Doug Williams

As witty and amusing as this thread has become, and though I doubt I will ever tire of seeing Childress's effeminate avatar, I would cast my vote for some sort of melee combat simulation in Combat Mission, even it it is via casualties only...no animations needed. Some things CM1 did better.

You want something like this:

 
Quote: 'A right thumb in the eye is more dependable'
 
The number of casualties from hand-to-hand combat in WW2 were microscopic. A good idnicator: by 1944 German rifles were being produced without bayonet lugs.