Jump to content

Stalin's Organ

Members
  • Posts

    1,419
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Stalin's Organ

  1. Err...Blitzkreig wasn't an early development of combined arms doctrine - armour, in fantry, artillery and air power had all been successfully combined in the last year of WW1. Obviously there were differnt limits, but that's notreally relevant.

    What Blitzkreig was was the application of mobility and firepower to a different type of warfare - the fast moving, penetration type we all know of now.

    Also I'd siggest that hte Pz IV was NOT designed as a heavy tank - it was a close support tank providing heavier artillery support than the current medium tank (PzIII with 37mm) could provide. Almost every nation had the same type of tank.

    When upgunning became necessary the Pz4 was used because it's turret ring was big enough to accomodate the increased forces. The smaller tanks (of all nations) couldn't manage this.

  2. Thanks for the reply user, but I think you miss the point.

    A bunker IMO is not a "soft" target, and AP is appropriate to use agaisnt it.

    Currently in CMBO a tank gun that has run out of HE can sometimes use AP against infantry - and occasionally scores a kill, presumably some poor chap with a 3" hole through him from a direct hit.

    My question is whether the small HE filler in APHE hakes it more useful vs infantry than straight AP shot?

  3. Check out:

    http://history.vif2.ru/guns/project_1.html

    According to this table the 3 of the 85mm gun AP rounds had characteristics:

    5 Warhead with a sharp tip;

    6 Blunt warhead with a ballistic cap;

    7 Warhead of improved armor penetration

    Obviously the one footnoted 6 has a ballistic cap. I suspect 5 = AP shot, 6 = APCBC and 7 = APC, but I can't swear to it.

    Can't answer the other questions sorry, except to note that I didn'tthink the Germans used any AP shot for the 88 - it was all APC or APCBC?

  4. Yes there was a smoke round for the 150mm rocket - 15cm Wurtgranate 41 w Kh Nebel.

    Don't know if there was one for the 21 & 30cm launchers or not, but the 28/32cm launcer did NOT have one.

    FWIW a previous poster noted that the original Nebelwerfer was a mortar - it was a very complicated 10cm affair intended to throw smoke as its main role. It turned into a very useful HE weapon with a range of over 6000m. However it was extremely expensive to make - more a light artillery piece at RM14,000 as opposed to RM 1500 for a more conventional 10cm mortar.

×
×
  • Create New...