Rommel Posted July 4, 2000 Posted July 4, 2000 Was my understanding that tanks could go through the bocage but no other units. Is this wrong, if it isn't how do you get them to do it? maybe i'm thinking about brush or something like that.
Lorak Posted July 4, 2000 Posted July 4, 2000 Rommel, allied tanks can go thru bocage. They were fitted with gear that would allow it. German tanks lack this attachment and therefore can not go thru bocage. Lorak ------------------ http://clubs.yahoo.com/clubs/combatmissionclub Lorak's FTX for CM <--Proud member of the Combat Mission Webring
Guest Michael emrys Posted July 4, 2000 Posted July 4, 2000 Since I haven't tried this yet, I have a question. Once a tank with Rhino has penetrated a bocage tile, can other units move through that tile freely, including other vehicular units? BTW, IIRC according to the accounts I've read it wasn't that German tanks couldn't cross bocage, it was that they exposed their thinly armored bellies as they went up and over. Same was true of American tanks before Rhino (Did the Brits ever use it? I can't remember.) Michael
Guest Germanboy Posted July 4, 2000 Posted July 4, 2000 And most of this has been answered time and again before, pointers to be found in the 'Rhinos and Bocage' thread, currently on page two of this forum. Don't think the Commonwealth used them. Andreas (junior member of Jason and the Searchonauts)
guachi Posted July 4, 2000 Posted July 4, 2000 http://www.battlefront.com/discuss/Forum1/HTML/000388.html and http://www.battlefront.com/discuss/Forum1/HTML/001786.html are just two examples Jason [This message has been edited by guachi (edited 07-04-2000).]
Guest Michael emrys Posted July 5, 2000 Posted July 5, 2000 Look. Why not just give me a simple yes or no. That would take you less time than it takes me to go through a *very* lengthy discussion only to discover that my question isn't answered at all: Can other units, including vehicles pass through gaps created by Rhino tanks? Jeez. Michael
Maastrictian Posted July 5, 2000 Posted July 5, 2000 Michael -- I don't think there is any need to be rude. To answer your question, there is no CC style gap left in bocage. --Chris
Guest Michael emrys Posted July 5, 2000 Posted July 5, 2000 Chris, I thank you for the courtesy of your reply. although I have never played CC and am not familiar with how they treat the subject, I think I know what you intend to say. I thought from my reading on the subject that the gaps in the hedges opened by Rhino tanks could be utilized by other vehicles, but perhaps more research is indicated. On the other matter, I think it is extremely rude behavior, bordering on contempt, to give someone the runaround when they have asked a simple and direct question. I was not seeking a reopening of the whole discusion on Rhino tanks and all their ramifications. And I certainly wasn't looking to spend a diverting hour in the archive. Given that, my response to an infuriating lack of consideration was mild indeed. I used no abusive language and never called into question either the poster's intelligence or parentage. You might take that into consideration the next time you feel the urge to mind my manners. Michael
Recommended Posts