Jump to content

Panther G (late) vs T-34 /85 M44 and others


Recommended Posts

Hey there, i did today a testing map and made a huge test, Panther G (late) vs T-34 /85 M44 and thinked that it would be maybe interesting for some people here around, so i share :

Panther G (late)(321 points) vs T-34/85 M44 (212 points)(10 rounds per test, all units are cracks)

Test 1

500 meter Panther G (late) abandoned T-34 /85 M44 ok

500 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 abandoned

500 meter Panther G (late) destroyed T-34 /85 M44 abandoned

Test 2

500 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 destroyed

500 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 destroyed

500 meter Panther G (late) destroyed T-34 /85 M44 ok

Test 3

500 meter Panther G (late) 1 wounded T-34 /85 M44 abandoned

500 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 destroyed

500 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 destroyed

Test 1

1000 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 destroyed

1000 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 abandoned

1000 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 abandoned

Test 2

1000 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 destroyed

1000 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 destroyed

1000 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 destroyed

Test 3

1000 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 abandoned

1000 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 destroyed

1000 meter Panther G (late) destroyed T-34 /85 M44 abandoned

Test 1

1500 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 abandoned

1500 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 abandoned

1500 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 destroyed

Test 2

1500 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 destroyed

1500 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 abandoned

1500 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 destroyed

Test 3

1500 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 destroyed

1500 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 abandoned

1500 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 abandoned

Test 1

2000 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 abandoned

2000 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 abandoned

2000 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 abandoned

Test 2

2000 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 abandoned

2000 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 abandoned

2000 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 abandoned

Test 3

2000 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 destroyed

2000 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 abandoned

2000 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 destroyed

Test 1

2500 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 destroyed

2500 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 abandoned

2500 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 destroyed

Test 2

2500 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 abandoned

2500 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 abandoned

2500 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 abandoned

Test 3

2500 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 abandoned

2500 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 destroyed

2500 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 abandoned

Test 1

3000 meter Panther G (late) gun damaged T-34 /85 M44 ok

3000 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 destroyed

3000 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 destroyed

Test 2

3000 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 abandoned

3000 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 abandoned

3000 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 abandoned

Test 3

3000 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 abandoned

3000 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 abandoned

3000 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 abandoned

Test 1

3500 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 ok

3500 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 abandoned

3500 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 abandoned

Test 2

3500 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 ok

3500 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 ok

3500 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 ok

Test 3

3500 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 abandoned

3500 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 1 wounded

3500 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 abandoned

Test 1

4000 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 ok

4000 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 1 wounded

4000 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 ok

Test 2

4000 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 abandoned

4000 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 1 wounded

4000 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 ok

Test 3

4000 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 ok

4000 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 1 wounded

4000 meter Panther G (late) ok T-34 /85 M44 ok

want some other tests ?

Enjoy

Greetings Jean-Pierre

[ September 23, 2002, 03:29 PM: Message edited by: JPSeiler ]

Link to comment
Share on other sites

How much does a Panther G (late) cost compared to a T-34/85?

In future tests please include the cost of the unit.

Nashorn/Elefant vs IS-1 and IS-2 please!!!!

Also is there any armor penetration data for the Sturmtiger oe just a blast value? :D something like 2000mm@0 degrees would be cool :D

Regards,

Gryphon

[ September 23, 2002, 10:12 AM: Message edited by: Gryphon ]

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Panzer Boxb
Originally posted by Chad Harrison:

You know, I would of thought that it would be more even. Looks like the Panther VG has quite the advantage. Any in game results along the same line, or does the T34/85 have better in game results?

Mono a mono at under 1000m I have found the Panther and T-34/85 to be about equal. Over 1500m and you start to really notice the optics and gun velocity differences. I had one battle between 4 Tiger Ie (late) with 4 Panther VG (late) and two Flak 88s versus about 30 Soviet tanks ranging from T-34/85 through the IS-2 on a very large map. Engagement ranges were anywhere from about 1800m on up with some hits taking place at about 3000m+. Soviets were regular and Germans were Veteran (to take advantage of the optics). I only lost one Panther to a side hull hit at around 1900m froma T-34 as it was hunting forward and didn't spot the bastage.

In another smaller battle I played the Soviets versus a small, randomly purchased German AI defender who took two Tigers as his main punch. Both fell to T-34/85s at under 1000m. One with a front turret shot and the other to a side hull hit.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

ohh im sorry costs for Panther G (late) 321 and 212 for the T-34 /85 M44.

For the Nashorn vs IS2 ... Nashorn gona lose at any range, allready tested it (short test here) but i will a large one too for you ;) Nashorns armor is just to thin ;)

The Jagdtiger is a real killer but i will show you later some stats smile.gif

Ingame i only fought several T-34 /85 M44 with 88er FLAKs and they get pretty fast destroyed ... .

And im startted the test to see what the new optics system does, and for sure the penetration system :).

Okey im back as soon i did the new Nashorn vs IS2 test :)

laters guys ;)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks lots :D

Another quick question, how does the combat system compare to CMBO's? What i mean is.. smile.gif

If a Panther costs 321 points, how much does a platoon of Panthers cost? and will you ever be able to purchase a platoon of vehicles in a small QB (since they are so expensive)? Also how does infantry compare to tanks in price? lots of infantry for one tank? And how expensive are tank hunter teams? (for eg. PzF 60)

Lots ofquestions i know, sorry :D

regards,

Gryphon

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I just played the Prokhorovka scenario and it proofs that the German heavy tanks have the edge when engaging from range, thanks to their superior optics. I placed the 8 Tiger tanks given in this scenario on high ground, protected their flanks with the Pz III and IV´s and simply watched them tear up the Soviet T-34´s and Su-122´s.

I only lost 1 Tiger from a flank shot by a T-34 which broke through the lines and another Tiger got bogged down in soft ground. The losses among my medium tanks however were considerably higher.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Originally posted by Panzer Boxb:

Mono a mono at under 1000m I have found the Panther and T-34/85 to be about equal. Over 1500m and you start to really notice the optics and gun velocity differences. I had one battle between 4 Tiger Ie (late) with 4 Panther VG (late) and two Flak 88s versus about 30 Soviet tanks ranging from T-34/85 through the IS-2 on a very large map. Engagement ranges were anywhere from about 1800m on up with some hits taking place at about 3000m+. Soviets were regular and Germans were Veteran (to take advantage of the optics). I only lost one Panther to a side hull hit at around 1900m froma T-34 as it was hunting forward and didn't spot the bastage.

In another smaller battle I played the Soviets versus a small, randomly purchased German AI defender who took two Tigers as his main punch. Both fell to T-34/85s at under 1000m. One with a front turret shot and the other to a side hull hit.

This whole optics thing is so new to me! I am still used to CMBO where its all fair at long ranges. Actually, when did we ever shoot over 1000m in CMBO? I never did.

The panther costs 321 points!!! How in the world does it cost that many points? In CMBO it cost 199 points for a regular crew. Was that a veteran panther at a early date where rarity plays into effect?

Stinks that the Panther is so much more expensive. Does anyone know if you can buy single tanks or if they have to come as a platoon? For a small 1000 point QB, you could never even dream of a platoon of Panthers!!!! Or even Mark IV for that matter.

Chad

Link to comment
Share on other sites

next one :)

Nashorn (146 points) vs IS 2 model 1944(283 points) (6 rounds per test, all units are cracks)

Test 1

500 meter Nashorn destroyed IS 2 model 1944 ok

500 meter Nashorn destroyed IS 2 model 1944 ok

500 meter Nashorn destroyed IS 2 model 1944 ok

Test 2

500 meter Nashorn destroyed IS 2 model 1944 ok

500 meter Nashorn destroyed IS 2 model 1944 ok

500 meter Nashorn destroyed IS 2 model 1944 1 wounded

Test 3

500 meter Nashorn destroyed IS 2 model 1944 1 wounded; gun damage

500 meter Nashorn destroyed IS 2 model 1944 destroyed

500 meter Nashorn destroyed IS 2 model 1944 ok

Test 1

1000 meter Nashorn destroyed IS 2 model 1944 ok

1000 meter Nashorn destroyed IS 2 model 1944 ok

1000 meter Nashorn ok IS 2 model 1944 destroyed

Test 2

1000 meter Nashorn destroyed IS 2 model 1944 destroyed

1000 meter Nashorn destroyed IS 2 model 1944 ok

1000 meter Nashorn ok IS 2 model 1944 destroyed

Test 3

1000 meter Nashorn destroyed IS 2 model 1944 ok

1000 meter Nashorn ok IS 2 model 1944 abandoned

1000 meter Nashorn ok IS 2 model 1944 abandoned

Test 1

1500 meter Nashorn ok IS 2 model 1944 abandoned

1500 meter Nashorn ok IS 2 model 1944 destroyed

1500 meter Nashorn ok IS 2 model 1944 abandoned

Test 2

1500 meter Nashorn ok IS 2 model 1944 destroyed

1500 meter Nashorn destroyed IS 2 model 1944 ok

1500 meter Nashorn destroyed IS 2 model 1944 ok

Test 3

1500 meter Nashorn ok IS 2 model 1944 destroyed

1500 meter Nashorn destroyed IS 2 model 1944 abandoned

1500 meter Nashorn destroyed IS 2 model 1944 ok

Test 1

2000 meter Nashorn unmoveable IS 2 model 1944 abandoned

2000 meter Nashorn destroyed IS 2 model 1944 ok

2000 meter Nashorn destroyed IS 2 model 1944 ok

Test 2

2000 meter Nashorn destroyed IS 2 model 1944 ok

2000 meter Nashorn ok IS 2 model 1944 destroyed

2000 meter Nashorn ok IS 2 model 1944 abandoned

Test 3

2000 meter Nashorn ok IS 2 model 1944 abandoned

2000 meter Nashorn ok IS 2 model 1944 abandoned

2000 meter Nashorn ok IS 2 model 1944 abandoned

Test 1

2500 meter Nashorn ok IS 2 model 1944 destroyed

2500 meter Nashorn 1 wounded IS 2 model 1944 abandoned

2500 meter Nashorn ok IS 2 model 1944 destroyed

Test 2

2500 meter Nashorn destroyed IS 2 model 1944 ok

2500 meter Nashorn ok IS 2 model 1944 abandoned

2500 meter Nashorn destroyed IS 2 model 1944 ok

Test 3

2500 meter Nashorn ok IS 2 model 1944 ok

2500 meter Nashorn destroyed IS 2 model 1944 1 wounded

2500 meter Nashorn ok IS 2 model 1944 destroyed

Test 1

3000 meter Nashorn ok IS 2 model 1944 destroyed

3000 meter Nashorn ok IS 2 model 1944 abandoned

3000 meter Nashorn destroyed IS 2 model 1944 1 wounded

Test 2

3000 meter Nashorn destroyed IS 2 model 1944 destroyed

3000 meter Nashorn ok IS 2 model 1944 destroyed

3000 meter Nashorn destroyed IS 2 model 1944 ok

Test 3

3000 meter Nashorn ok IS 2 model 1944 abandoned

3000 meter Nashorn ok IS 2 model 1944 destroyed

3000 meter Nashorn destroyed IS 2 model 1944 ok

Test 1

3500 meter Nashorn ok IS 2 model 1944 unmoveable

3500 meter Nashorn ok IS 2 model 1944 destroyed

3500 meter Nashorn destroyed IS 2 model 1944 ok

Test 2

3500 meter Nashorn ok IS 2 model 1944 1 wounded

3500 meter Nashorn destroyed IS 2 model 1944 ok

3500 meter Nashorn destroyed IS 2 model 1944 ok

Test 3

3500 meter Nashorn ok IS 2 model 1944 abandoned

3500 meter Nashorn destroyed IS 2 model 1944 ok

3500 meter Nashorn destroyed IS 2 model 1944 ok

Test 1

4000 meter Nashorn ok IS 2 model 1944 ok

4000 meter Nashorn ok IS 2 model 1944 abandoned

4000 meter Nashorn ok IS 2 model 1944 ok

Test 2

4000 meter Nashorn ok IS 2 model 1944 ok

4000 meter Nashorn ok IS 2 model 1944 1 wounded

4000 meter Nashorn ok IS 2 model 1944 ok

Test 3

4000 meter Nashorn ok IS 2 model 1944 1 wounded

4000 meter Nashorn ok IS 2 model 1944 ok

4000 meter Nashorn ok IS 2 model 1944 ok

[ September 23, 2002, 03:31 PM: Message edited by: JPSeiler ]

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Originally posted by Chad Harrison:

The panther costs 321 points!!! How in the world does it cost that many points? In CMBO it cost 199 points for a regular crew. Was that a veteran panther at a early date where rarity plays into effect?

Stinks that the Panther is so much more expensive. Does anyone know if you can buy single tanks or if they have to come as a platoon? For a small 1000 point QB, you could never even dream of a platoon of Panthers!!!! Or even Mark IV for that matter.

Chad

the Panther cost 321 point cause he wasnt regualr, i have the germane version

unerfahren unexpercianced ?

rekruten rekruts

regulär regular ;)

erfahren experirienced

hartgesotten hardsimmered(translated this one with babelfish :))

and for sure ELITE ;)

you dont have to buy platoons (züge)from tank to tank the platoon strenght is diffrent, example a platoon of Sturmtigers have 2 tanks a platoon of Tigers 4 tanks.

Here the platoon cost for a regualar Panther G(late) platoon:

tankleader 238

and 4 x 199

makes 1034 points total

one single regular Panther G (late) costs 238 points

Infantrie Battalion 42 costs 1472

Kompanie 433

and a single platoon 135

(all regualar)

You cant buy Panzerfäuste 60 ... they are just automatical assigne to the squads

but there are the Panzerjägertrupps (you seen in the demo) and panzerschrecks :)

regualar Panzerjäger cost 11 points

regualar Schreck 28 points

hope i didnt forget someones question ;)

and sorry for my bad english :-(

Greetings

Jean-Pierre

[ September 23, 2002, 12:35 PM: Message edited by: JPSeiler ]

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Im quite suprised of JS-2 long range accuracy.

I thought it wasnt that great. Test shows kills quite regularly up to 3500m.

How is maximum gunsight magnification in JS-2?

Nashorn has 10x max.

[ September 23, 2002, 12:34 PM: Message edited by: illo ]

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Panzer Boxb
Originally posted by JPSeiler:

By the way, heres a picture from my testing map, maybe someone want it than i can email it to you smile.gif

click here for image big picture of the whole map (2000 x 4000 meter = 597 x 1224 pixel)

Greetings

Jean-Pierre

Excellent looking firing range setup you made. I for one would be interested in receiving it. Or hosting it on a site for others to obtain.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

next one as requested smile.gif :

Tiger PzIVE (late) (296 points) vs ISU-152(207 points) (10 rounds per test, all units are cracks)

Test 1

500 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) destroyed ISU-152 destroyed

500 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) destroyed ISU-152 destroyed

500 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) abandoned ISU-152 ok

Test 2

500 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 abandoned

500 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 destroyed

500 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) abandoned ISU-152 destroyed

Test 3

500 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) abandoned ISU-152 unmoveable

500 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 destroyed

500 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) destroyed ISU-152 1 wounded

Test 1

1000 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 abandoned

1000 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) abandoned ISU-152 destroyed

1000 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 destroyed

Test 2

1000 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 destroyed

1000 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) abandoned ISU-152 ok

1000 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 destroyed

Test 3

1000 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) abandoned ISU-152 ok

1000 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) abandoned ISU-152 ok

1000 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) unmoveable ISU-152 destroyed

Test 1

1500 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) abandoned ISU-152 1 wounded

1500 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 abandoned

1500 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 abandoned

Test 2

1500 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 abandoned

1500 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 abandoned

1500 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 destroyed

Test 3

1500 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) destroyed ISU-152 ok

1500 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 abandoned

1500 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 destroyed

Test 1

2000 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) 1 wounded ISU-152 abandoned

2000 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 destroyed

2000 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 abandoned

Test 2

2000 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 abandoned

2000 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 abandoned

2000 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) abandoned ISU-152 ok

Test 3

2000 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 abandoned

2000 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 abandoned

2000 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 abandoned

Test 1

2500 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 abandoned

2500 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 abandoned

2500 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 abandoned

Test 2

2500 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 abandoned

2500 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) 1 wounded ISU-152 1 wounded

2500 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) gun damaged ISU-152 ok

Test 3

2500 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 abandoned

2500 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 abandoned

2500 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 1 wounded

Test 1

3000 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 abandoned

3000 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 abandoned

3000 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) destroyed ISU-152 ok

Test 2

3000 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 abandoned

3000 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 unmoveable

3000 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 abandoned

Test 3

3000 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 abandoned

3000 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 1 wounded; unmoveable

3000 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 ok

Test 1

3500 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 ok

3500 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 ok

3500 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) destroyed ISU-152 unmoveable

Test 2

3500 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 ok

3500 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 1 wounded

3500 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 unmoveable

Test 3

3500 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 1 wounded

3500 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 unmoveable

3500 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 ok

Test 1

4000 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 unmoveable

4000 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 ok

4000 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 unmoveable

Test 2

4000 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 unmoveable

4000 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 ok

4000 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 1 wounded

Test 3

4000 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 ok

4000 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 ok

4000 meter Tiger PzIVE (late) ok ISU-152 1 wounded

[ September 23, 2002, 03:33 PM: Message edited by: JPSeiler ]

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Panthers come at 230-240 points depending on version before rarity. A platoon of five will set you back by 1,009-1,039 points.

The German unit experience ratings are:

Rekruten = Recruits

Unerfahren = Green

Regulaer = Regular

Erfahren = Veteran

Hartgesotten = Crack (that is what was translated as hardsimmered)

Elite = Elite

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Originally posted by Andreas:

Panthers come at 230-240 points depending on version before rarity. A platoon of five will set you back by 1,009-1,039 points.

The German unit experience ratings are:

Rekruten = Recruits

Unerfahren = Green

Regulaer = Regular

Erfahren = Veteran

Hartgesotten = Crack (that is what was translated as hardsimmered)

Elite = Elite

thank you andreas smile.gif
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Originally posted by Dressler:

Hartgesotten would roughly translate to "hardboiled" or "hardcore" in English.

thank you smile.gif

In your tests, when you say "left" does that mean the crew bailed out and abandoned the vehicle?

thats correct, thinked its interesting for opperations to know ... ;)
Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...