Jump to content

Nupremal

Members
  • Posts

    701
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Nupremal

  1. I just could not find it in the manual - also the air value matters because a level 4 advanced air carrier would be 4 air attack - but that makes sense what you say.

    Reason I am asking is, since I need to use PDE for my world campaign, I want to boost the abilities of carriers, or at least Japanese and US carriers, as their naval attack cannot increase with tech. The BB has an advantage, but the BB can only attack if it is next to the carrier, which can attack at range. I am also considering giving carriers 2 strikes.

    Any ideas anyone has are welcome.

  2. I saw the science doc - let me be more specific.

    A Carrier attacks a BB - what does it use, Naval Attack? Then what does the BB use? Naval Defense or Carrier Defense? Then what about the reverse. How about when a Fighter intercepts? Is it Carrier Attack vs Air Defense (Fighter attacking) and then Air Attack vs Carrier Defense (Carrier Attack)?

    Are there 2 calcs - attacker vs defender + defender vs attacker - simultaneous?

    I don't care about the other various factors - I just want to know what the "sequence" is - without any modifiers. I can account for those later.

  3. I am confused about when an Attack Value interacts with a defense value and have not seen any explanation.

    Examples - An Infantry attacks a tank - does this mean it uses Tank Attack vs. Soft Defense? Does the Tank fire back at Soft attack vs Tank Defense?

    What about the really confusing Carriers? How do Air, Carrier, and Naval Attack and Defense interact? I have no idea. Is it a single attack followed by a simultaneous defense? - or 2 actions - or is it 1 action, attack vs defense - I dont see how it can be 1 action or some stats would not apply. Is there some explanation I missed?

  4. I am having somewhat of a problem with the whole issue of connected cities, since it has to be the capital of a major, this puts for example the UK at an unreasonable disadvantage, since say India, AUS or SAF or even Canada (until the US joins) will be disconnected. However, can minor units be built in their HOME country if they are connected to their own capital? I have a feeling the answer is No, which means scripting is the only way - which is unfortunate. I also don't think this is something that can be modded, right?

  5. sounds good for the future. I actually think I can deal with fewer minors. Many are not important anyway and can just be added as part of other counrties anyway, like the various Commonwealth Nations can all be included w/UK and their values can be activated at certain times. I am considering not having Japan join until they actually got involved with more than China. Before that, not a lot changed in China (between 9/39 and 12/41) either way.

  6. Are you asking me? I will post it there at some point I am not sure I want to only very partially done.

    I also determined that Italy will have to be a minor instead of France. I need the Allies to have Paris so they can connect their cities since you can't make a connection by sea. Italy stays connected to Berlin so other than the fact that they won't have their own research and diplomacy, which is not a huge deal, and their units won't have their own symbols, it should not matter all that much. I will kind of miss their own symbols for units. Unless someone has some other solution they can think of.

    I will then make Italian upgrades like most of the minors cost +100% to keep them limited.

  7. I am obsessed with global campaigns - spent years making my own for PG II - played it but building took as much if not more time. Basically w/that all the strategic parts were handled outside of the game, and the battles were then zoomed into for PG II play custom made for components of each battle - that was more work.

    The map is gonna take a long time anyway... but good news is I was in error on Pacific it will still have 6 majors so this will be ported to that before it is finished.

×
×
  • Create New...