Jump to content

Soddball

Members
  • Posts

    3,497
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Soddball

  1. I have seen a number of occasions where routed enemy infantry fleeing back to their own lines have run across a minefield out of LOS to me. At that point the minefield has become visible, even though I had no LOS to it and no way of knowing it was there. I had to ask my opponent why I could see a minefield and he told me a routed squad had just fled across it.

  2. Originally posted by Peter Cairns:

    Rail infrastructure in europe in the 30's and 40's was pretty primative by todays standards and indeed all infrastructure was.

    Really? Would you honestly say that the British rail systems of the 1930s and 1940s were primitive compared to today?

    I hardly think so.

  3. Originally posted by Philippe:

    And railroad tracks should almost always come in pairs, except on trunk lines to a factory or warehouse.

    Not true. There are lots of single-track railway lines. Most of the ones in the UK were closed by the Evil Dr. Beeching but they are not uncommon. Major inter-city lines would have 2 tracks.
  4. Originally posted by MartinEden:

    I'm of the opinion that if no one else had anything to say on the matter, people would stop posting. Seems as if this is more a matter of what wants to be heard rather than what wants to be said. Sure is easy to see this forum is in the U.K. and not the U.S. ;)

    KG_Soldier

    So, now you know it's a US-based forum, run by a US company, how stupid do you feel?
  5. Originally posted by dalem:

    Here in my local historical miniatures gaming group, a guy who used to be in the Canadian military runs occasional "Map Games" for us using the online Kriegspiel rules. I've talked about it before. I've played the role of a divisional commander a few times and I'm told that the games we run are similar in feel and scope to the paper exercises real militaries sometimes do.

    And as the divisional commander, I have a map and a dream, and that's IT. smile.gif I give my orders to the guys representing my regimental commanders, and I get support for them from corps and other parts of the division. But do I order COMPANIES around the map? Of course not. I don't even have anything to represent units that small on the map anyway.

    So the idea of a battalion commander pushing bazooka and MG teams around the map seems equally silly to me.

    -dale

    You clearly aren't playing the 'Hitler' rules, which allow you to know in an instant the strength of the enemy and to place individual companies in the correct location. smile.gif
  6. Originally posted by Sergei:

    </font><blockquote>quote:</font><hr />Originally posted by Soddball:

    </font><blockquote>quote:</font><hr />Originally posted by Sergei:

    Bah! Company level is for wimps, battalion level for amateurs... Regiment scale is where IT is in! :D

    I have just the campaign for you. Divisional scale. </font>
  7. UK carriers had all-metal flightdecks and most were converted from battleship or battlecruiser hulls, hence their impressive resilience. Think of the kamikaze attacks on them in 1945. US carrier hit - flight deck out of operation, hangar on fire. UK carrier hit - one ensign with a broom required to sweep deck clean.

    Of course, that meant they held 1/3 the number of planes of US carriers and time has shown that the US system was superior.

  8. Originally posted by flamingknives:

    Firing ports are a bad idea anyway unless you're fighting through fall-out. In conventional warfare, infantry really ought to dismount to fight.

    There were a pair of BMP-1s at the War and Peace Show.

    Every time I looked at them, all I could think they were good for was shooting rioting civilians. Stupid design. Can't hold enough soldiers to make any difference, crap armour against anything but molotov coctails.

×
×
  • Create New...