios Is something I'm all for and currently discussing with someone. if you have some concrete suggestions as to how this will work I'd love to hear them
------------------
SS_PanzerLeader.......out
-
How many time have you actually played LD as AMERICANS
?I'd like to see you keep your morale at high levels - Also I never said I didnt deserve to lose _ I merely wanted to play it out _ I wish people would quit putting words in my mouth and Implying things that simply arent there
------------------
SS_PanzerLeader.......out
sorry forgot a smiley
[This message has been edited by SS_PanzerLeader (edited 04-19-2000).]
-
TOM W already finished emailing it out now
AUTO SURRENDER???????
in Combat Mission Archive #2 (2000)
Posted
Well I'm not sure how you dismiss my points as impossible to set up - didn't quite follow that one. You say they aren't related to morale; but the morale was a very big factor in fact they are cenetred AROUND morale- All those little things add up to slighted scenario; The morale will have a huge effect when you start losing because of all these subtle edges you didnt notice when examining a scenario. You really haven't stated much that I can see that convinces me otherwise - except some unknown feature, but until I see that in action I can only go on what I see
------------------
SS_PanzerLeader.......out