Jump to content
Battlefront is now Slitherine ×

Aragorn2002

Members
  • Posts

    6,324
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    13

Posts posted by Aragorn2002

  1. Originally posted by JasonC:

    Don't give me 48 kinds of rare and largely useless vehicles and mixed guns. Learn a little history and use realistic force composition, with plenty of one type only. A few of another type is occasionally realistic, more than that and you are in Hollywood, not on the eastern front.

    Yes, I normally remove scenarios like that immediately, unless the map is well made and can be re-used. To my experience scenarios like that are usually unplayable and unbalanced. I like big battles like George MC's Blowtorch-series, but also smaller ones like Panther Commanders KC-series. I also prefer scenarios with a historical accurate subject and details, not some crazy fantasy, like attacking a Gestapo HQ full of Nazi officials or other nonsense. Scenarios with a short or superficial briefing are also something I don't like. I also hate scenarios where the different units are mixed in a way that overview is nearly impossible.

    I do like big, well-made maps, because I can use them to make my own battle, using lots of units, just for the sake of seeing it. It gives me a certain sense of being there. I know it isn't entirely fair on the scenario makers, but of course I wouldn't dream of doing something else with them than using them for my own pleasure/study. For gaming they are less suited sometimes (there are exceptions like George MC's masterpieces and recently Federoff's Wilkowitschken). For fast and intense gaming battles like Panther Commanders KC Lt Neumeyer are my favorite. But lots of talented scenario makers are around and make these games so special.

  2. Originally posted by Erik Springelkamp:

    When we come down to 'decent' I would like to add Maurits of Oranje-Nassau and his brother Willem Frederik, for their 'scientific' operations and the first steps towards the introduction of fire-based linear infantry tactics, resulting in the establishment of a stable new republic in Europe.

    Oranje boven, Erik! ;)

    Actually, after reading 'The Great Siege, Malta 1565', by Ernle Bradford, my choice for greatest commander would be Grand Master Jean Parisot De La Valetta of the order of St. John, whose gallant defence of Malta prevented a Turkish invasion of Sicily and Italy and possibly even Turkish domination of Western Europe.

    [ December 03, 2005, 06:34 AM: Message edited by: Aragorn2002 ]

×
×
  • Create New...