This arguement is still going on?
My opinion: This game is ok. It's no Combat Missions. Something to mess with between PBEMs and CMSF's release.
Negative-
-Feels awkward, clunky, men dont follow my orders to a degree i expect(dont hold ground, etc)
-too much baby sitting for real time, switching ammo on 5 tanks, trying to get my men to use grenades, pause button is nice but i dont see how it will be possible to play multiplayer
-relativly small amount of units in battles
-terrian: its ugly, and it is not apparent to me it has any effect on my units ability to hide/take cover (sometimes my tank can shoot through 5 rows of bushes, sometimes only 1)
Positive-
-tanks look very nice, expecially when pieces come off
-the whole exp. system makes for interesting campaigns and unit management, more reason to keep your men alive
Well, those are my thoughts. This game has had a long and troubled developement, most of the time not in the hands of Battlefront, i dont think you can blame them, they did what they could with what they had. Cant wait for CMSF.