Balanced scenarios list from the Blitz ladder (CMBB)

[pocketrocket]

Here is a list of scenarios wich have been played at least 5 times and have a balance of no more than 43-57% wins for a particular side.

Note: I have designated the number of wins for each side as G: R: . However on many of those listed below these numbers may be the worng way round. Sorry I am tard when it comes to these sort of things and had to edit this list in hand in note pad.

Hope some of you may find this usefull:

Armor on the Boulevard CMBB G10 R7 D3 57% P20 E7.33

Road to Moscow CMBB G10 R7 D3 57% p20 E7.90

Morning at the Zoo CMBB G17 R12 D6 57% p35 E7.28

The Road to Straszov V2 CMBB G4 R3 D1 56% p8 E9.25

Early Wittmann G11 R8 D6 56% p25 E7.39

Izyium Diet Plan CMBB G21 R15 D20 55% p56 E7.53

Marxdorf CMBB G7 R5 D9 55% p21 E6.92

SS Strikes, Kalinin FrontCMBB G5 R4 D4 54% p13 E8.29

A Second Chance CMBB G11 R10 52% p21 E6.24

Suburbs of Leningrad CMBB G3 R3 50% p6 E7.83

Where Forefathers FoughtCMBB G3 R3 D2 50% p8 E7.50

ROWIII The Beast CMBB G3 R3 50% p6 E6.50

Race for Polzny Bridge CMBB G4 R4 50% p8 E8.00

The Sideshow CMBB G2 R2 D1 50% p5 E7.50

GD410705 Assault on KamienkaCMBB G2 R2 D2 50% p6 E6.50

Defense of Verkhne-Golubaya CMBB G3 R3 D1 50% p7 E7.50

SP Our Backs to the Volga CMBB G7 R7 D6 50% p20 E9.00

ROWIII Hosszupalyi CMBB G3 R3 50% P6 E7.71

B&T King of Debrecen CMBB G2 R2 D1 50% p5 E7.75

B&T Clash of the Titans II CMBB G6 R7 D14 48% p27 E8.42

B&T Sword of Bagration CMBB G9 R8 D10 48% p27 E7.80

Korsun Relief CMBB G8 R10 D7 46% p25 E5.76

Hornet's Nest CMBB G5 R4 D3 46% p12 E6.80

Manstein Cometh CMBB G8 R10 D4 45% p22 E7.8

(FGM) Ostfront Tiger CMBB G3 R2 D2 43% p7 E6.75

According to this list the most balanced and most fun (as voted for by you the public) is SP Our Backs to the Volga

[Kingfish]

Good to see Capdog's classic is still getting rave reviews. I remember testing it with Jeff smith back in the day, and I rate that as the best CMBB PBEM game I ever played.

[Col Deadmarsh]

And where might one get these battles?

[Kingfish]

Izyium Diet Plan, Early Wittman and anything that begins with ROW III, SP or B&T can be found here

[Holien]

ROWIII The Beast CMBB G3 R3 50% p6 E6.50

A stunning game.

I really enjoyed this one.

H

And if my memory serves me well "Our Backs to the Volga" is another stunning game but requires a decent PC to handle the size of it and the Smoke...

[Holien]

http://www.battlefront.com/cgi-bin/bbs/ultimatebb.cgi?ubb=get_topic;f=6;t=002676;p=1&r=actu

There was some debate a year or so ago about the balance of this game.

I guess time has proved it to be balanced.

H

[Kingfish]

Interesting little aside about 'Our backs to the Volga' and 'The Beast'. In both cases neither designer - Capdog and Harv - had any experience with scenario design, yet they both produced these two gems. In fact, I still remember several of us chatting on line at CMHQ, trying to convince Harv to add a scenario for ROW III. He was reluctant, but we eventually won him over.

[Holien]

Just goes to show everyone has one good design in them at least.

Bit like a book.

Mind you some people have many great designs.

H