Jump to content

Sir Uber General

Members
  • Posts

    200
  • Joined

  • Last visited

    Never

Posts posted by Sir Uber General

  1. "What is even more puzzling though is that even using the figures in the game a Sherman should not be able to knock out a Panther with a front shot except for the occasional weak point (which seems to happen more often than it should)."

    I'm afraid you are wrong, the above report says cannot penetrate the glacis,

    "17 pdr APCBC will not penetrate Panther glacis at any range on level ground."

    That leaves the turret front and lower hull front available for a kill shot from the frontal aspect.

    Furthermore I think the CMBO penalises late war panzers with a -% armour modifier as quality was not so good at that stage. I think that kicks in from panther G onwards.

  2. My take is they are worth it at veteren level or above.

    Stuck out on a flank where he can observe a possible enemy axis of advance they are sometimes incredibly useful. I've had 1 guy take out 2 FO teams in 1 round before they'd fired a single shot. You can't beat that for points value. Even if they are not that useful, used carefully they can slow an attack down nicely by picking off HQ and other high-value units.

    Never use them at close ranges, anything under 2-300m will get him spotted instantly. Left alone, he won't take these shots.

    CMBO funny moment #37, my sniper runs into an enemy sniper in a forest. Both halt and try to hide, neither taking a shot at each other as they are too close. It's like they both sat down for a cup of tea on the sideline while the battle raged in the middle of the map.

  3. WW2O has taken up most of my time for the last year or so. I've got CMBB here but besides playing the odd scenario, I can't get back into it. If only I was unemployed ;)

    Nippy has some common gripes about ww2o but I think they are generally unfair given the unfinished state of the game and the direction the developers have taken it.

    The abondoning of historical timelines is due to each side now being able to control its R&D and Production. Therefore, it is possible to produce pieces of kit much earlier in the war than occurred historically. Of course, to do this you must first sacrifice development in other areas. Same goes with production levels, high commands can go for maximum amounts of heavy tanks, but that reduces the numbers of lighter ones considerably. It makes sense to me because it opens up lots of "what-if" scenarios.

    There are many complaints of "balance" and they are natural considering simulation of the early war's crushing defeats by the axis forces will be very boring if you play allied... ergo, there are many axis players that resent balance, but they are important to the games survival.

    Terrain isn't complete and there are lots of missing units, but honestly if you look at the game now and compare it to the originally released version you wouldn't even recognise it... and its only getting better. Unfortunately, that means CMBB stays on the shelf for a bit longer, but thems the breaks, I'll be back here one day.

    If you've looked at ww2o in the past, I recommend checking it out again soon, once "Deployment" is in place. Deployment will mean army groups running around the map instead of loaded spawns at every town, it will make the game very interesting.

    edit - oh yeah the french have been given US lend lease gear as there is no data for post BoF equipment, aka P40 and the stuart coming soon.

    [ June 11, 2003, 01:14 AM: Message edited by: Sir Uber General ]

  4. Ahh, the MkIV, it'll always have a warm place in my heart. One day during a QB I had my last piece of armour, a MKIV, come head to head with 2 105 shermans. The rest of my armour had been killed early by a nasty jabo. Both shermans scored hits from 300 meters on the lower hull. My return fire took out both of his pieces, and proceeded to maul the infantry they were accompanying, tipping the balance in my favour for the rest of the fight. I couldnt' believe my luck. I love the Pz4 now smile.gif My opponent that day learned some new respect for the old workhorse.

    [ August 16, 2002, 02:11 AM: Message edited by: Sir Uber General ]

×
×
  • Create New...