Jump to content

DLaurier

Members
  • Posts

    324
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by DLaurier

  1. The Panther was complex, complicated, expensive, and finiky.

    It was mechanicaly unreliable, and prone to breakdown.

    It required a huge logistics train.

    It was severely underpowered, and overweight.

    It was very expensive to produce.

    It was an excellent long range tank killer. Ideal for defence across open steppes... but could not be swung around and rushed to another sector without railway support.

    It was an engineering marvel, but far too specialized to be a good tank.

    The M4 Sherman was a simple and reliable, general purpose tank.

    It was better than adequate in every role. (ie: fair to good/very good)

    It was easy to repair and maintain.

    It was also cheap to build.

    It could (and did) cross europe under it's own power. Something no Panther could do.

    The Sherman was an excellent tank by virtue of it not being excellent in any one area, but fair to good in most, and very good in a few.

    It was a go-anywhere-do-anything tank.

  2. But, before anyone rushes that Kubelwagen forward, please think of the little pixelfrauen and pixelkinder. :'-(

    this.

    In the CMx1 games, I tended to treat my units as real people.

    You give me a German company, and I guarantee you I will give my units lives outside the game.

    Hauptman Krebs is a secret anti-nazi conspirator who regularly corresponds with his old prewar CO Klaus Staufenberg. (yeah, that one)

    Lt Bekker is fresh out of the accademy, and he worries constantly about how he can earn the respect of his platoon.

    Sgt Wolk is an old veteran who cares for his troops like they were his children.

    etc etc etc.

    Once I get this game, I expect I'll be doing the same thing.

  3. A while back we had a Racist,anti semite on this forum.I think he got the boot by BFC.I kinda wish he was around now,would make for some interesting replies to this thread.I had several arguments with him and he was so simple minded and backwards in his way of thinking it was hilarious,in a sad sort of way.I even had a long PM argument going with him.I miss him,he made things interested.:D

    I could try to fill in... I might need a bit of help though

    "BAW!! Den durned nig nogs iz infeareur to mi BAWWWWW!!!!!!!!"

    Was that good?

    Did it sound convincing?

  4. Don't forget the Sicily offensive causing a premature end, not the massive, planned Soviet counter operation to the North. Before I derail my own thread and lead a blood trail for the 'they had the best tanks/uniforms/tactical doctrine/LMGs they should have/could have won' brigade, I will now remain silent until I/someone else actually reads the book and comments on its findings.

    Aragorn, oh yes myths are impossible to kill because they appeal to the heart, not the head, speak of hopes not facts and yet often contain grains of truth.

    They had the best bondage gear!!! They should have won!!! BAWWWW!!!

  5. There are swings, and there are roundabouts. Your open top M10 is also more vulnerable to small arms, and if that goes, so does your best AT weapon. If I lose the Priest, I've still got 3 HE chuckers, and that'll probably do. And I'm more confident in my ability to keep the Priest unmolested by random small arms than I am a hunting M10.

    It's not the priest I'm worried about... it's the choirboys.

  6. The CM titles have always attracted two type of player. Those who want to *WIN!* (all caps with an exclamation point), and those who want to *experience*. The experiencers want to be placed into 1944 Normandy. Not just 1944 Normandy but 11 June 1944 exactlly 1km northeast of Carentan at two oclock in the afternoon. whether or not they win the battle hardly matters. The others want to WIN! preferably on a mirrored map against carefully balanced forces without any pesky acts of God intervening in the battle. :D

    I'm in both camps. but in the same subset of those camps. I want to win, as the side that lost... on 11 June 1944 exactlly 1km northeast of Carentan at two oclock in the afternoon.

    I HATE mirrored maps with perfectly balanced forces.

    You know that German officer cadet who fell and broke his back on a training exercise on May 2nd 1944, just days before recieving his commision?

    Yeah.

  7. If you pay off your balance in full every month the card shouldn't cost you anything, other than what it costs to buy stuff that you couldn't buy because you didn't have a credit card.

    I know... I just have moral and ethical issues with the whole culture of credit and debt. I've spent years raging against it, and now find myself unable to avoid becoming part of it.

  8. Someone posted earlier that our European brothers don't use Credit/debit cards nearly as much as we do. That may be the issue here. I admit I thought everyone had easy access to plastic now-a-days. Everyone here can get pre-paid cards at nearly any major grocery store.

    At 44 years of age, I still deal in cash.

    I've never had a credit card in my life, and whenever I've ordered something it's always been either COD or purchase via money order.

    Certainly I would send a money order to Battlefront Co Inc.

    Yes I still use a rotary dial phone.

  9. The M3 Stuart is well armored for a light tank.

    The Panzer II is a stop gap vehicle that was never meant to engage serious opposition. It's 20 mm gun is weak compared to most tank guns.

    The M3 has the 37 mm gun. A much more powerfull weapon against tanks.

    It will eat Pz IIs for breakfast

    A single Pz III with infantry support would have served you better.

×
×
  • Create New...