I just finished the Carentan campaign as the Germans.
Allied losses: 1239 cas. (641 KIA), 6 captured, 10 mortars, 67 vehicles
Men OK: 34
German losses: 321 (164 KIA), 6 guns, 43 vehicles.
Men OK: 409
Add to that the fact that as the defender, I controlled more ground than I had at the start of the game...
Tell me why I didn't win!