Hello, I've come across an interesting situation in a pbem and I'd like to know how other more experinced players on this forum view this particular action. It is a demo pbem in the Valley of Trouble scenario, I am playing as the ami attacker and my opponant is the german defender, now I'm sure everyone on this forum is familiar with the layout of this map with the two large hills dominating each sides setup zone. Quite naturally I set up my artillery spotters on the large hill under cover of tall pines, the rest of the unit placement is irrelevant as you will soon find out. Now my opponant just used the default computer setup, how do I know this you ask? Simple, because he had fog of war off. After the setup was complete and I went to issue orders for my first turn I noticed that all his units were visible to me, so I sent an e-mail telling him he forgot fog of war was off or it was some kind of bug. He then replies with an apalogy saying he left it off to observe the computer and forgot leaving it off when he set the game up. So we start the same map over again this time only with full fog of war. Now to be a gentlemen I set my units up in the exact same manor as before, and I think it was a stupid thing to do. At the start of this new pbem immediatley motar fire starts landing near my spotters even though they are hidden in the pines. Needless to say I suffer casualties from this, now here is what I need to know. Was I being naive about placing my units in the same position as before? It is only logical to put the spotters there and they were hidden from enemy los and to me at least it seems as though he's taking advantage of the previous setup in wich fog of war was disabled. I know a prepitory bombardment is sometimes acceptable but in most occasions I wait for visual contact with the enemy before I start dropping shells and I'm sure most others do too. So do you think his little trick was unacceptable? I'm tempted to call the match off right now or I can play his game and paste every patch of forest and building with my surviving 150 spotter even though I can't see the enemy hidden within. But that's not very much fun though now is it?