Jump to content

Physim

Members
  • Posts

    27
  • Joined

  • Last visited

    Never

Posts posted by Physim

  1. I'm by no means knowledgeable on climatology, but a couple layman's observations.

    Firstly climate change. There have been many periods of extreme climate change, ice core samples at the poles have shown this as have fossil records. Homo sapiens had not yet even evolved so it wasnt us who caused them.

    As for extinctions, these have occurred throughout prehistory, there was the extinction aound 350 million years ago where 95% of species dissappeared, again evidence in fossil records, and of course the dinosaur extinction which was more recent. None of these were due to homo sapiens.

    I don't think we have enough data on our climate, most is no more than 100 years which is a blink of an eye in climatology, to make any predictions.

    The last ice age finished about 10 000 years ago, we could just be going through the normal warming cycle. Who knows?

    Just my 2c worth I claim no expert knowledge in this area.

  2. The French and the Brits had no counter for the blitzkrieg tactic, they had prepared for war like it was fought in WW1, once the static defences were flanked they were gone. As you rightly say the russians were helped by scale, this meant the initial blitz had to last longer. It stretched the German supply lines and gave the Russians time to prepare for a counter. I also think splitting the German offensive into 3 groups was a mistake, they should have concentrated on the South and held the oil fields this would have strangled Russian industry, Moscow and Leningrad were political and prestige targets not strategic ones and too many resources were wated on them.

  3. Played this one late last night. Ended up a tactical defeat when ceasefire called due to both sides low on ammo. Losing my tanks very early didn't help, but the lessons learned in the 110,111,112 scenarios helped my infantry capture and hold the first flag and give the AI infantry a hard time in the centre and on the right flank, my left flank was creamed.

    Two questions, once my mortars ran out of ammo I used the AT rifles as Heavy support to my infantry in attacking foxholes /trenches that held enemy infantry, I found them to be very effective in this task. Is this gamey or were they used for that purpose in real life?

    Also when I target using a spotter for offboard artillery it can sometimes take over 20 turns for the artillery to fire, is this normal or am I doing something wrong or is this the norm?

  4. As with most meglamaniniacs, Hitler eventually bit off more than he could chew. With considerable resources already tied up garrisoning conquered areas and fighting in North Africa, I don't think he ever had the manpower or industrial resources to beat the Soviets too. Due to his racist view of them he underestimated them and due to his own meglamania overestimated his own abilities and those of his country. I think even with a total war scenario it was only a matter of time.

  5. After numerous numerous tries I finally passed this scenario. I left it completely vanilla.

    I used the tactics as learned from the thread ie keep in command range. Use two or three to shoot and keep the MG occupied while advancing one or two units short distances and hiding. Around turn 10 I got two units behind the wooden fence and moved two more from the tree toward the road with the HQ in the middle. Pouring in the fire eventually flushed out and then eliminated the MG at about turn 14 with no casualties.

    All previous times I got my butt kicked badly.

  6. Sounds like Raus i am reading the book Panzer operations which is his memoir of his time on the Eastern Front. Whilst commanding the 1st Panzer Army he also commandered elements of the Hungarian Army this was referred to as an Army Group, although semantically it is not an accurate description.

    Having read half the book, I think he certainly exagerrated German successes (especially his own) and played down the Russians. He was sacked from command in April 1945 after unsuccessful battles in Pomerania.

    After the war the US used him as a consultant/adviser re Russian combined arms tactics so they could develop plans to counter them should there be a conventional war in Europe.

×
×
  • Create New...