Bigdog Posted March 9, 2002 Share Posted March 9, 2002 These are the Top Ten Scenarios with more than 3 reviews 3/1/02 We would like to welcome Eric Martucci 's "Greif" to the Dog House # -Scenario Number Of Reviews Score Number of Weeks in the Dog House - Place Last Week Author 1-Fertile Fields 14 Reviews 9.42 18th Week - 1st Place Clubfoot 2-Where Eagles Dare 3 Reviews 9.27 8th Week - 2ndPlace William (Goanna) Thiel 3-The Wrong Hill 10 Reviews 9.21 10th Week - 2nd Place Wild Bill Wilder 4- Cintheaux - Totalize 4 Reviews 9.08 4th Week - 4th Place Helge "The Desert Fox" Bertram 5- Greif *(special note below)* 3 Reviews 9.07 ***NEW*** Eric Martucci 6- Welcome to My Neighborhood 4 Reviews 8.90 10th Week - 5th Place Jeff Weatherspoon 7- Blowfish 11 Reviews 8.89 18th Week - 6th Place Clubfoot 8- Foothills 3 Reviews 8.87 4th Week - 7th Place Tim "Rune" Orosz 9- ROW - Duel at Dompaire 3 Reviews 8.77 2nd Week - 8th Place Wild Bill Wilder 10-To The Last Man 16 Reviews 8.76 28th Week - 9th Place Andreas "Germanboy" Biermann Special note on the scenario Greif. I am allowing Greif into the Dog House even though there are mutable reviews by the same reviewer. The Scenario was reworked and the reviewer wanted to note his approval the changes. I would like to suggest that instead of complete score updating, just up grade the category that the rework was done and leave the other categories at 0. As in, if there was improvement in the map and you gave a 7 score & upon review you think it should be 9, just score it 10 and leave other fields at 0, this update the average score of the map without overly boosting the average score. I think this the best way to do an addendum to your review. Be sure to check out Big Dogs No Way Around screen shots available on its page (ShamelessPlug) No Way Around [ March 09, 2002, 09:03 PM: Message edited by: Bigdog ] Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Bigdog Posted March 10, 2002 Author Share Posted March 10, 2002 These are the Top Ten Scenarios with more than 3 reviews 3/9/02 *** Revised 3/10/02 *** We would like to welcome Eric Martucci 's "Greif" & Juan Ramon Lopez Letamendi's "Berlin - Get the Reichstag! " to the Dog House # -Scenario Number Of Reviews Score Number of Weeks in the Dog House - Place Last Week Author 1-Fertile Fields 14 Reviews 9.42 18th Week - 1st Place Clubfoot 2- Berlin - Get the Reichstag! 3 Reviews 9.31 ***NEW*** Juan Ramon Lopez Letamendi 3-Where Eagles Dare 3 Reviews 9.27 8th Week - 2ndPlace William (Goanna) Thiel 4-The Wrong Hill 10 Reviews 9.21 10th Week - 2nd Place Wild Bill Wilder 5- Cintheaux - Totalize 4 Reviews 9.08 4th Week - 4th Place Helge "The Desert Fox" Bertram 6- Greif *(specal note below)* 3 Reviews 9.07 ***NEW*** Eric Martucci 7- Welcome to My Neighborhood 4 Reviews 8.90 10th Week - 5th Place Jeff Weatherspoon 8- Blowfish 11 Reviews 8.89 18th Week - 6th Place Clubfoot 9- Foothills 3 Reviews 8.87 4th Week - 7th Place Tim "Rune" Orosz 10-To The Last Man 17 Reviews 8.78 28th Week - 9th Place Andreas "Germanboy" Biermann Special note on the scenario Greif. I am allowing Greif into the Dog House even though there are mutable reviews by the same reviewer. The Scenario was reworked and the reviewer wanted to note his approval the changes. I would like to suggest that instead of complete score updating, just up grade the category that the rework was done and leave the other categories at 0. As in, if there was improvement in the map and you gave a 7 score & upon review you think it should be 9, just score it 10 and leave other fields at 0, this update the average score of the map without overly boosting the average score. I think this the best way to do an addendum to your review. Be sure to check out Big Dogs No Way Around screen shots available on its page (ShamelessPlug) Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Bigdog Posted March 13, 2002 Author Share Posted March 13, 2002 These are the Top Ten Scenarios with more than 3 reviews 3/9/02 *** Revised 3/12/02 *** We would like to welcome Eric Martucci 's "Greif", Juan Ramon Lopez Letamendi's "Berlin - Get the Reichstag! " & Clubfoot's "Hastings' Howards" to the Dog House Unfortunately we must say goodbye to Andreas "Germanboy" Biermann's "To The Last Man" after 28 weeks in the Dog House, 17 reviews & a score of 8.78. It has never been knocked off my top 10 list since it's start 8/20/01. No other scenario has ben reviewed so often without its score not dipping. We are sure that Andreas will return to the Dog House soon. <<<SALUTE>>> # -Scenario Number Of Reviews Score Number of Weeks in the Dog House - Place Last Week Author 1-Fertile Fields 14 Reviews 9.42 18th Week - 1st Place Clubfoot 2- Berlin - Get the Reichstag! 3 Reviews 9.31 ***NEW*** Juan Ramon Lopez Letamendi 3-Where Eagles Dare 3 Reviews 9.27 8th Week - 2ndPlace William (Goanna) Thiel 4- Hastings' Howards 4 Reviews 9.20 ***NEW*** Clubfoot 5-The Wrong Hill 12 Reviews 9.13 10th Week - 2nd Place Wild Bill Wilder 6- Cintheaux - Totalize 4 Reviews 9.08 4th Week - 4th Place Helge "The Desert Fox" Bertram 7- Greif *(specal note below)* 3 Reviews 9.07 ***NEW*** Eric Martucci 8- Blowfish 11 Reviews 8.89 18th Week - 6th Place Clubfoot 9t- Welcome to My Neighborhood 5 Reviews 8.87 10th Week - 5th Place Jeff Weatherspoon 9t- Foothills 3 Reviews 8.87 4th Week - 7th Place Tim "Rune" Orosz Special note on the scenario Greif. I am allowing Greif into the Dog House even though there are mutable reviews by the same reviewer. The Scenario was reworked and the reviewer wanted to note his approval the changes. I would like to suggest that instead of complete score updating, just up grade the category that the rework was done and leave the other categories at 0. As in, if there was improvement in the map and you gave a 7 score & upon review you think it should be 9, just score it 10 and leave other fields at 0, this update the average score of the map without overly boosting the average score. I think this the best way to do an addendum to your review. Be sure to check out Big Dogs No Way Around screen shots available on its page (ShamelessPlug) [ March 14, 2002, 12:41 AM: Message edited by: Bigdog ] Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts