Sam,
That was outstanding! It nailed it entirely. One thing I'd like to add is skill selection. The reason so many people get into trouble in the "middle" game (where the planes and pilots really start to get good) is that the AI will punish you for earlier errors. If you've made bad choices about skills, it will come back to haunt you now. I really admire people who pick Aggressive or Stay With Him! instead of Evasive or Shake Him Off! The first two skills are going to be difficult to survive with in the middle game, but the later two are crucial, IMHO. If you look at Sixxkiller's skill set, you have to admire how he has got his pilots to such high levels with such offensive-minded skills. In order to get to the high levels like that, Sixx rode a very narrow and much more dangerous line than I did with my defensive skills. If you look at Black Mamba's medals, she's flown a ton of unscathed missions where she never took a point of damage. That's because of my (The Bride's) skill selection. Offensive skills are great for killing, but they make you more vulnerable to getting shot down. On the other hand, Sixx will tell you the best defense is killing the other guy!
Consider the *order* you purchase your skills too. I plan out the 10 skills I want to eventually have, then purchase them in decreasing order of cost. This is due to the fact the skills get exponentially more expensive. If you ever want to have my favorite skill, Quick Reflexes, you really must bite the bullet and save for it to be one of the first three skills you buy because it gets outrageously expensive. Delay that gratification!
Another angle is mission selection and parameters. Black Mamba flew probably 75% dogfight missions where it was 1v1. Flying escorts or 2v2's just puts that much more risk into the system. For this reason, I very much admire Stalin's O for his ability to consitently fly escort missions and kill all 4 opposing enemies over and over. Again - risky, but revealing how skilled the guys who can do it and get away with it.
It's not a game of luck! There's so much depth to it. Man, I am so addicted!
[ June 09, 2006, 07:06 PM: Message edited by: Inigo Montoya ]