Well, my non-steel steelbox experience has been good.
It wasn't I, but a friend who opened the mail package, and although yes, the box did suffer damage, it still impressed my friend a great deal, who thought it very pretty indeed.
I thought it was nothing too special, but I'm a cynical bitch and I've been spoiled by Flight Simulator 2004's, I think it was, or CFS3, I don't remember. That was a pretty cool full real metal metalbox. Solid, sturdy.
Anyway, the box is pretty indeed, my friend approves of it, and I approve of its look. Very nice. Sadly, there's no promotional accompanying mouse pad. Dude, where's my mouse pad? CMSF's is getting worn out...
Also good was the lucky sneaky passage of the package through customs, without eliciting import fees. WHERE'S YOUR GOVERNMENT NOW?! I'm glad this place isn't as efficient as IngSoc.
So, ok, cool, nice box.
The sepia over sepian-gray manual wasn't the best of choices, but it's also not as bad as it looks on the PDF. It's easier to read than the PDF IMO actually. Still, please don't go artsy in manuals, at least not on the important bits, i.e. the main text.
On the bad side, the box got damaged both in the front and back. The front damage was very slight, a minor depression near the top. The rear damage was deeper and more pronounced, actually extending to open a crack along the height of the inner plastic body from top to bottom, near the top inner corner of the box. Meh. I'm not a collector and didn't buy this for the box; the game mostly works, so we're still in business.