Jump to content

apex

Members
  • Posts

    135
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by apex

  1. Hi,

    in a PBEM ran into the problem that a pillbox was taken out in the very first turn by a Bofors 40mm. I did test the matter further and built a test scenario with only a bofors and a 88 pillbox in it, distance 850 meters, no ammo for the 88. Result: 10 times out of 10 the pillbox was taken out or the gun damaged within the first turn, usually around 20 seconds into the first round.

    Now, obviously this renders pillboxes quite useless, and furthermore I don't think the war accounts I have read talk much about AAA being used to take out pillboxes. Thesis: This is a bug / hole in the modelling.

    Comments?

    apex

  2. The video datastructure exists in the PBEM files. It's just a matter of exporting playdata into that structure (happens for every PBEM but not AI/HS games) and modifying the player to sequentially play these files while skipping the user input phases. Not a three hour job, granted, but nothing requiring lots of new code either, the player is there, the data format is too, that's the work that took effort. That is, if CM used a object oriented language smile.gif

    apex

  3. <BLOCKQUOTE>quote:</font><HR>This (to me, at least ) is analogous to the defeat of French armor in 1940, though the French tanks were superior to the German in many respects (especially armor protection).<HR></BLOCKQUOTE>

    Complete bull. The french and british armies both outnumbered and outclassed the german armor they faced. Their defeat resulted solely from inadequate tactics, this definitely wasn't the case with the german tank force after operation Overlord where the allied success definitely wasn't because of tactics but due to numbers and logistics.

    apex

  4. ... I'm in a PBEM with Jarmo and he told me to:

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

    rockets are not precision weapons

  5. Priest, I put the answer first and the sarcastic comment second. Yes, it's simulated psychology, in CM, the greener the unit the more likely they are to fire on an enemy when he comes into range. I've had green units fire at 200m despite a hiding order. I've had crack units hold their fire until the enemy was within 10 meters, cutting lose and slaughtering an entire american airborne squad within seconds (at La Fiere, one advance unit in the little house on the other side of the street, wasn't even in command radius, but sure had nerves of steel. Survived the entire battle, too, 2 losses, vs AI though).

    apex

  6. What I would like to see is campaigns or a series of campaigns that attach themselves to a unit rather than a struggle around a certain location. Probably CM's timescope is too small for this, but really putting someone in the battalion commander's seat, leading his troops from Poland to wherever they surrendered and taking part in every important battle the unit was involved in along the way really would be a killer. As I said, it's probably not doable right now or at least only in limited scale, but it should be a long term goal IMHO.

    apex

×
×
  • Create New...