Jump to content

smoke hand grenades, yes or no?


Recommended Posts

Actually, Markus Hofbauer who is a member of the forum and reads this regularly is the author of that site. It is an excellent one indeed.

------------------

___________

Fionn Kelly

Manager of Historical Research,

The Gamers Net - Gaming for Gamers

Link to comment
Share on other sites

We are collecting/ammassing info on infantry smoke grenades usage, though don't hold your breath for now. Markus (and Tommi) have been very helpful. I have ammassed a lot of stuff too. In fact smoke grenades is another of those underreported, unclear aspects of WW2 micro-history that make being a military historian/afficitiando so much fun.

One thing is clear at least on the US side, while any given vet may have seen smoke grenades used in masking situations at somepoint during his combat experience, it was not employed at the same level as they are today, meaning you could not give a smoke grenade capability to every squad in CM and get a historically accurate outcome.

It's definately something that will have to be looked at in the future to determine how to make the means (effort to model this accurately) justify the end result.

There are other more deliberate means of smoke generation available to the player as it is, so you won't be lefting wanting for the capability. Hope that helps...

Los

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Big Time Software

Also remember that production figures include items used in training, lost at the bottom of the sea, stuck in a warehouse, blown up in a rail car, "misplaced", stuck off in rear areas, issued to backwaters (like Norway), etc. Training alone would consume a HUGE number of whatever expendable thing we are talking about. Who knows how to calculate this stuff, but just to give you some idea...

Depending on the source you cite, something like 425k Sturmgewehr 44 (MP44) were made. Most sources state that fully TWO thirds were never issued because of transportation problems. TWO THIRDS!! And this was a critical piece of hardware for the hardpressed, and undertrained, troops in the last days of the war.

Lesson here is that production figures themselves don't mean much wink.gif

Steve

Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...