TBH the differences between German and American units by 1944 could probably be considered academic. Both Armies had a fond appreciation of the importance of good NCOs, flexible leadership, and arming as many men in the squad with as many rapid fire weapons as possible.
In short it basically should be a coin toss barring other factors. We're looking at two well trained, well equipped, modern Western Armies. Ze Germans weren't magic super soldiers and the Americans weren't scrappy underdogs.