Bil Hardenberger Posted June 15, 2022 Share Posted June 15, 2022 @Rinaldi, at least they gave you a bit of a challenge this time. Your stuff is easy to read and your graphics are perfect. Well done. 4 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rinaldi Posted June 15, 2022 Author Share Posted June 15, 2022 58 minutes ago, Bil Hardenberger said: @Rinaldi, at least they gave you a bit of a challenge this time. Your stuff is easy to read and your graphics are perfect. Well done. Yes, it was a much more frenetic fight than I wanted. I am not entirely pleased with my plan. The layered air and artillery wasn't really done with my fields of fire in mind. I should've brought both the combat aviation and artillery down closer to the cliffs and more the NE; where the tanks established that ABF. It wasn't really a joint-fires affair like I had hoped. 0 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rinaldi Posted June 20, 2022 Author Share Posted June 20, 2022 We're back; and we're here. The end of Part 1 of this little project (don't worry, I've already typed up Missions 03 through 06 of the 82 campaign). Red pass. The big one. The centrepiece. Chapter 2: Counterattack at Red Pass! October 21st, 0630 hours. Somewhere south of Hill 644.2. “I am expecting a pure MRB, with no frills. Probably coming in three echelons, a MRC each, and you can bet the bottom dollar those lead MRCs are going to go for the flanks and hold the shoulders for a final assault on your main positions…” It was the TF S-2 talking, addressing the three company leaders. They were stuffed into the TOC, and the close proximity was rapidly driving the temperature and humidity up to unbearable levels. It was affecting Wren’s ability to focus, but he willed himself to concentrate on the briefing. It was an important one. This was their final test. The TF had a hard-fought 20th of October. The heavy team and C Company had spent themselves unsticking die-hard enemy reconnaissance elements and an MRC in the vicinity of Hill 644.2. They had succeeded, but so comprehensively ruined was the tank-heavy team that they had been functionally disbanded, and surviving tanks folded into platoons in the rifle companies. The TF had gone firm to lick its wounds and await the OPFOR counterstroke, the topic of the briefing. The Battalion scout platoon, well forward and in good hides, had identified the main effort: Red Lake Pass. B Team’s area of responsibility. The S-2 finished, and the LTC stepped forward. “Gentlemen, step outside and catch some air, and follow me.” They tumbled out of the TOC and followed the Old Man around its side, to see yet another sand table. They looked expectantly at their chief. Slowly and deliberately, the LTC took a marker meant to represent B Team, moving it onto a mound of sand representing Benchmark 2108. “As you know, the engineer platoon got chopped up pretty badly during the last attack. They don’t have enough men to go around to dig us in before the OPFOR are expected to go in. To my mind, that makes the coming fight an ultimately offensive operation.” He paused to meet his subordinates’ gazes. He clearly liked what he saw, continuing, “we’re going to assume some risk here, I’m going to shore up C Team with your – “he nods at Wren “M150s and a rifle platoon, they’re also going to get most of the engineer support. A Team will also provide M150s to C. That should allow them to hold a larger-than-usual frontage and make up for their losses. That will free up A Team as a reserve. Once we confirm the main effort is in B Team’s sector, I’m going to let them off the leash to counterattack. B Team’s going to fix them, attrit them, force ‘em to dismount. Then A team is going to finish them.” Wren liked what he was hearing, and it was completely in line with his own aggressive thinking. The TF had learned from the Brown Pass fight that the way to counter the OPFOR’s clockwork-like battle drills was to get them off balance early and often, and counterpunch frequently. His combat team being halved for the battle was disquieting, but he knew fortune favoured the bold. It was a solid plan, based on excellent intel, and he knew the terrain would allow him to push his thinned-out company to maximum effect. He looked up to see the LTC studying him, as if trying to read his thoughts. Finally, the boss said: “Captain, tell me how you intend to fight the initial battle, and we’ll plan around it.” “Well sir, as I see it, we’re going to have to accept a decisive engagement to take advantage of our superior dismounts. The Tanks are going to have to fight forward to force the enemy to deploy and to feel out their main effort. With some range cards and sufficient fire support, say priority from the 155 battery and some combat aviation, we can bleed them at range well enough to fix them close. I’m envisioning two engagement areas…” Eight helmeted heads crowded around the sand table as Wren outlined his basic plan with emphatic gestures and sweeps of his hand. They would need another hour or so to flesh it out on the map, and another two hours after that to walk the intended ground with their platoon leaders and fire support officers, but the nucleus of a winning plan had formed. Wren’s defence was aggressive and scrappy, and more importantly, shaped an excellent flanking counterattack for A Company. Later that morning, Wren and his counterpart in A Company explained the taskings to their own subordinates. Initial Tasking: - B Company (-) – Task: Fix o Tank Platoon (-) – Raid to Benchmark 2108. With the following attachments: 1st Squad, 1st Platoon FO, 1st Platoon o 1st Platoon (-) – Task: Occupy main BP vic. Benchmark 2124. With the following attachments: Company HQ Tank section o Mortars – Task: Priority of fires to 1st Platoon (-). Position in “Sandy Wadi”. o Company FIST: OP on Benchmark 2124. Reinforcement: - A Company (-) – Task: Flank o Tank Platoon o 1st Platoon o 2nd Platoon Fires and Combat Aviation: Cluster 155mm at H+5; and 1 x Flight of Cobras at alert 15. Though Wren’s team did little more than follow and support during the night attack to seize 644.2, the job of clearing out die hard infiltrators had inevitably caused some losses. Most of 1st Platoon had suffered at least one or two men critically or lightly wounded in the squads, and they were down a basic load of ammunition from the sporadic fighting and patrols. More critically, two TCs in the tank platoon had been wounded by mortar fire earlier that morning, leaving two tanks understrength. Wren opted to take those two tanks into the main BP, where proximity to the infantry and OPs would hopefully make up for the crew deficit. They were as ready as they were going to get. The men of 1st Platoon rested in shifts, and improved their fighting positions throughout the morning, awaiting word from the TF scouts about whether the big one was indeed coming their way. The sun reached, then passed its zenith, baking the men and causing much discomfort. Then, came word: 40-50 vehicles were approaching the dry Red Pass Lake. Ten minutes later, a lone scout track came barrelling through what was going to be EA Red and pulled back along Bitter Springs MSR. Wren, deployed forward of Benchmark 2124 with the sniping tanks, could see it for himself: a massive cloud of high, hanging dust in the distance. A veritable stampede. It was 1250 hours. The horde advance with alacrity, and by 1255 hours he could begin to spot individual vehicles through the dust. It was the main element of the MRB, just as the Battalion S-2 predicted. Travelling well in front of the main herd was a platoon of BMPs, in line, coming right down the middle towards Point 606.1. Artillery began to crash several hundred meters off Wren’s right, along the goat trail that constituted Bitter Springs MSR, smoke shells began to billow among the explosive bursts of HE. “Bravo 26 send to Papa 66.” “This is Papa 66, go ahead” – An unfamiliar voice, one of the Duty NCOs at TOC, responds. “Bravo 26 reports contact with enemy main body.” “Bravo 26, this is Papa 66. Roger your last. H-Hour, H-Hour. Out” – The Old man himself is on the horn now, announcing the start of the planned final battle. It was 1300 hours. “Bravo 26 send to Bravo Tango. Get your men moving, out” “Bravo Tango: acknowledged” 1LT Harmon’s tank section, on this signal, moves out in column. The company mortars, monitoring the net, provide pre-arranged smoke to mask this movement. The destination: the rolling hills on the company team’s left flank. It only takes them two minutes to arrive at an appropriate attack-by-fire position. The two carriers rolling with them, carrying 1st squad of 1st platoon, and the FO, roll on towards the more complex terrain. Harmon pushes his men up for a quick attack by fire, but the engagement proves frustrating. Such a mass of enemy targets are impossible not to identify, but at such extended range, the small, speedy BMPs make difficult targets. Little is accomplished, and the 1LT doesn’t waste any further time in the position: he signals with his hands from his cupola, telling the section to orient on him. As the tanks pull back into cover and rumble on, the promised priorities of fire from the supporting 155 battery are released to Wren. The battery is immediately tasked to fire on the building concentrations of BMPs along Benchmark 2033 and Point 606.1. From his OP position, well forward, Wren can see more BMPs entering the area. It appears to be another company. Like the lead forces, this unit initially speeds across the dry Red Pass Lake, but then wheels smartly to the north and disappears behind Benchmark 2108. Are they heading for 1LT Harmon’s position? 1LT Harmon is trying to remain calm. There’s a lot of combat power driving right at the rest of the Company, and the compulsion to rush is almost overwhelming. “Move deliberately” he chides himself. “Slow is smooth and smooth is fast” he repeats to himself, mentally. The sandy desert floor was treacherous, and his tanks were likely to throw a track if they rushed unduly or made too sharp a change of direction. Nevertheless, he pressed his men on as fast as he dared. It took just shy of ten minutes to reach a second attack-by-fire position. This time, gunnery is much more satisfactory, aided no doubt by the fact that the BMPs are entering terrain they had previously ranged out. A BMP is destroyed at Point 2033. More and more BMPs array themselves on and around Hill 636.2 and Benchmark 2033. Harmon isn’t sure what they’re waiting for, but he’s glad they’ve stopped. His tank section continues their attack by fire, doing berm drills to avoid the growing attentions of his erstwhile targets, and the volleys of Sagger missiles they send his way. Then the artillery ordered by the CPT arrives. Bomblets immediately make an impression, and another BMP is flamed in the beaten zone, compelling BMPs to fall back in a hurry. The retrograde movement is fleeting. The moment arrives: the mass of BMPs, despite the discomfort of the artillery fire and Harmon’s flanking fire, surge forward. The MRC that had earlier disappeared to the north reappear, forming up only a ridge away from Harmon’s positions. Wren is able to raise his tank platoon commander on the net and inform him of the impending threat. A strained acknowledgement is received. To his relief, he sees the three M60s swiftly pull back and orient to face this. Would Harmon be able to hold with just three tanks and 12 dismounts? Pulling back to the main BP in time is simply out of the question. Wren winces, realising that to have asked such a small force to punch out so far forward was a mistake: he just hoped it wouldn’t be a fatal one. Little further time could be spent agonizing over the matter, as another MRC competes for his attention to the southeast. They are straddling the Bitter Springs MSR and flanking to the south. “The S-2 will be glad to hear how correct he was about the enemy scheme.” He thinks bitterly. Despite how well-predicted and doctrinal the assault was, it hadn’t done them a whit of good. Astonished by the pace of advance, they haven’t whittled down the lead OPFOR units anywhere near as much as they had hoped or planned. There was no time to dwell on that now. Nor was there time to alter the scheme. Wren was experienced enough to know to do so would only cause undue, possibly fatal confusion. “Time to get in this fight.” Scrambling down the sandy embankment, Wren rushes towards the nearest M60, waving it forward. He hoped that as the range closed rapidly, his own gunnery would become far more accurate. He had high expectations that this forward sniping position would put a hurting on the BMPs as they entered EA Blue. As the M60 rumbled up the ridge to a firing position, the SPC commanding the (under-strength) tank slips into the turret and slams the hatch shut behind him. His wingman, no doubt alerted via the platoon net, shortly does the same. One of the pair expertly two BMPs in as many shots, but before it can pull back into cover it is struck by a Sagger missile from somewhere to the north. The other M60 also finds success. It flames a BMP with its first shot, destroying it even as it attempts to return fire with a missile. A second round impacts on the next nearest BMP, which explodes with such violence that a third, trying to skirt around its stricken comrades, is also knocked out. The sudden violent attack by fire sows confusion, briefly, among the OPFOR . The BMPs must slow their rate of advance to push past their burning compatriots and deploy back into an effective line. CPT Wren and the surviving M60 take this opportunity to make good their escape, falling back across several ridges and washes to take position in the main BP. *** To 1LT Harmon what is happening several hundred meters to his right may as well be in a different universe. He is entirely preoccupied with the immediate fight, which rapidly descends into what can only be described as a confused melee. Upon being warned by the CO of the impending attack, he had just enough time to deploy his three tanks into somewhat effective battle positions. There was a massive blind spot on his left created by a low spur, and the best he could do in the time he had was to give vague orders to the infantry NCO to get over there and “deal with it.” No sooner had he given that unhelpful order, then the first OPFOR BMPs crested the ridge to his immediate front. All three TCs dropped into their cupolas, slamming their hatches in near unison. Three cannons snap in quick succession. Harmon had failed to assign any fire sectors. 3 HEAT rounds smash into the same BMP, which shudders and explodes violently. The next couple of volleys are better controlled by the hard-pressed platoon leader, and three more BMPs are destroyed. The OPFOR surge roars forward, almost heedless, and Harmon realises they’re going to go right through him at this pace. He urgently orders the tanks to retreat, heading for a ravine in the rear slope. Chaos reigns. Harmon bounces between the vision blocks in his cupola, in an attempt to figure out what the hell is happening. He’s astonished to see a BMP surge right past his tank, beelining into a scrub-filled ravine to his rear. Slewing the turret with the override, he gives the surprised gunner firing point procedures, even as he sprays frantically with the .50 calibre. The BMP is knocked out. “There’s a freakin’ BMP to our front, it’s practically kissing us!” it’s his driver on the intercom. Even as they were dealing with the BMP to their rear, another one had charged right at them. Harmon hadn’t even realised. The Gunner, calmer now, quickly slews the turret. The vehicle fills the entire FOV of his sight. At this range, he cannot miss. The BMP explodes in a fireball. Harmon’s two wingman tanks report their own successful engagements in similarly messy, point-blank scraps. The attached infantry are equally astonished to see BMPs driving right past them, their firing ports flashing and winking with rifle fire. Having grabbed as many LAWs as they could before dismounting, they are able to destroy several BMPs from the flank and rear. The M113s, hidden away in the washes near their dismounts, are likewise able to knock out a pair of BMPs, firing into their sides and rear. Belatedly, a few surviving BMPs disgorge dismounts, who try to work their way down into the washes. They are able to knock out the M113s as they crest a ridge but have more trouble dealing with the dismounts. In a shootout right out of a Western, they are sprayed down at close range and forced to retreat. It’s chaotic, it’s messy, but it ends decisively in Harmon’s favour. In two extremely confused minutes, he has removed an enemy company from the larger fight. He takes a minute, trying to restore his situational awareness (and his frayed nerves). The head count takes longer than he would like, and his stomach drops at the thought that all his dismounts are dead. The M113s don’t answer, and his worry mounts. Finally, breathing heavily, the FO NCO reports in and confirms his left is secure. He is also able to re-establish contact with the company HQ via radio and gives as accurate a SITREP as he can, given the circumstances. “Good, we’re still in this fight.” He concludes. “Alright, we need to sweep this ravine for any stragglers we missed. Gunner, scan every BMP, some might be playing dead and waiting for a chance shot. Driver, advance. Speed: 1.” *** Wren is equally focused on his immediate fight, and after having guided the surviving M60 into a good hide, has once again taken as exposed from which he could control the battle. 1LT Voegt, from his position near Benchmark 2124, reports the OPFOR beginning to dismount within EA blue. It's an excellent sign; the enemy would be basically fixed in position as they tried to climb up around the flanks with their dismounts first, at an infantry pace. 1st Platoon and the surviving M60 are now decisively engaged. It is 1320 hours. Then Wren’ radio squawks: “Alpha 26 send to Bravo 26: we are now exiting Sierra Whiskey.” Sierra Whiskey – the Sandy Wadi. A Company had arrived, with impeccable timing. Risking a somewhat lengthy radio message, CPT Wren does his best to update his counterpart on the current situation. The decision ultimately lies with A Team’s CPT: the counterattack is on…but how? Leaning out of his command track’s hatch, the newly arrived leader takes a moment to gather his thoughts. The thrust on the northern flank sounds like it had been stopped cold, if not destroyed. He could push his team in that direction, wheeling right to hit the enemy engaged in EA Blue from the flank and rear. Alternatively, he could push his entire team into the main BP and engage the deployed enemy head-on. He had to decide, and quick. Ultimately, he chooses the bolder option, rationalizing that wheeling right through B Team’s tank platoon would: Reinforce a success Help mop up any straggling or infiltrating enemy; and Avoid a complex forward passage of line through the main BP and into the teeth of an attacking MRC. Ordering a tank section to take a support-by-fire position near point 632.1, the rest of A Company (-) move out of the Sandy Wadi in column, keeping Point 632.1 to their right, and begin their attack. He informs CPT Wren of his scheme of manoeuvre. All 1st Platoon and its attachments must do is hold on. Cluster munitions shift, in the meantime, to deny the ground the OPFOR are attempting to advance through. The hope is that it will buy enough time to vector Cobras onto the surviving enemy. As A Co roars forward and through a brief danger area, the number 3 tank from the company’s tank platoon foolishly halts to engage a BMP several kilometres distant. It misses, badly, and is immediately struck by a Sagger missile for its wasted effort. The tank platoon leader can only swear to himself and urge the rest of his callsigns to be less foolish. It only takes a couple of minutes to link up with 1LT Harmon’s surviving callsigns. The hard-pressed armor officer was still rooting out surviving enemy dismounts and BMPs that were scattered around the ravine. In the hide-and-seek firefight that resulted after the melee, he had lost both M113s and one of his tanks had been damaged by a BMP’s 73mm gun. The point element of A Company arriving swings the balance firmly back in Harmon’s favour, and they announce its arrival in style, the lead tank knocking out one of these sheltering BMPs. As the tanks advance, they take small arms fire from surviving OPFOR dismounts, they report it for the following infantry and press on to link up with Harmon. The combined two tank sections take effective hull down positions and attack by fire. Despite the long range they are able to knock out several BMPs at the edge of EA Blue are knocked out. The enemy attack appears to be stalling, the main effort in EA Blue reduced to a bloody dismount-forward assault. Then the OPFOR helicopters arrive. Despite the VADs best efforts, the pilots skilfully evade and devastate the company mortar platoon with gun runs and rockets. The weapons platoon leader is killed in action during one of these attacks. While frustrating, and devastating to the rear area of B Team, it doesn’t give the attack the impetus it needs. The BMPs, taking cover as best they can in the washboard-like terrain in EA Blue, fill the air with Saggers, searching out for the surviving M60 which has been making a deadly nuisance of itself, ably directed by Wren into, and out of, firing positions. Eventually, however, the M60’s luck runs out. An enemy Sagger finally strikes, disabling the tank. Nevertheless, the MRBs losses rise inexorably. The “battlefield calculus” is overwhelmingly in A and B Team’s favour thus far. Back in the ravine, 1st Squad from B Team’s 1st Platoon continue to root out enemy dismounts. They are shortly joined by the infantry from A Team, who dismount behind a low berm and effectively engage the enemy, who have expertly and calmly sheltered in any fold of terrain they could find. They take casualties, but the firefights go overwhelmingly their way, often aided by the M113s. The battle is reaching its climax. The surviving BMPs are fighting gamely from decent cover, and at least of company of enemy dismounts are continuing to advance. Wren gets on the horn: “Bravo 26 send to Alpha 26.” “Alpha 26 here.” “Cobras are telling me they’re Winchester and we’re in a firefight here with multiple dismounts. If you’re going to make a move, make it now. Out” The stress is evident in Wren’s voice, and it spurs A Team’s leader to action. He tells his tank platoon (-) and to get moving, and the unengaged 2nd Platoon to follow and support. The three M60s do one final jockey into a firing position, scanning for targets, then roll up and over the ridge. The tanks surge forward, aiming to hit the rear of the OPFOR’s formation. Advancing on line and at a steady pace, they hose down the washboard terrain with coax, in an attempt to keep the OPFOR dismounts pinned. Despite the volume of fire, the platoon leader’s tank is disabled by a die-hard RPG gunner. Nevertheless, the two remaining M60s push through and begin to sweep away the surviving BMPs. While the balance of A Company is driving into the MRB’s flank and rear, its 1st Platoon, having finished mopping up OPFOR infiltrators, climbs Benchmark 2108. A beautiful sight greets them. Excitedly, the platoon FO requests for priority of fires. “We got the whole logistical tail of the MRB here!” – He gets his fire mission. Several minutes later, the 155 scattering the soft skins that are taking cover behind Hill 636.2 and destroying two. The roaring battle slowly peters out, as A Company’s 2nd Platoon root out the enemy from the washboard terrain. Even at this late stage, the OPFOR dismounts fight tenaciously. Almost all of them must be killed in close assaults by the riflemen. None surrender. Then, the radios across the Taskforce crackle: “End-ex, end-ex, end-ex.” The fight is over. Indeed, the battle and rotation are over. The burning vehicles and the dead men fade into what they really are: blinking MILEs lights and disappointed soldiers sitting cross legged on the desert floor, signalling they are “killed.” To Wren and the entirety of this TF however, it was real enough. This final fight was nothing short of harrowing. The OPFOR were relentless, quite literally storming through their positions at times. While the field of ruin that used to be an entire enemy MRB is a gratifying sight, and would appear to be clear evidence of a smashing success for the TF, determining who won was a matter of difficulty. Controversy ensues during the final AAR. The observers and evaluators can hardly agree among themselves how to rate the TF’s final performance. The OPFOR brigade commander, the NTC coordinator, ultimately declares it a minor defeat. He cites, absurdly to Wren’s mind, the dismounted losses taken by A and B Company Team as being unsustainable. Worse still, CPT Wren is criticized, though not with enthusiasm, for accepting a decisive engagement. The TF commander is lauded for his aggressive plan, and equally importantly, for trusting his subordinates with planning and command decisions. The LTC had the idea, and a framework, but how it was accomplished was rightly left to the two CPTs who would have to fight the actual battle. The tank losses are brought up and are bitterly criticized. The US Army CPT who was leading the main MRB battalion (the OPFOR always lead “one up”, so a LT often lead a company) is conspicuously and noticeably quiet throughout the debriefing. Wren and his counterpart in A Company take this as the greatest sign of how the battle really went. The vivid image of the MRB’s logistical units’ MILES indicators blinking in the desert heat was evidence enough for the officers and men of the TF. The criticisms raised did ring true, and the NTC had shown itself to be a harsh master. Years later, men of the TF would say it was, in many ways, harder than the real thing. The OPFOR pushed through often murderous fire with a unity of purpose and fearlessness that no unit could maintain in the face of such heavy losses. Real men in a real battle fear death, are awed by the sight of burning, twisted metal and flesh, the howl of artillery and the screaming of the wounded. No matter how realistic the NTC was, Wren mused, a self-confident OPFOR could never be convinced to halt their attack when they are simply resurrected for battle the next day. Despite this, the TF had won. This rotation was firm proof that the Soviets, the real opposing force, can and could be defeated. 10 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
IICptMillerII Posted June 20, 2022 Share Posted June 20, 2022 Yes but, how does this relate to Ukraine? Couldn't help myself. Anyways, fantastic writeup as usual! I'm sure many heads will pop at the performance here. 1 hour ago, Rinaldi said: Controversy ensues during the final AAR. The observers and evaluators can hardly agree among themselves how to rate the TF’s final performance. The OPFOR brigade commander, the NTC coordinator, ultimately declares it a minor defeat. He cites, absurdly to Wren’s mind, the dismounted losses taken by A and B Company Team as being unsustainable. Worse still, CPT Wren is criticized, though not with enthusiasm, for accepting a decisive engagement. I am also curious at the scoring for this mission. I recall there was some kind of bugged scoring with this mission but was under the impression that it had been fixed. @Bil Hardenberger any idea what could be going on here? 2 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Bil Hardenberger Posted June 21, 2022 Share Posted June 21, 2022 @Rinaldi, this was intended to really push the player to the limit.. and it sounds like it did just that. You played it exactly like I had hoped someone would, using the terrain as a force multiplier. I purposefully and painstakingly built in all of the little wadis/gullies and other terrain features from satellite photos so this type of maneuver was possible, so I really appreciate your approach. Another really fun read.. I especially appreciate seeing an AAR of this battle, as very few people have reported on it... it can be a humbling scenario if you don't approach it in the manner you did, aggressively and with flexibility. Not sure if something is wrong with the scoring, or if the fact that the OPFOR attained their terrain objective is what pushed them over the top. Maybe @George MC can comment. 2 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rinaldi Posted June 21, 2022 Author Share Posted June 21, 2022 (edited) 15 hours ago, IICptMillerII said: Yes but, how does this relate to Ukraine? Couldn't help myself. Rumour has it that once upon a time there was discussion on something called Combat Mission...passed into legend now. 1 hour ago, Bil Hardenberger said: @Rinaldi, this was intended to really push the player to the limit.. and it sounds like it did just that. You played it exactly like I had hoped someone would, using the terrain as a force multiplier. I purposefully and painstakingly built in all of the little wadis/gullies and other terrain features from satellite photos so this type of maneuver was possible, so I really appreciate your approach. Yes, I think it's a lesson in the importance of walking the terrain; only the most careful of terrain reads will help glean what the enemy's likely COAs are. I think, and from what I've gathered reading from others who have shared their experiences, that a lot of individuals assumed the Soviet MRB would pound forward. The high ground to the American left dominates any route of retreat (if someone chooses a delay in sector), so that is obvious. Likewise, a 'straight in' approach to the main American position would never be a likely route in: The washboard terrain and the forest tiles just make it a natural obstacle to movement; hence my selection of EAs being in the pass itself, and then to my extreme right flank. 1 hour ago, Bil Hardenberger said: Not sure if something is wrong with the scoring, or if the fact that the OPFOR attained their terrain objective is what pushed them over the top. Maybe @George MC can comment. I saved the ENDREP file and I've had a look just now. Soviets gained 350 for their phase lines, and 1253 for dismounts. I'm unsure if that's intended or not, but whatever the case, I know from my own mission making experience just how esoteric the point allocations can be for units. I actually am okay with the minor defeat; I think that type of controversy captures precisely the early eras of the NTC. As we all know, the OPFOR always cheats and often wins ;). Now, I think this is a good segue into a brief discussion about the purpose of the campaign. In short: I have nothing but praise for the NTC campaign. I truly do believe it exceeds at some points the difficulty of the US campaign, which means its doing its job. I also think it is a perfect headshake to those who are used to 'look down, shoot down' equivalents for NATO mechanized units from SF2 and Black Sea. What surprises me is how slow the realisation can be for some as they play through the campaign. The first mission being a shock to most should be no surprise, by the second mission they should be experimenting for answers to the questions asked by the OPFOR. By the third mission they should be perfecting their methodology on how to defeat the OPFOR. So I won't mince words, any vagaries of the scoring system aside, this is a rough result for the final mission; I think the execution at the platoon scale more so than the TF scheme is where I let myself down. The formula I learned here I will put on display as we turn to the shooting war in Europe in subsequent chapters of the AAR, and with much greater efficacy, if I say so myself. I spoke recently with @domfluff about why the fictional titles seem to be so focused in what points their campaigns are trying to make, and I do think it is because they aren't beholden to having to try to recreate a historical situation. That means, with artistic licence, they can make a point through a series of plausible scenarios. By contrast, Road to Montebourg is a massive, masterpiece-effort campaign, but it has no real thesis beyond "the bocage is tough" and capturing the actions of three separate battalions from three different regiments. The NTC campaign, by contrast, is a perfect example of our point that fictional situations can ease the task of a campaign maker to demonstrate something. It clearly sets out to prove a point: that technological supremacy is nothing without a clear tactical doctrine; the OPFOR have one, by the end you should too. Edited June 21, 2022 by Rinaldi 7 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
domfluff Posted June 21, 2022 Share Posted June 21, 2022 I've said before, but I think the NTC campaign might be my favorite across all of CM, precisely because of that sharp focus. Each mission and decision point serves a cohesive purpose, and the whole doesn't outstay its welcome. I do think the final scoring might be a little scuffed, but I'm not sure it matters really. 5 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
EvilTwinn Posted June 21, 2022 Share Posted June 21, 2022 Honestly the score at the end of the game doesn't ever really matter. What matters is the lessons you can take from it. I mean, and enjoyment too, but who plays video games to have fun? In either case, I really do think the NTC forces you to learn how to fight and to abandon any bad habits you might have formed in other games. Focus in on proper execution of the fundamentals and you get good results, just as it should be. 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
George MC Posted June 21, 2022 Share Posted June 21, 2022 (edited) 6 hours ago, Bil Hardenberger said: @Rinaldi, this was intended to really push the player to the limit.. and it sounds like it did just that. You played it exactly like I had hoped someone would, using the terrain as a force multiplier. I purposefully and painstakingly built in all of the little wadis/gullies and other terrain features from satellite photos so this type of maneuver was possible, so I really appreciate your approach. Another really fun read.. I especially appreciate seeing an AAR of this battle, as very few people have reported on it... it can be a humbling scenario if you don't approach it in the manner you did, aggressively and with flexibility. Not sure if something is wrong with the scoring, or if the fact that the OPFOR attained their terrain objective is what pushed them over the top. Maybe @George MC can comment. oops... the score for Mission 2B should be 160 points for BLUEFOR dismounts but due to my fat climber fingers I typed in 8160.... You wuz robbed @Rinaldi that CPT did weel to keep his gob shut. he knew it! I've attached the tweaked version. I'll let @BFCElvisknow. NTC 1982 Training In The Desert_v2.cam Edited June 21, 2022 by George MC 5 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Simcoe Posted June 23, 2022 Share Posted June 23, 2022 On 6/20/2022 at 3:38 PM, Rinaldi said: We're back; and we're here. The end of Part 1 of this little project (don't worry, I've already typed up Missions 03 through 06 of the 82 campaign). Red pass. The big one. The centrepiece. Chapter 2: Counterattack at Red Pass! October 21st, 0630 hours. Somewhere south of Hill 644.2. “I am expecting a pure MRB, with no frills. Probably coming in three echelons, a MRC each, and you can bet the bottom dollar those lead MRCs are going to go for the flanks and hold the shoulders for a final assault on your main positions…” It was the TF S-2 talking, addressing the three company leaders. They were stuffed into the TOC, and the close proximity was rapidly driving the temperature and humidity up to unbearable levels. It was affecting Wren’s ability to focus, but he willed himself to concentrate on the briefing. It was an important one. This was their final test. The TF had a hard-fought 20th of October. The heavy team and C Company had spent themselves unsticking die-hard enemy reconnaissance elements and an MRC in the vicinity of Hill 644.2. They had succeeded, but so comprehensively ruined was the tank-heavy team that they had been functionally disbanded, and surviving tanks folded into platoons in the rifle companies. The TF had gone firm to lick its wounds and await the OPFOR counterstroke, the topic of the briefing. The Battalion scout platoon, well forward and in good hides, had identified the main effort: Red Lake Pass. B Team’s area of responsibility. The S-2 finished, and the LTC stepped forward. “Gentlemen, step outside and catch some air, and follow me.” They tumbled out of the TOC and followed the Old Man around its side, to see yet another sand table. They looked expectantly at their chief. Slowly and deliberately, the LTC took a marker meant to represent B Team, moving it onto a mound of sand representing Benchmark 2108. “As you know, the engineer platoon got chopped up pretty badly during the last attack. They don’t have enough men to go around to dig us in before the OPFOR are expected to go in. To my mind, that makes the coming fight an ultimately offensive operation.” He paused to meet his subordinates’ gazes. He clearly liked what he saw, continuing, “we’re going to assume some risk here, I’m going to shore up C Team with your – “he nods at Wren “M150s and a rifle platoon, they’re also going to get most of the engineer support. A Team will also provide M150s to C. That should allow them to hold a larger-than-usual frontage and make up for their losses. That will free up A Team as a reserve. Once we confirm the main effort is in B Team’s sector, I’m going to let them off the leash to counterattack. B Team’s going to fix them, attrit them, force ‘em to dismount. Then A team is going to finish them.” Wren liked what he was hearing, and it was completely in line with his own aggressive thinking. The TF had learned from the Brown Pass fight that the way to counter the OPFOR’s clockwork-like battle drills was to get them off balance early and often, and counterpunch frequently. His combat team being halved for the battle was disquieting, but he knew fortune favoured the bold. It was a solid plan, based on excellent intel, and he knew the terrain would allow him to push his thinned-out company to maximum effect. He looked up to see the LTC studying him, as if trying to read his thoughts. Finally, the boss said: “Captain, tell me how you intend to fight the initial battle, and we’ll plan around it.” “Well sir, as I see it, we’re going to have to accept a decisive engagement to take advantage of our superior dismounts. The Tanks are going to have to fight forward to force the enemy to deploy and to feel out their main effort. With some range cards and sufficient fire support, say priority from the 155 battery and some combat aviation, we can bleed them at range well enough to fix them close. I’m envisioning two engagement areas…” Eight helmeted heads crowded around the sand table as Wren outlined his basic plan with emphatic gestures and sweeps of his hand. They would need another hour or so to flesh it out on the map, and another two hours after that to walk the intended ground with their platoon leaders and fire support officers, but the nucleus of a winning plan had formed. Wren’s defence was aggressive and scrappy, and more importantly, shaped an excellent flanking counterattack for A Company. Later that morning, Wren and his counterpart in A Company explained the taskings to their own subordinates. Initial Tasking: - B Company (-) – Task: Fix o Tank Platoon (-) – Raid to Benchmark 2108. With the following attachments: 1st Squad, 1st Platoon FO, 1st Platoon o 1st Platoon (-) – Task: Occupy main BP vic. Benchmark 2124. With the following attachments: Company HQ Tank section o Mortars – Task: Priority of fires to 1st Platoon (-). Position in “Sandy Wadi”. o Company FIST: OP on Benchmark 2124. Reinforcement: - A Company (-) – Task: Flank o Tank Platoon o 1st Platoon o 2nd Platoon Fires and Combat Aviation: Cluster 155mm at H+5; and 1 x Flight of Cobras at alert 15. Though Wren’s team did little more than follow and support during the night attack to seize 644.2, the job of clearing out die hard infiltrators had inevitably caused some losses. Most of 1st Platoon had suffered at least one or two men critically or lightly wounded in the squads, and they were down a basic load of ammunition from the sporadic fighting and patrols. More critically, two TCs in the tank platoon had been wounded by mortar fire earlier that morning, leaving two tanks understrength. Wren opted to take those two tanks into the main BP, where proximity to the infantry and OPs would hopefully make up for the crew deficit. They were as ready as they were going to get. The men of 1st Platoon rested in shifts, and improved their fighting positions throughout the morning, awaiting word from the TF scouts about whether the big one was indeed coming their way. The sun reached, then passed its zenith, baking the men and causing much discomfort. Then, came word: 40-50 vehicles were approaching the dry Red Pass Lake. Ten minutes later, a lone scout track came barrelling through what was going to be EA Red and pulled back along Bitter Springs MSR. Wren, deployed forward of Benchmark 2124 with the sniping tanks, could see it for himself: a massive cloud of high, hanging dust in the distance. A veritable stampede. It was 1250 hours. The horde advance with alacrity, and by 1255 hours he could begin to spot individual vehicles through the dust. It was the main element of the MRB, just as the Battalion S-2 predicted. Travelling well in front of the main herd was a platoon of BMPs, in line, coming right down the middle towards Point 606.1. Artillery began to crash several hundred meters off Wren’s right, along the goat trail that constituted Bitter Springs MSR, smoke shells began to billow among the explosive bursts of HE. “Bravo 26 send to Papa 66.” “This is Papa 66, go ahead” – An unfamiliar voice, one of the Duty NCOs at TOC, responds. “Bravo 26 reports contact with enemy main body.” “Bravo 26, this is Papa 66. Roger your last. H-Hour, H-Hour. Out” – The Old man himself is on the horn now, announcing the start of the planned final battle. It was 1300 hours. “Bravo 26 send to Bravo Tango. Get your men moving, out” “Bravo Tango: acknowledged” 1LT Harmon’s tank section, on this signal, moves out in column. The company mortars, monitoring the net, provide pre-arranged smoke to mask this movement. The destination: the rolling hills on the company team’s left flank. It only takes them two minutes to arrive at an appropriate attack-by-fire position. The two carriers rolling with them, carrying 1st squad of 1st platoon, and the FO, roll on towards the more complex terrain. Harmon pushes his men up for a quick attack by fire, but the engagement proves frustrating. Such a mass of enemy targets are impossible not to identify, but at such extended range, the small, speedy BMPs make difficult targets. Little is accomplished, and the 1LT doesn’t waste any further time in the position: he signals with his hands from his cupola, telling the section to orient on him. As the tanks pull back into cover and rumble on, the promised priorities of fire from the supporting 155 battery are released to Wren. The battery is immediately tasked to fire on the building concentrations of BMPs along Benchmark 2033 and Point 606.1. From his OP position, well forward, Wren can see more BMPs entering the area. It appears to be another company. Like the lead forces, this unit initially speeds across the dry Red Pass Lake, but then wheels smartly to the north and disappears behind Benchmark 2108. Are they heading for 1LT Harmon’s position? 1LT Harmon is trying to remain calm. There’s a lot of combat power driving right at the rest of the Company, and the compulsion to rush is almost overwhelming. “Move deliberately” he chides himself. “Slow is smooth and smooth is fast” he repeats to himself, mentally. The sandy desert floor was treacherous, and his tanks were likely to throw a track if they rushed unduly or made too sharp a change of direction. Nevertheless, he pressed his men on as fast as he dared. It took just shy of ten minutes to reach a second attack-by-fire position. This time, gunnery is much more satisfactory, aided no doubt by the fact that the BMPs are entering terrain they had previously ranged out. A BMP is destroyed at Point 2033. More and more BMPs array themselves on and around Hill 636.2 and Benchmark 2033. Harmon isn’t sure what they’re waiting for, but he’s glad they’ve stopped. His tank section continues their attack by fire, doing berm drills to avoid the growing attentions of his erstwhile targets, and the volleys of Sagger missiles they send his way. Then the artillery ordered by the CPT arrives. Bomblets immediately make an impression, and another BMP is flamed in the beaten zone, compelling BMPs to fall back in a hurry. The retrograde movement is fleeting. The moment arrives: the mass of BMPs, despite the discomfort of the artillery fire and Harmon’s flanking fire, surge forward. The MRC that had earlier disappeared to the north reappear, forming up only a ridge away from Harmon’s positions. Wren is able to raise his tank platoon commander on the net and inform him of the impending threat. A strained acknowledgement is received. To his relief, he sees the three M60s swiftly pull back and orient to face this. Would Harmon be able to hold with just three tanks and 12 dismounts? Pulling back to the main BP in time is simply out of the question. Wren winces, realising that to have asked such a small force to punch out so far forward was a mistake: he just hoped it wouldn’t be a fatal one. Little further time could be spent agonizing over the matter, as another MRC competes for his attention to the southeast. They are straddling the Bitter Springs MSR and flanking to the south. “The S-2 will be glad to hear how correct he was about the enemy scheme.” He thinks bitterly. Despite how well-predicted and doctrinal the assault was, it hadn’t done them a whit of good. Astonished by the pace of advance, they haven’t whittled down the lead OPFOR units anywhere near as much as they had hoped or planned. There was no time to dwell on that now. Nor was there time to alter the scheme. Wren was experienced enough to know to do so would only cause undue, possibly fatal confusion. “Time to get in this fight.” Scrambling down the sandy embankment, Wren rushes towards the nearest M60, waving it forward. He hoped that as the range closed rapidly, his own gunnery would become far more accurate. He had high expectations that this forward sniping position would put a hurting on the BMPs as they entered EA Blue. As the M60 rumbled up the ridge to a firing position, the SPC commanding the (under-strength) tank slips into the turret and slams the hatch shut behind him. His wingman, no doubt alerted via the platoon net, shortly does the same. One of the pair expertly two BMPs in as many shots, but before it can pull back into cover it is struck by a Sagger missile from somewhere to the north. The other M60 also finds success. It flames a BMP with its first shot, destroying it even as it attempts to return fire with a missile. A second round impacts on the next nearest BMP, which explodes with such violence that a third, trying to skirt around its stricken comrades, is also knocked out. The sudden violent attack by fire sows confusion, briefly, among the OPFOR . The BMPs must slow their rate of advance to push past their burning compatriots and deploy back into an effective line. CPT Wren and the surviving M60 take this opportunity to make good their escape, falling back across several ridges and washes to take position in the main BP. *** To 1LT Harmon what is happening several hundred meters to his right may as well be in a different universe. He is entirely preoccupied with the immediate fight, which rapidly descends into what can only be described as a confused melee. Upon being warned by the CO of the impending attack, he had just enough time to deploy his three tanks into somewhat effective battle positions. There was a massive blind spot on his left created by a low spur, and the best he could do in the time he had was to give vague orders to the infantry NCO to get over there and “deal with it.” No sooner had he given that unhelpful order, then the first OPFOR BMPs crested the ridge to his immediate front. All three TCs dropped into their cupolas, slamming their hatches in near unison. Three cannons snap in quick succession. Harmon had failed to assign any fire sectors. 3 HEAT rounds smash into the same BMP, which shudders and explodes violently. The next couple of volleys are better controlled by the hard-pressed platoon leader, and three more BMPs are destroyed. The OPFOR surge roars forward, almost heedless, and Harmon realises they’re going to go right through him at this pace. He urgently orders the tanks to retreat, heading for a ravine in the rear slope. Chaos reigns. Harmon bounces between the vision blocks in his cupola, in an attempt to figure out what the hell is happening. He’s astonished to see a BMP surge right past his tank, beelining into a scrub-filled ravine to his rear. Slewing the turret with the override, he gives the surprised gunner firing point procedures, even as he sprays frantically with the .50 calibre. The BMP is knocked out. “There’s a freakin’ BMP to our front, it’s practically kissing us!” it’s his driver on the intercom. Even as they were dealing with the BMP to their rear, another one had charged right at them. Harmon hadn’t even realised. The Gunner, calmer now, quickly slews the turret. The vehicle fills the entire FOV of his sight. At this range, he cannot miss. The BMP explodes in a fireball. Harmon’s two wingman tanks report their own successful engagements in similarly messy, point-blank scraps. The attached infantry are equally astonished to see BMPs driving right past them, their firing ports flashing and winking with rifle fire. Having grabbed as many LAWs as they could before dismounting, they are able to destroy several BMPs from the flank and rear. The M113s, hidden away in the washes near their dismounts, are likewise able to knock out a pair of BMPs, firing into their sides and rear. Belatedly, a few surviving BMPs disgorge dismounts, who try to work their way down into the washes. They are able to knock out the M113s as they crest a ridge but have more trouble dealing with the dismounts. In a shootout right out of a Western, they are sprayed down at close range and forced to retreat. It’s chaotic, it’s messy, but it ends decisively in Harmon’s favour. In two extremely confused minutes, he has removed an enemy company from the larger fight. He takes a minute, trying to restore his situational awareness (and his frayed nerves). The head count takes longer than he would like, and his stomach drops at the thought that all his dismounts are dead. The M113s don’t answer, and his worry mounts. Finally, breathing heavily, the FO NCO reports in and confirms his left is secure. He is also able to re-establish contact with the company HQ via radio and gives as accurate a SITREP as he can, given the circumstances. “Good, we’re still in this fight.” He concludes. “Alright, we need to sweep this ravine for any stragglers we missed. Gunner, scan every BMP, some might be playing dead and waiting for a chance shot. Driver, advance. Speed: 1.” *** Wren is equally focused on his immediate fight, and after having guided the surviving M60 into a good hide, has once again taken as exposed from which he could control the battle. 1LT Voegt, from his position near Benchmark 2124, reports the OPFOR beginning to dismount within EA blue. It's an excellent sign; the enemy would be basically fixed in position as they tried to climb up around the flanks with their dismounts first, at an infantry pace. 1st Platoon and the surviving M60 are now decisively engaged. It is 1320 hours. Then Wren’ radio squawks: “Alpha 26 send to Bravo 26: we are now exiting Sierra Whiskey.” Sierra Whiskey – the Sandy Wadi. A Company had arrived, with impeccable timing. Risking a somewhat lengthy radio message, CPT Wren does his best to update his counterpart on the current situation. The decision ultimately lies with A Team’s CPT: the counterattack is on…but how? Leaning out of his command track’s hatch, the newly arrived leader takes a moment to gather his thoughts. The thrust on the northern flank sounds like it had been stopped cold, if not destroyed. He could push his team in that direction, wheeling right to hit the enemy engaged in EA Blue from the flank and rear. Alternatively, he could push his entire team into the main BP and engage the deployed enemy head-on. He had to decide, and quick. Ultimately, he chooses the bolder option, rationalizing that wheeling right through B Team’s tank platoon would: Reinforce a success Help mop up any straggling or infiltrating enemy; and Avoid a complex forward passage of line through the main BP and into the teeth of an attacking MRC. Ordering a tank section to take a support-by-fire position near point 632.1, the rest of A Company (-) move out of the Sandy Wadi in column, keeping Point 632.1 to their right, and begin their attack. He informs CPT Wren of his scheme of manoeuvre. All 1st Platoon and its attachments must do is hold on. Cluster munitions shift, in the meantime, to deny the ground the OPFOR are attempting to advance through. The hope is that it will buy enough time to vector Cobras onto the surviving enemy. As A Co roars forward and through a brief danger area, the number 3 tank from the company’s tank platoon foolishly halts to engage a BMP several kilometres distant. It misses, badly, and is immediately struck by a Sagger missile for its wasted effort. The tank platoon leader can only swear to himself and urge the rest of his callsigns to be less foolish. It only takes a couple of minutes to link up with 1LT Harmon’s surviving callsigns. The hard-pressed armor officer was still rooting out surviving enemy dismounts and BMPs that were scattered around the ravine. In the hide-and-seek firefight that resulted after the melee, he had lost both M113s and one of his tanks had been damaged by a BMP’s 73mm gun. The point element of A Company arriving swings the balance firmly back in Harmon’s favour, and they announce its arrival in style, the lead tank knocking out one of these sheltering BMPs. As the tanks advance, they take small arms fire from surviving OPFOR dismounts, they report it for the following infantry and press on to link up with Harmon. The combined two tank sections take effective hull down positions and attack by fire. Despite the long range they are able to knock out several BMPs at the edge of EA Blue are knocked out. The enemy attack appears to be stalling, the main effort in EA Blue reduced to a bloody dismount-forward assault. Then the OPFOR helicopters arrive. Despite the VADs best efforts, the pilots skilfully evade and devastate the company mortar platoon with gun runs and rockets. The weapons platoon leader is killed in action during one of these attacks. While frustrating, and devastating to the rear area of B Team, it doesn’t give the attack the impetus it needs. The BMPs, taking cover as best they can in the washboard-like terrain in EA Blue, fill the air with Saggers, searching out for the surviving M60 which has been making a deadly nuisance of itself, ably directed by Wren into, and out of, firing positions. Eventually, however, the M60’s luck runs out. An enemy Sagger finally strikes, disabling the tank. Nevertheless, the MRBs losses rise inexorably. The “battlefield calculus” is overwhelmingly in A and B Team’s favour thus far. Back in the ravine, 1st Squad from B Team’s 1st Platoon continue to root out enemy dismounts. They are shortly joined by the infantry from A Team, who dismount behind a low berm and effectively engage the enemy, who have expertly and calmly sheltered in any fold of terrain they could find. They take casualties, but the firefights go overwhelmingly their way, often aided by the M113s. The battle is reaching its climax. The surviving BMPs are fighting gamely from decent cover, and at least of company of enemy dismounts are continuing to advance. Wren gets on the horn: “Bravo 26 send to Alpha 26.” “Alpha 26 here.” “Cobras are telling me they’re Winchester and we’re in a firefight here with multiple dismounts. If you’re going to make a move, make it now. Out” The stress is evident in Wren’s voice, and it spurs A Team’s leader to action. He tells his tank platoon (-) and to get moving, and the unengaged 2nd Platoon to follow and support. The three M60s do one final jockey into a firing position, scanning for targets, then roll up and over the ridge. The tanks surge forward, aiming to hit the rear of the OPFOR’s formation. Advancing on line and at a steady pace, they hose down the washboard terrain with coax, in an attempt to keep the OPFOR dismounts pinned. Despite the volume of fire, the platoon leader’s tank is disabled by a die-hard RPG gunner. Nevertheless, the two remaining M60s push through and begin to sweep away the surviving BMPs. While the balance of A Company is driving into the MRB’s flank and rear, its 1st Platoon, having finished mopping up OPFOR infiltrators, climbs Benchmark 2108. A beautiful sight greets them. Excitedly, the platoon FO requests for priority of fires. “We got the whole logistical tail of the MRB here!” – He gets his fire mission. Several minutes later, the 155 scattering the soft skins that are taking cover behind Hill 636.2 and destroying two. The roaring battle slowly peters out, as A Company’s 2nd Platoon root out the enemy from the washboard terrain. Even at this late stage, the OPFOR dismounts fight tenaciously. Almost all of them must be killed in close assaults by the riflemen. None surrender. Then, the radios across the Taskforce crackle: “End-ex, end-ex, end-ex.” The fight is over. Indeed, the battle and rotation are over. The burning vehicles and the dead men fade into what they really are: blinking MILEs lights and disappointed soldiers sitting cross legged on the desert floor, signalling they are “killed.” To Wren and the entirety of this TF however, it was real enough. This final fight was nothing short of harrowing. The OPFOR were relentless, quite literally storming through their positions at times. While the field of ruin that used to be an entire enemy MRB is a gratifying sight, and would appear to be clear evidence of a smashing success for the TF, determining who won was a matter of difficulty. Controversy ensues during the final AAR. The observers and evaluators can hardly agree among themselves how to rate the TF’s final performance. The OPFOR brigade commander, the NTC coordinator, ultimately declares it a minor defeat. He cites, absurdly to Wren’s mind, the dismounted losses taken by A and B Company Team as being unsustainable. Worse still, CPT Wren is criticized, though not with enthusiasm, for accepting a decisive engagement. The TF commander is lauded for his aggressive plan, and equally importantly, for trusting his subordinates with planning and command decisions. The LTC had the idea, and a framework, but how it was accomplished was rightly left to the two CPTs who would have to fight the actual battle. The tank losses are brought up and are bitterly criticized. The US Army CPT who was leading the main MRB battalion (the OPFOR always lead “one up”, so a LT often lead a company) is conspicuously and noticeably quiet throughout the debriefing. Wren and his counterpart in A Company take this as the greatest sign of how the battle really went. The vivid image of the MRB’s logistical units’ MILES indicators blinking in the desert heat was evidence enough for the officers and men of the TF. The criticisms raised did ring true, and the NTC had shown itself to be a harsh master. Years later, men of the TF would say it was, in many ways, harder than the real thing. The OPFOR pushed through often murderous fire with a unity of purpose and fearlessness that no unit could maintain in the face of such heavy losses. Real men in a real battle fear death, are awed by the sight of burning, twisted metal and flesh, the howl of artillery and the screaming of the wounded. No matter how realistic the NTC was, Wren mused, a self-confident OPFOR could never be convinced to halt their attack when they are simply resurrected for battle the next day. Despite this, the TF had won. This rotation was firm proof that the Soviets, the real opposing force, can and could be defeated. This is absolutely amazing! Great work. 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rinaldi Posted June 30, 2022 Author Share Posted June 30, 2022 Bit late on this one. Busy week at work. We're at the main event now: Germany. We don't join our intrepid core force just yet, however... *** The war arrived like a thunderclap. NATO units were doing a summer exercise, something had become almost rote in the decades since the Iron Curtain had fallen over Europe, when the bolt fell. Confusion reigned supreme. Some units at first even believed this was a highly realistic, unannounced part of the exercise. When real rounds of artillery began crashing around them and men began to die, that mistaken belief was rapidly abandoned. The Soviets had gained near total operational surprise. The only saving grace was the equally routine paranoia that gripped NATO forces when the Soviets conducted summer exercises (the cover for their invasion) themselves. When the Soviets rolled across the border, they found themselves tangling with strong, and alert, covering forces. Operational and Strategic surprise did not always translate to the tactical level. In the CENTAG zone, that meant bruising brushes with the 11th and 2nd Armored Cavalry regiments. Chapter 3: Apache Pass Forward Edge of the Battle Area. July 13th, 0600 hours. 1st Battalion, 15th Tank Regiment, 39th Motor Rifle Division “That is the plan, comrades. Combat aviation goes in at 0600. Our friends in the VVS follows 5 minutes after that. Artillery begins on these marked targets at 0615. We are across the line of departure in strength by 0620 hours. Questions?” Lieutenant Colonel Burobin looked around at his company commanders. Silence. Stony, determined stares. He folded the map and lightly slapped it against his knee. The briefing was over. “Very well. To your tanks, mount up.” They had several kilometres to traverse to get to the assembly area, a large, forested hill, labelled as the Dorn Berg. Recon was already well forward and had reported apparently light enemy forces entering the valley, no doubt to block further advances. His primary objective was a town in the middle of the valley, called Mittleaschenbach, which had vital bridges over the muddy streams that dominated the approaches to, and through, the valley. Seizing the town was key to creating manoeuvre room for the balance of the regiment. He had been tasked, as well, to take the next town (Hofaschenbach), if possible. As Burobin climbed on top of his T-64, he thought over the situation. The first hours of the war had gone exceedingly well, better than they it should have. The lead units had been lower echelon units with equipment in the process of being phased out, which had apparently set off less alarms with the enemy than the shock units normally would. Forward forces had brushed away surprised NATO forces, many of which were still on their routine summer exercises. Where breakthroughs hadn’t been made, the enemy had to pull back due to a lack of ammunition. In theory they had created the ideal scenario for his force: the “meeting engagement.” His mind turned to his immediate problem. The reports from regimental and divisional reconnaissance hinted that this window of opportunity was rapidly closing, if it was not already closed. They had no run-ins yet with the US so-called “armoured cavalry”, which he knew the Capitalists would put much faith in to hold, delay and destroy forces like his own. If he was the American, he thought grimly, this valley is where he would begin that delaying action. He was no fool and respected his opponents. If he realised the value of this terrain, he was assumed his counterparts did to. Where would they deploy? There were only two options, really… The terrain was complex and canalized. Muddy streams would force movement down only a handful of viable alleys. Thick forested hills blocked massed vehicular movement or restricted it to small dirt paths. A small force on these pieces of terrain could savage him. Speed. Speed was key. Without their air power, which regiment said would be negligible, the Americans could not hope to stop him. He did not share the Colonel’s belief that they were living under a ‘Red Sky.’ Not quite yet. Speed…speed was key. Even if it came at the cost of effective fire. Grab them by the belt… His thoughts were interrupted, the sanctuary of his thoughts shattered by a loud, booming roar. He looked up just in time to see two fighters, their wings swept back, red starts prominent on their tail, streak overhead in tight formation. Hugging the earth, they dipped out of sight, the canopy of the trees visibly swaying. The preparatory strikes had begun. He keyed his microphone and signalled the Battalion to begin its march. Then he slid down into the turret, ‘buttoning up’ his hatch as he did so. *** Darting forward cautiously, Soviet BRDMs nose into the Mittleschenbach valley. Moments earlier, four “Hind” helicopters had passed overhead, crossing the valley swiftly before disappearing over the opposite hill. The reconnaissance men could not yet know it, but the Hinds were already engaging American forces which were advancing to take blocking positions. Like their grandfathers in IL-2s, they swooped low, strafing enemy personnel carriers, and firing rockets in salvos. Two Hinds equipped with wire-guided missiles attempted to hit heavier targets, but were repeatedly forced to break off their attacks by enemy anti-helicopter missiles. Some BRDMs briefly halt among the treeline at the base of the Dorn Berg, having finally spotted the enemy: personnel carriers advancing despite the Hinds, into the valley. They duly report these contacts and decide to halt in their present positions to set up observation posts. Anti-tank BRDMs push into Oberaschenbach, losing a vehicle to an unseen assailant as they break cover. A survivor swiftly reports the village devoid of the enemy. The Soviet helicopters initially press their attack, despite the missiles. The BRDMs can see their handiwork now, as the Americans press on, zig-zagging and deploying smoke to frustrate the Hind’s aim. A Hind is blotted out of the sky by a missile, whilst an American APC explodes in a fireball from a direct hit. Panicking, the destroyed Hind’s wingman breaks off his attack entirely. A second APC is destroyed by a rocket run a moment later. With the APCs are tanks, who also zig-zag and pop smoke. They fare much better, and slide into the trees that line the Linz Berg – Ulmenstein gap. The enemy are on decisive terrain, although it has cost them. Would it be enough? Then the Migs arrive. Guided In by observation posts scattered around the valley, they scream in towards their pre-planned objectives, dropping cluster bombs on the towns that line the valley floor. Black smoke rises, evidencing their success. Despite the seemingly powerful air assault, the picture being built up by the lead recon elements is grim. The Americans have boldly seized decisive terrain, locking down the two best routes into the valley. Judging by the burning BRDM, they were also supported by anti-tank missiles of some kind. This was the situation which greeted the lead platoon of the 2/15th Tank Regiment as it entered the area of operations. They were met by one of the observation teams, who clambered on top of the lead T-64 and briefed the young (extremely young!) lieutenant. The lieutenant, wisely, if somewhat passively, decides to report the situation and hold for the rest of his company. He directs his tanks into the treeline, trusting even less than his battalion commander the assurances that the sky is Soviet. The next tank platoon to arrive from the company has a more aggressive, more senior lieutenant. Seeing six T-64s and supporting anti-tank BRDMs, he urges an engagement by fire on the powerful blocking force across the valley. If the enemy forces strung between Linz Berg and Ulmenstein were not destroyed or reduced, the attack would falter. The logic is iron-clad, despite the immense risk and the long odds. At 0610 hours they conduct their combined attack. The results are mixed. Gunnery is about even, despite the superior volume of fire the Soviets put out. Vehicles burn on both sides, and surviving T-64s pull back into the trees, their efforts spent for now. They leave two burning hulks, fires hissing away, as they do so. The surviving lieutenant, a bit alarmed at the enemy’s expert gunnery, urges his superior to hurry. A sharp rebuke - “Discipline, discipline, get off the air! Essential communications only!” – is his reward for his efforts. Burobin, monitoring the engagement on his second radio, is disquieted. He was in column with the battalion’s attached MRC and had just crossed the line of departure. It sounded like he was going to get a hot reception. He unbuttons briefly, and is engulfed in the dust being kicked up by the thundering herd. Coughing, he cranes his head up momentarily. A gap in the dust gives him a brief sight of the morning sky…there! Screaming overhead are two flying cruciform-like shapes. Suddenly, a BMP explodes. A second shortly follows. Sliding back into the turret, the Lt. Col hollers with such an urgency he fails to provide his callsign: “Air warning, air warning. Smoke and wheel right!” Thick, oily-black smoke blooms as more than 20 vehicles contribute to creating a smokescreen. They run the gauntlet, losing a few more vehicles in the process to both direct fire and air attack. The unit disperses into a small copse of trees, and the Shilkas deploy to defend the temporary harbour. The MRC’s air defence troops roll over the sides of their BMPs and attempt to engage the enemy air. It is uncertain what they accomplished. In cover of the forests and pines near the Dorn Berg, Burobin counts heads and collects his thoughts. His second company was still on its way but was surely also under air attack at present time. The enemy clearly had won the race; the meeting engagement was rapidly turning into a deliberate attack. It mattered not: he would have to accept a high attrition in men and material to seize the objective if so. He clambered out of his tank and looked for Major Istmin, the rifle company leader. The Major was alive, though looking decidedly unwell. Doing his best to ignore the pale pallor on his subordinate’s face, Burobin ordered him to disperse the BMPs and hold for now. They will go in as a unit. Striding back to his command tank, he stops to speak to the nearby FO in his specialist MTLB. The artillery will have to redouble its efforts. So it does. Guided on by the FOs, the Soviet artillery ponderously shifts its fire, striking enemy anti-tank vehicles that had taken hull down positions in a field of crops. Burobin requests for a repeat of the air strike, and to his shock, it is approved immediately. Regiment and Division, monitoring the situation, seem to have grasped the gravity of the situation. Under this cover of this artillery, Burobin urges on his point company. He knows the order has condemned more of his young tankers to fiery fates, but they must inflict more casualties on the enemy platoon holding the opposite heights if the rest of the Battalion are to safely transit. They do not, however, push heedlessly over the exposed ground. Realising the dangerousness of the mission, and the omnipresence of enemy air, the Major opts to push his surviving tanks through the claustrophobic hiking paths that line the Dorn Berg. This pushes the tanks several hundred meters forward. The hope is that the closer engagement range swings the balance in favour of the massed firepower. Time, the most precious resource the Soviets have, ticks away as the T-64s carefully pick their way down the path and fan out among the pines. The Major is patient. Not until every tank appears abreast of its partners does he order them to move forward. The excellence and effectiveness of enemy fire continues to shock the Soviet tankers. Several T-64s are burning within minutes, almost every other has sustained several hits. The massed fires, however, are inexorable. The MRC’s weapons platoon add to the fire, pushing their BMPs up to fire off missiles. One is destroyed, but its wingman reaches out with its Spandrel missile, destroying an enemy tank. Soon enough, most of the enemy vehicles between the Linz Berg and Ulmenstein are burning. All that remains is a single, unseen tank that sporadically fires. The timing is fortuitous, for Burobin's second tank company has arrived. Believing they are through; the Lt. Col immediately hurls his companies forward with an urgent word. Acknowledgements flood in. Then the enemy air power reappears, popping up over a neighbouring hill, their guns flashing. The Major commanding the second company is seen bailing out of his ruined tank, along with his crew. ZSU fire chases the enemy planes, and one explodes in a fireball as it careens into the side of a hill several kilometres away. The ZSUs themselves, out of ammunition, pull back into the treeline. Unknown to Burobin, the SA-7s are long dead. Their BMP hit by an air-delivered missile whilst the crews displaced to new firing positions. It is too late to stop now, however. The Battalion, what is left of it, lunges forward, the trailing platoons of T-64s stopping on occasion to deliver crashing volleys to any enemy targets they identify. The casualties are appalling. The Americans have put them in a vice. If they halt for any length of time to put down effective fire, they are smashed by American air and artillery. If they push forward, they find themselves moving into a storm of enemy direct fire. Despite destroying the enemy positions to their direct front, the battalion is punished by fire from secondary positions nearer Hofaschenbach. Burobin is faced with an unpalatable choice: butchery in place, or butchery forward. He chooses the latter, continuing to place his faith in speed. Soviet airpower makes a belated reappearance, and even the score card, somewhat. Enemy direct fire slackens, but bereft of anti-air defences, it is merely pro-forma. By the time the battalion has passed through Oberaschenbach, it is reduced to 5 tanks and 5 BMPs. It is a miracle that Burobin is alive. Even more miraculously, the Major leading the first company is among the living as well. Istmin burns along with his BMP, free from fear now. The MRCs only surviving officer is a young junior lieutenant. The other squads are not from his platoon. It matters not – what can be done except to accomplish their objective? Despair will not raise the dead. “All callsigns, guide on me” The Lt. Col speaks a terse word. There is no acknowledgement save from the first company leader’s tank. The other units cannot send, only receive. He must trust they are following. The surviving T-64s fan out on a hill just opposite the Linz Berg. They halt briefly in good hulldown positions. Burobin spots the surviving enemy tank first. A volley crashes out from the line of T-64s. The M60 burns. “We have no cover here. Follow me, we must head for that treeline. BMPs, break left and assault objective Fedor. Out.” Any idea of appropriate radio protocol died somewhere with his lead company. For the surviving "runners" in the unit there can be no doubt it is the Boss speaking. Spotting a gap in the trees and trusting that it heralded another wide trail through the forest, the T-64s break forward again. One explodes just as it begins to roll forward. It is unclear what destroys it. Nevertheless, the gamble pays off. A narrow, traversable path through the trees deposits the 4 remaining T-64s onto the flank of Mittleschenbach. They begin to fire systematically into the village, smashing suspected positions and covering the BMPs. The motor riflemen, for their part, also suffer in their final dash to the objective. Two BMPs are destroyed by American helicopters, skilfully flitting up and down behind a treeline somewhere to the left. The lieutenant, more frenzied by panic than determination, pushes forward. His men follow his example. They slow down, only briefly, to allow accurate cannon fire to be put down onto suspected positions. In one of the BMPs a sergeant orders his men to put down suppressive fires. The squad dutifully fire in staccato bursts through the firing ports. They know now who, or what, they are supposed to see. The American defenders, a rifle platoon, fight back viciously. The T-64s break cover and successfully rejoin their comrades in the village. Tank and BMP once more fight in close tandem. The order “dismount!” does not come until the town square is penetrated by surviving vehicles. Mittleschenbach is reduced to a charnel house as 125mms fire HEAT and HE into houses yards away. The Soviet riflemen are routinely forced to hurl themselves to the ground and duck into alleys to avoid the deadly overpressure from the high calibre cannons. Somehow, the shattered battalion manages to compel the defenders to retreat. A single American APC careens out of the village at 0655 hours, dipping into dead ground on the far side of town, before it motors away, out of sight. Any thought of pushing forward is out of the question. Even if Burobin’s shattered unit had the ammunition left to fight, they did not have the strength to advance. Even as the Soviets began to flatten Mittleschenbach, surviving OPs on the Dorn Berg report a platoon of enemy vehicles take blocking positions in the gardens and hedges at the forward edge of Hofaschenbach. The way forward had been closed, and leaving the safety of the town would only invite further air attack. The surviving vehicles circle the wagons as Burobin reports the objective clear and his casualties. “Regiment will deploy behind the Dorn Berg and pass through your unit at 1300 hours. Assume and maintain the defence in your current locus” comes the response with calculated disinterest, squealing through the enemy’s interference. On opposite sides of the FEBA, two counterparts, Colonels both, receive reports with some satisfaction. Casualties heavy, yes, but initial objectives met. 7 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Simcoe Posted July 1, 2022 Share Posted July 1, 2022 7 hours ago, Rinaldi said: Bit late on this one. Busy week at work. We're at the main event now: Germany. We don't join our intrepid core force just yet, however... *** The war arrived like a thunderclap. NATO units were doing a summer exercise, something had become almost rote in the decades since the Iron Curtain had fallen over Europe, when the bolt fell. Confusion reigned supreme. Some units at first even believed this was a highly realistic, unannounced part of the exercise. When real rounds of artillery began crashing around them and men began to die, that mistaken belief was rapidly abandoned. The Soviets had gained near total operational surprise. The only saving grace was the equally routine paranoia that gripped NATO forces when the Soviets conducted summer exercises (the cover for their invasion) themselves. When the Soviets rolled across the border, they found themselves tangling with strong, and alert, covering forces. Operational and Strategic surprise did not always translate to the tactical level. In the CENTAG zone, that meant bruising brushes with the 11th and 2nd Armored Cavalry regiments. Chapter 3: Apache Pass Forward Edge of the Battle Area. July 13th, 0600 hours. 1st Battalion, 15th Tank Regiment, 39th Motor Rifle Division “That is the plan, comrades. Combat aviation goes in at 0600. Our friends in the VVS follows 5 minutes after that. Artillery begins on these marked targets at 0615. We are across the line of departure in strength by 0620 hours. Questions?” Lieutenant Colonel Burobin looked around at his company commanders. Silence. Stony, determined stares. He folded the map and lightly slapped it against his knee. The briefing was over. “Very well. To your tanks, mount up.” They had several kilometres to traverse to get to the assembly area, a large, forested hill, labelled as the Dorn Berg. Recon was already well forward and had reported apparently light enemy forces entering the valley, no doubt to block further advances. His primary objective was a town in the middle of the valley, called Mittleaschenbach, which had vital bridges over the muddy streams that dominated the approaches to, and through, the valley. Seizing the town was key to creating manoeuvre room for the balance of the regiment. He had been tasked, as well, to take the next town (Hofaschenbach), if possible. As Burobin climbed on top of his T-64, he thought over the situation. The first hours of the war had gone exceedingly well, better than they it should have. The lead units had been lower echelon units with equipment in the process of being phased out, which had apparently set off less alarms with the enemy than the shock units normally would. Forward forces had brushed away surprised NATO forces, many of which were still on their routine summer exercises. Where breakthroughs hadn’t been made, the enemy had to pull back due to a lack of ammunition. In theory they had created the ideal scenario for his force: the “meeting engagement.” His mind turned to his immediate problem. The reports from regimental and divisional reconnaissance hinted that this window of opportunity was rapidly closing, if it was not already closed. They had no run-ins yet with the US so-called “armoured cavalry”, which he knew the Capitalists would put much faith in to hold, delay and destroy forces like his own. If he was the American, he thought grimly, this valley is where he would begin that delaying action. He was no fool and respected his opponents. If he realised the value of this terrain, he was assumed his counterparts did to. Where would they deploy? There were only two options, really… The terrain was complex and canalized. Muddy streams would force movement down only a handful of viable alleys. Thick forested hills blocked massed vehicular movement or restricted it to small dirt paths. A small force on these pieces of terrain could savage him. Speed. Speed was key. Without their air power, which regiment said would be negligible, the Americans could not hope to stop him. He did not share the Colonel’s belief that they were living under a ‘Red Sky.’ Not quite yet. Speed…speed was key. Even if it came at the cost of effective fire. Grab them by the belt… His thoughts were interrupted, the sanctuary of his thoughts shattered by a loud, booming roar. He looked up just in time to see two fighters, their wings swept back, red starts prominent on their tail, streak overhead in tight formation. Hugging the earth, they dipped out of sight, the canopy of the trees visibly swaying. The preparatory strikes had begun. He keyed his microphone and signalled the Battalion to begin its march. Then he slid down into the turret, ‘buttoning up’ his hatch as he did so. *** Darting forward cautiously, Soviet BRDMs nose into the Mittleschenbach valley. Moments earlier, four “Hind” helicopters had passed overhead, crossing the valley swiftly before disappearing over the opposite hill. The reconnaissance men could not yet know it, but the Hinds were already engaging American forces which were advancing to take blocking positions. Like their grandfathers in IL-2s, they swooped low, strafing enemy personnel carriers, and firing rockets in salvos. Two Hinds equipped with wire-guided missiles attempted to hit heavier targets, but were repeatedly forced to break off their attacks by enemy anti-helicopter missiles. Some BRDMs briefly halt among the treeline at the base of the Dorn Berg, having finally spotted the enemy: personnel carriers advancing despite the Hinds, into the valley. They duly report these contacts and decide to halt in their present positions to set up observation posts. Anti-tank BRDMs push into Oberaschenbach, losing a vehicle to an unseen assailant as they break cover. A survivor swiftly reports the village devoid of the enemy. The Soviet helicopters initially press their attack, despite the missiles. The BRDMs can see their handiwork now, as the Americans press on, zig-zagging and deploying smoke to frustrate the Hind’s aim. A Hind is blotted out of the sky by a missile, whilst an American APC explodes in a fireball from a direct hit. Panicking, the destroyed Hind’s wingman breaks off his attack entirely. A second APC is destroyed by a rocket run a moment later. With the APCs are tanks, who also zig-zag and pop smoke. They fare much better, and slide into the trees that line the Linz Berg – Ulmenstein gap. The enemy are on decisive terrain, although it has cost them. Would it be enough? Then the Migs arrive. Guided In by observation posts scattered around the valley, they scream in towards their pre-planned objectives, dropping cluster bombs on the towns that line the valley floor. Black smoke rises, evidencing their success. Despite the seemingly powerful air assault, the picture being built up by the lead recon elements is grim. The Americans have boldly seized decisive terrain, locking down the two best routes into the valley. Judging by the burning BRDM, they were also supported by anti-tank missiles of some kind. This was the situation which greeted the lead platoon of the 2/15th Tank Regiment as it entered the area of operations. They were met by one of the observation teams, who clambered on top of the lead T-64 and briefed the young (extremely young!) lieutenant. The lieutenant, wisely, if somewhat passively, decides to report the situation and hold for the rest of his company. He directs his tanks into the treeline, trusting even less than his battalion commander the assurances that the sky is Soviet. The next tank platoon to arrive from the company has a more aggressive, more senior lieutenant. Seeing six T-64s and supporting anti-tank BRDMs, he urges an engagement by fire on the powerful blocking force across the valley. If the enemy forces strung between Linz Berg and Ulmenstein were not destroyed or reduced, the attack would falter. The logic is iron-clad, despite the immense risk and the long odds. At 0610 hours they conduct their combined attack. The results are mixed. Gunnery is about even, despite the superior volume of fire the Soviets put out. Vehicles burn on both sides, and surviving T-64s pull back into the trees, their efforts spent for now. They leave two burning hulks, fires hissing away, as they do so. The surviving lieutenant, a bit alarmed at the enemy’s expert gunnery, urges his superior to hurry. A sharp rebuke - “Discipline, discipline, get off the air! Essential communications only!” – is his reward for his efforts. Burobin, monitoring the engagement on his second radio, is disquieted. He was in column with the battalion’s attached MRC and had just crossed the line of departure. It sounded like he was going to get a hot reception. He unbuttons briefly, and is engulfed in the dust being kicked up by the thundering herd. Coughing, he cranes his head up momentarily. A gap in the dust gives him a brief sight of the morning sky…there! Screaming overhead are two flying cruciform-like shapes. Suddenly, a BMP explodes. A second shortly follows. Sliding back into the turret, the Lt. Col hollers with such an urgency he fails to provide his callsign: “Air warning, air warning. Smoke and wheel right!” Thick, oily-black smoke blooms as more than 20 vehicles contribute to creating a smokescreen. They run the gauntlet, losing a few more vehicles in the process to both direct fire and air attack. The unit disperses into a small copse of trees, and the Shilkas deploy to defend the temporary harbour. The MRC’s air defence troops roll over the sides of their BMPs and attempt to engage the enemy air. It is uncertain what they accomplished. In cover of the forests and pines near the Dorn Berg, Burobin counts heads and collects his thoughts. His second company was still on its way but was surely also under air attack at present time. The enemy clearly had won the race; the meeting engagement was rapidly turning into a deliberate attack. It mattered not: he would have to accept a high attrition in men and material to seize the objective if so. He clambered out of his tank and looked for Major Istmin, the rifle company leader. The Major was alive, though looking decidedly unwell. Doing his best to ignore the pale pallor on his subordinate’s face, Burobin ordered him to disperse the BMPs and hold for now. They will go in as a unit. Striding back to his command tank, he stops to speak to the nearby FO in his specialist MTLB. The artillery will have to redouble its efforts. So it does. Guided on by the FOs, the Soviet artillery ponderously shifts its fire, striking enemy anti-tank vehicles that had taken hull down positions in a field of crops. Burobin requests for a repeat of the air strike, and to his shock, it is approved immediately. Regiment and Division, monitoring the situation, seem to have grasped the gravity of the situation. Under this cover of this artillery, Burobin urges on his point company. He knows the order has condemned more of his young tankers to fiery fates, but they must inflict more casualties on the enemy platoon holding the opposite heights if the rest of the Battalion are to safely transit. They do not, however, push heedlessly over the exposed ground. Realising the dangerousness of the mission, and the omnipresence of enemy air, the Major opts to push his surviving tanks through the claustrophobic hiking paths that line the Dorn Berg. This pushes the tanks several hundred meters forward. The hope is that the closer engagement range swings the balance in favour of the massed firepower. Time, the most precious resource the Soviets have, ticks away as the T-64s carefully pick their way down the path and fan out among the pines. The Major is patient. Not until every tank appears abreast of its partners does he order them to move forward. The excellence and effectiveness of enemy fire continues to shock the Soviet tankers. Several T-64s are burning within minutes, almost every other has sustained several hits. The massed fires, however, are inexorable. The MRC’s weapons platoon add to the fire, pushing their BMPs up to fire off missiles. One is destroyed, but its wingman reaches out with its Spandrel missile, destroying an enemy tank. Soon enough, most of the enemy vehicles between the Linz Berg and Ulmenstein are burning. All that remains is a single, unseen tank that sporadically fires. The timing is fortuitous, for Burobin's second tank company has arrived. Believing they are through; the Lt. Col immediately hurls his companies forward with an urgent word. Acknowledgements flood in. Then the enemy air power reappears, popping up over a neighbouring hill, their guns flashing. The Major commanding the second company is seen bailing out of his ruined tank, along with his crew. ZSU fire chases the enemy planes, and one explodes in a fireball as it careens into the side of a hill several kilometres away. The ZSUs themselves, out of ammunition, pull back into the treeline. Unknown to Burobin, the SA-7s are long dead. Their BMP hit by an air-delivered missile whilst the crews displaced to new firing positions. It is too late to stop now, however. The Battalion, what is left of it, lunges forward, the trailing platoons of T-64s stopping on occasion to deliver crashing volleys to any enemy targets they identify. The casualties are appalling. The Americans have put them in a vice. If they halt for any length of time to put down effective fire, they are smashed by American air and artillery. If they push forward, they find themselves moving into a storm of enemy direct fire. Despite destroying the enemy positions to their direct front, the battalion is punished by fire from secondary positions nearer Hofaschenbach. Burobin is faced with an unpalatable choice: butchery in place, or butchery forward. He chooses the latter, continuing to place his faith in speed. Soviet airpower makes a belated reappearance, and even the score card, somewhat. Enemy direct fire slackens, but bereft of anti-air defences, it is merely pro-forma. By the time the battalion has passed through Oberaschenbach, it is reduced to 5 tanks and 5 BMPs. It is a miracle that Burobin is alive. Even more miraculously, the Major leading the first company is among the living as well. Istmin burns along with his BMP, free from fear now. The MRCs only surviving officer is a young junior lieutenant. The other squads are not from his platoon. It matters not – what can be done except to accomplish their objective? Despair will not raise the dead. “All callsigns, guide on me” The Lt. Col speaks a terse word. There is no acknowledgement save from the first company leader’s tank. The other units cannot send, only receive. He must trust they are following. The surviving T-64s fan out on a hill just opposite the Linz Berg. They halt briefly in good hulldown positions. Burobin spots the surviving enemy tank first. A volley crashes out from the line of T-64s. The M60 burns. “We have no cover here. Follow me, we must head for that treeline. BMPs, break left and assault objective Fedor. Out.” Any idea of appropriate radio protocol died somewhere with his lead company. For the surviving "runners" in the unit there can be no doubt it is the Boss speaking. Spotting a gap in the trees and trusting that it heralded another wide trail through the forest, the T-64s break forward again. One explodes just as it begins to roll forward. It is unclear what destroys it. Nevertheless, the gamble pays off. A narrow, traversable path through the trees deposits the 4 remaining T-64s onto the flank of Mittleschenbach. They begin to fire systematically into the village, smashing suspected positions and covering the BMPs. The motor riflemen, for their part, also suffer in their final dash to the objective. Two BMPs are destroyed by American helicopters, skilfully flitting up and down behind a treeline somewhere to the left. The lieutenant, more frenzied by panic than determination, pushes forward. His men follow his example. They slow down, only briefly, to allow accurate cannon fire to be put down onto suspected positions. In one of the BMPs a sergeant orders his men to put down suppressive fires. The squad dutifully fire in staccato bursts through the firing ports. They know now who, or what, they are supposed to see. The American defenders, a rifle platoon, fight back viciously. The T-64s break cover and successfully rejoin their comrades in the village. Tank and BMP once more fight in close tandem. The order “dismount!” does not come until the town square is penetrated by surviving vehicles. Mittleschenbach is reduced to a charnel house as 125mms fire HEAT and HE into houses yards away. The Soviet riflemen are routinely forced to hurl themselves to the ground and duck into alleys to avoid the deadly overpressure from the high calibre cannons. Somehow, the shattered battalion manages to compel the defenders to retreat. A single American APC careens out of the village at 0655 hours, dipping into dead ground on the far side of town, before it motors away, out of sight. Any thought of pushing forward is out of the question. Even if Burobin’s shattered unit had the ammunition left to fight, they did not have the strength to advance. Even as the Soviets began to flatten Mittleschenbach, surviving OPs on the Dorn Berg report a platoon of enemy vehicles take blocking positions in the gardens and hedges at the forward edge of Hofaschenbach. The way forward had been closed, and leaving the safety of the town would only invite further air attack. The surviving vehicles circle the wagons as Burobin reports the objective clear and his casualties. “Regiment will deploy behind the Dorn Berg and pass through your unit at 1300 hours. Assume and maintain the defence in your current locus” comes the response with calculated disinterest, squealing through the enemy’s interference. On opposite sides of the FEBA, two counterparts, Colonels both, receive reports with some satisfaction. Casualties heavy, yes, but initial objectives met. This was great! Would you have preferred a motor rifle battalion with attached tank company compared to a tank battalion with motor rifle company? I think Soviet handheld AT weapons are highly underrated. 0 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Halmbarte Posted July 1, 2022 Share Posted July 1, 2022 1 hour ago, Simcoe said: This was great! Would you have preferred a motor rifle battalion with attached tank company compared to a tank battalion with motor rifle company? I think Soviet handheld AT weapons are highly underrated. The AT7 and AT4 are great ATGMs. The AT7 is as good as the Dragon if not better and the vehicle carries a lot of reloads. The AT4 has almost as much range as TOW and is much more portable with a lot of reloads on the vehicle. Either will wreck a M60 from the front. H 0 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
The_Capt Posted July 1, 2022 Share Posted July 1, 2022 18 hours ago, Rinaldi said: Bit late on this one. Busy week at work. We're at the main event now: Germany. We don't join our intrepid core force just yet, however... *** The war arrived like a thunderclap. NATO units were doing a summer exercise, something had become almost rote in the decades since the Iron Curtain had fallen over Europe, when the bolt fell. Confusion reigned supreme. Some units at first even believed this was a highly realistic, unannounced part of the exercise. When real rounds of artillery began crashing around them and men began to die, that mistaken belief was rapidly abandoned. The Soviets had gained near total operational surprise. The only saving grace was the equally routine paranoia that gripped NATO forces when the Soviets conducted summer exercises (the cover for their invasion) themselves. When the Soviets rolled across the border, they found themselves tangling with strong, and alert, covering forces. Operational and Strategic surprise did not always translate to the tactical level. In the CENTAG zone, that meant bruising brushes with the 11th and 2nd Armored Cavalry regiments. Chapter 3: Apache Pass Forward Edge of the Battle Area. July 13th, 0600 hours. 1st Battalion, 15th Tank Regiment, 39th Motor Rifle Division “That is the plan, comrades. Combat aviation goes in at 0600. Our friends in the VVS follows 5 minutes after that. Artillery begins on these marked targets at 0615. We are across the line of departure in strength by 0620 hours. Questions?” Lieutenant Colonel Burobin looked around at his company commanders. Silence. Stony, determined stares. He folded the map and lightly slapped it against his knee. The briefing was over. “Very well. To your tanks, mount up.” They had several kilometres to traverse to get to the assembly area, a large, forested hill, labelled as the Dorn Berg. Recon was already well forward and had reported apparently light enemy forces entering the valley, no doubt to block further advances. His primary objective was a town in the middle of the valley, called Mittleaschenbach, which had vital bridges over the muddy streams that dominated the approaches to, and through, the valley. Seizing the town was key to creating manoeuvre room for the balance of the regiment. He had been tasked, as well, to take the next town (Hofaschenbach), if possible. As Burobin climbed on top of his T-64, he thought over the situation. The first hours of the war had gone exceedingly well, better than they it should have. The lead units had been lower echelon units with equipment in the process of being phased out, which had apparently set off less alarms with the enemy than the shock units normally would. Forward forces had brushed away surprised NATO forces, many of which were still on their routine summer exercises. Where breakthroughs hadn’t been made, the enemy had to pull back due to a lack of ammunition. In theory they had created the ideal scenario for his force: the “meeting engagement.” His mind turned to his immediate problem. The reports from regimental and divisional reconnaissance hinted that this window of opportunity was rapidly closing, if it was not already closed. They had no run-ins yet with the US so-called “armoured cavalry”, which he knew the Capitalists would put much faith in to hold, delay and destroy forces like his own. If he was the American, he thought grimly, this valley is where he would begin that delaying action. He was no fool and respected his opponents. If he realised the value of this terrain, he was assumed his counterparts did to. Where would they deploy? There were only two options, really… The terrain was complex and canalized. Muddy streams would force movement down only a handful of viable alleys. Thick forested hills blocked massed vehicular movement or restricted it to small dirt paths. A small force on these pieces of terrain could savage him. Speed. Speed was key. Without their air power, which regiment said would be negligible, the Americans could not hope to stop him. He did not share the Colonel’s belief that they were living under a ‘Red Sky.’ Not quite yet. Speed…speed was key. Even if it came at the cost of effective fire. Grab them by the belt… His thoughts were interrupted, the sanctuary of his thoughts shattered by a loud, booming roar. He looked up just in time to see two fighters, their wings swept back, red starts prominent on their tail, streak overhead in tight formation. Hugging the earth, they dipped out of sight, the canopy of the trees visibly swaying. The preparatory strikes had begun. He keyed his microphone and signalled the Battalion to begin its march. Then he slid down into the turret, ‘buttoning up’ his hatch as he did so. *** Darting forward cautiously, Soviet BRDMs nose into the Mittleschenbach valley. Moments earlier, four “Hind” helicopters had passed overhead, crossing the valley swiftly before disappearing over the opposite hill. The reconnaissance men could not yet know it, but the Hinds were already engaging American forces which were advancing to take blocking positions. Like their grandfathers in IL-2s, they swooped low, strafing enemy personnel carriers, and firing rockets in salvos. Two Hinds equipped with wire-guided missiles attempted to hit heavier targets, but were repeatedly forced to break off their attacks by enemy anti-helicopter missiles. Some BRDMs briefly halt among the treeline at the base of the Dorn Berg, having finally spotted the enemy: personnel carriers advancing despite the Hinds, into the valley. They duly report these contacts and decide to halt in their present positions to set up observation posts. Anti-tank BRDMs push into Oberaschenbach, losing a vehicle to an unseen assailant as they break cover. A survivor swiftly reports the village devoid of the enemy. The Soviet helicopters initially press their attack, despite the missiles. The BRDMs can see their handiwork now, as the Americans press on, zig-zagging and deploying smoke to frustrate the Hind’s aim. A Hind is blotted out of the sky by a missile, whilst an American APC explodes in a fireball from a direct hit. Panicking, the destroyed Hind’s wingman breaks off his attack entirely. A second APC is destroyed by a rocket run a moment later. With the APCs are tanks, who also zig-zag and pop smoke. They fare much better, and slide into the trees that line the Linz Berg – Ulmenstein gap. The enemy are on decisive terrain, although it has cost them. Would it be enough? Then the Migs arrive. Guided In by observation posts scattered around the valley, they scream in towards their pre-planned objectives, dropping cluster bombs on the towns that line the valley floor. Black smoke rises, evidencing their success. Despite the seemingly powerful air assault, the picture being built up by the lead recon elements is grim. The Americans have boldly seized decisive terrain, locking down the two best routes into the valley. Judging by the burning BRDM, they were also supported by anti-tank missiles of some kind. This was the situation which greeted the lead platoon of the 2/15th Tank Regiment as it entered the area of operations. They were met by one of the observation teams, who clambered on top of the lead T-64 and briefed the young (extremely young!) lieutenant. The lieutenant, wisely, if somewhat passively, decides to report the situation and hold for the rest of his company. He directs his tanks into the treeline, trusting even less than his battalion commander the assurances that the sky is Soviet. The next tank platoon to arrive from the company has a more aggressive, more senior lieutenant. Seeing six T-64s and supporting anti-tank BRDMs, he urges an engagement by fire on the powerful blocking force across the valley. If the enemy forces strung between Linz Berg and Ulmenstein were not destroyed or reduced, the attack would falter. The logic is iron-clad, despite the immense risk and the long odds. At 0610 hours they conduct their combined attack. The results are mixed. Gunnery is about even, despite the superior volume of fire the Soviets put out. Vehicles burn on both sides, and surviving T-64s pull back into the trees, their efforts spent for now. They leave two burning hulks, fires hissing away, as they do so. The surviving lieutenant, a bit alarmed at the enemy’s expert gunnery, urges his superior to hurry. A sharp rebuke - “Discipline, discipline, get off the air! Essential communications only!” – is his reward for his efforts. Burobin, monitoring the engagement on his second radio, is disquieted. He was in column with the battalion’s attached MRC and had just crossed the line of departure. It sounded like he was going to get a hot reception. He unbuttons briefly, and is engulfed in the dust being kicked up by the thundering herd. Coughing, he cranes his head up momentarily. A gap in the dust gives him a brief sight of the morning sky…there! Screaming overhead are two flying cruciform-like shapes. Suddenly, a BMP explodes. A second shortly follows. Sliding back into the turret, the Lt. Col hollers with such an urgency he fails to provide his callsign: “Air warning, air warning. Smoke and wheel right!” Thick, oily-black smoke blooms as more than 20 vehicles contribute to creating a smokescreen. They run the gauntlet, losing a few more vehicles in the process to both direct fire and air attack. The unit disperses into a small copse of trees, and the Shilkas deploy to defend the temporary harbour. The MRC’s air defence troops roll over the sides of their BMPs and attempt to engage the enemy air. It is uncertain what they accomplished. In cover of the forests and pines near the Dorn Berg, Burobin counts heads and collects his thoughts. His second company was still on its way but was surely also under air attack at present time. The enemy clearly had won the race; the meeting engagement was rapidly turning into a deliberate attack. It mattered not: he would have to accept a high attrition in men and material to seize the objective if so. He clambered out of his tank and looked for Major Istmin, the rifle company leader. The Major was alive, though looking decidedly unwell. Doing his best to ignore the pale pallor on his subordinate’s face, Burobin ordered him to disperse the BMPs and hold for now. They will go in as a unit. Striding back to his command tank, he stops to speak to the nearby FO in his specialist MTLB. The artillery will have to redouble its efforts. So it does. Guided on by the FOs, the Soviet artillery ponderously shifts its fire, striking enemy anti-tank vehicles that had taken hull down positions in a field of crops. Burobin requests for a repeat of the air strike, and to his shock, it is approved immediately. Regiment and Division, monitoring the situation, seem to have grasped the gravity of the situation. Under this cover of this artillery, Burobin urges on his point company. He knows the order has condemned more of his young tankers to fiery fates, but they must inflict more casualties on the enemy platoon holding the opposite heights if the rest of the Battalion are to safely transit. They do not, however, push heedlessly over the exposed ground. Realising the dangerousness of the mission, and the omnipresence of enemy air, the Major opts to push his surviving tanks through the claustrophobic hiking paths that line the Dorn Berg. This pushes the tanks several hundred meters forward. The hope is that the closer engagement range swings the balance in favour of the massed firepower. Time, the most precious resource the Soviets have, ticks away as the T-64s carefully pick their way down the path and fan out among the pines. The Major is patient. Not until every tank appears abreast of its partners does he order them to move forward. The excellence and effectiveness of enemy fire continues to shock the Soviet tankers. Several T-64s are burning within minutes, almost every other has sustained several hits. The massed fires, however, are inexorable. The MRC’s weapons platoon add to the fire, pushing their BMPs up to fire off missiles. One is destroyed, but its wingman reaches out with its Spandrel missile, destroying an enemy tank. Soon enough, most of the enemy vehicles between the Linz Berg and Ulmenstein are burning. All that remains is a single, unseen tank that sporadically fires. The timing is fortuitous, for Burobin's second tank company has arrived. Believing they are through; the Lt. Col immediately hurls his companies forward with an urgent word. Acknowledgements flood in. Then the enemy air power reappears, popping up over a neighbouring hill, their guns flashing. The Major commanding the second company is seen bailing out of his ruined tank, along with his crew. ZSU fire chases the enemy planes, and one explodes in a fireball as it careens into the side of a hill several kilometres away. The ZSUs themselves, out of ammunition, pull back into the treeline. Unknown to Burobin, the SA-7s are long dead. Their BMP hit by an air-delivered missile whilst the crews displaced to new firing positions. It is too late to stop now, however. The Battalion, what is left of it, lunges forward, the trailing platoons of T-64s stopping on occasion to deliver crashing volleys to any enemy targets they identify. The casualties are appalling. The Americans have put them in a vice. If they halt for any length of time to put down effective fire, they are smashed by American air and artillery. If they push forward, they find themselves moving into a storm of enemy direct fire. Despite destroying the enemy positions to their direct front, the battalion is punished by fire from secondary positions nearer Hofaschenbach. Burobin is faced with an unpalatable choice: butchery in place, or butchery forward. He chooses the latter, continuing to place his faith in speed. Soviet airpower makes a belated reappearance, and even the score card, somewhat. Enemy direct fire slackens, but bereft of anti-air defences, it is merely pro-forma. By the time the battalion has passed through Oberaschenbach, it is reduced to 5 tanks and 5 BMPs. It is a miracle that Burobin is alive. Even more miraculously, the Major leading the first company is among the living as well. Istmin burns along with his BMP, free from fear now. The MRCs only surviving officer is a young junior lieutenant. The other squads are not from his platoon. It matters not – what can be done except to accomplish their objective? Despair will not raise the dead. “All callsigns, guide on me” The Lt. Col speaks a terse word. There is no acknowledgement save from the first company leader’s tank. The other units cannot send, only receive. He must trust they are following. The surviving T-64s fan out on a hill just opposite the Linz Berg. They halt briefly in good hulldown positions. Burobin spots the surviving enemy tank first. A volley crashes out from the line of T-64s. The M60 burns. “We have no cover here. Follow me, we must head for that treeline. BMPs, break left and assault objective Fedor. Out.” Any idea of appropriate radio protocol died somewhere with his lead company. For the surviving "runners" in the unit there can be no doubt it is the Boss speaking. Spotting a gap in the trees and trusting that it heralded another wide trail through the forest, the T-64s break forward again. One explodes just as it begins to roll forward. It is unclear what destroys it. Nevertheless, the gamble pays off. A narrow, traversable path through the trees deposits the 4 remaining T-64s onto the flank of Mittleschenbach. They begin to fire systematically into the village, smashing suspected positions and covering the BMPs. The motor riflemen, for their part, also suffer in their final dash to the objective. Two BMPs are destroyed by American helicopters, skilfully flitting up and down behind a treeline somewhere to the left. The lieutenant, more frenzied by panic than determination, pushes forward. His men follow his example. They slow down, only briefly, to allow accurate cannon fire to be put down onto suspected positions. In one of the BMPs a sergeant orders his men to put down suppressive fires. The squad dutifully fire in staccato bursts through the firing ports. They know now who, or what, they are supposed to see. The American defenders, a rifle platoon, fight back viciously. The T-64s break cover and successfully rejoin their comrades in the village. Tank and BMP once more fight in close tandem. The order “dismount!” does not come until the town square is penetrated by surviving vehicles. Mittleschenbach is reduced to a charnel house as 125mms fire HEAT and HE into houses yards away. The Soviet riflemen are routinely forced to hurl themselves to the ground and duck into alleys to avoid the deadly overpressure from the high calibre cannons. Somehow, the shattered battalion manages to compel the defenders to retreat. A single American APC careens out of the village at 0655 hours, dipping into dead ground on the far side of town, before it motors away, out of sight. Any thought of pushing forward is out of the question. Even if Burobin’s shattered unit had the ammunition left to fight, they did not have the strength to advance. Even as the Soviets began to flatten Mittleschenbach, surviving OPs on the Dorn Berg report a platoon of enemy vehicles take blocking positions in the gardens and hedges at the forward edge of Hofaschenbach. The way forward had been closed, and leaving the safety of the town would only invite further air attack. The surviving vehicles circle the wagons as Burobin reports the objective clear and his casualties. “Regiment will deploy behind the Dorn Berg and pass through your unit at 1300 hours. Assume and maintain the defence in your current locus” comes the response with calculated disinterest, squealing through the enemy’s interference. On opposite sides of the FEBA, two counterparts, Colonels both, receive reports with some satisfaction. Casualties heavy, yes, but initial objectives met. The real war! 0 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rinaldi Posted July 1, 2022 Author Share Posted July 1, 2022 (edited) 8 hours ago, The_Capt said: The real war! Yes indeed, and more to come. 19 hours ago, Simcoe said: This was great! Would you have preferred a motor rifle battalion with attached tank company compared to a tank battalion with motor rifle company? I think Soviet handheld AT weapons are highly underrated. So, I'll preface my answer by admitting it didn't cross my mind. In hindsight, sure, of course, but to do so would defeat what makes Valley of Ashes a good tactical problem. It's capturing a Soviet operational misfire at the tactical level, in short. It does that well. The Tank Battalion is a pursuit weapon in ideal circumstances. It's meant to be used for meeting engagements ("movements to contact") and exploitation. The premise of course is that the Soviets think they have a situation that warrants putting the tanks out front. They don't, and now they have to push through in absolutely atrocious terrain because time pressure simply does not allow for a reorganisation. I wouldn't change a single iota of Valley of Ashes, it's one of the strongest standalones I've played thus far from the Soviet perspective. The fact it is in the same timeline as the campaigns also makes it a nice little 'prelude.' The AI plans are excellent, and the fire support you receive on both sides is absolutely true-to-life. Am I happy with a draw? Only in hindsight; the silver lining of the entire affair was how effective my air power was. 17 hours ago, Halmbarte said: The AT7 and AT4 are great ATGMs. The AT7 is as good as the Dragon if not better and the vehicle carries a lot of reloads. The AT4 has almost as much range as TOW and is much more portable with a lot of reloads on the vehicle. Either will wreck a M60 from the front. H All good points. That having been said: I doubt very much it would've made much of a difference. The company level weapons lack the range to be offensive weapons in this type of terrain. AT4s are a different matter, sure, but their proliferation at even the Battalion level isn't going to be a silver bullet. Furthermore, given how much any type of pause brings down the thunder (and rightly so), dismounting for a deliberate attack is foolish in the extreme in the grand scheme of things. It is worth noting that the BTR/BMP formations are broadly meant to be handled the same way. I don't think the time pressure in the scenario allows for much infiltration by infantry. Edited July 1, 2022 by Rinaldi 2 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
domfluff Posted July 1, 2022 Share Posted July 1, 2022 Yup yup. Valley of Ashes is a scenario which is weighted against the Soviets, because it's intended to be - the challenge is an attack through some deceptively poor and canalising terrain, and trying to make good. My first run through was also a draw (as you saw), and whilst I know I could have done better if I'd paused at the near objective, I pushed on and gave up the points in the process. I'm certain it's possible to do better than I did in that scenario. It's a tough challenge, but a fair one - the scenario is plausible and the representation convincing. I do agree that it's one of the stronger stand alone scenarios in Cold War. I've mentioned before that I think the correct way to think about "balance" in simulationist games is not a scenario where both sides have a 50% chance of winning. That kind of mentality has dominated the hobby space forever (Paddy Griffith wrote a whole essay about it decades ago, in relation to some of the WRG rulesets), and the idea that wargame should be two equal forces across an open table having a little fight is one that really stops thinking far too early, in my opinion, and it fails to really take advantage of some of the depth that this kind of deep simulation can offer. Instead of "both sides have an equally high chance of winning", I prefer something like "both sides have an equally interesting problem to solve". It's nice if you can tie up asymmetric objectives to represent that, but in most cases what it actually says on the victory screen is of secondary importance to the process. 3 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Simcoe Posted July 1, 2022 Share Posted July 1, 2022 1 hour ago, domfluff said: Yup yup. Valley of Ashes is a scenario which is weighted against the Soviets, because it's intended to be - the challenge is an attack through some deceptively poor and canalising terrain, and trying to make good. My first run through was also a draw (as you saw), and whilst I know I could have done better if I'd paused at the near objective, I pushed on and gave up the points in the process. I'm certain it's possible to do better than I did in that scenario. It's a tough challenge, but a fair one - the scenario is plausible and the representation convincing. I do agree that it's one of the stronger stand alone scenarios in Cold War. I've mentioned before that I think the correct way to think about "balance" in simulationist games is not a scenario where both sides have a 50% chance of winning. That kind of mentality has dominated the hobby space forever (Paddy Griffith wrote a whole essay about it decades ago, in relation to some of the WRG rulesets), and the idea that wargame should be two equal forces across an open table having a little fight is one that really stops thinking far too early, in my opinion, and it fails to really take advantage of some of the depth that this kind of deep simulation can offer. Instead of "both sides have an equally high chance of winning", I prefer something like "both sides have an equally interesting problem to solve". It's nice if you can tie up asymmetric objectives to represent that, but in most cases what it actually says on the victory screen is of secondary importance to the process. Totally agree in regards to balance. Some of the most exciting and immersive scenarios are the ones where you are just trying to survive against overwhelming odds. For campaigns, part of the strategy is, so do you take the last objective or save the troops for the next mission. 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
The_Capt Posted July 1, 2022 Share Posted July 1, 2022 1 hour ago, Rinaldi said: I wouldn't change a single iota of Valley of Ashes, it's one of the strongest standalones I've played thus far from the Soviet perspective. The fact it is in the same timeline as the campaigns also makes it a nice little 'prelude.' The AI plans are excellent, and the fire support you receive on both sides is absolutely true-to-life. Am I happy with a draw? Only in hindsight; the silver lining of the entire affair was how effective my air power was. Wow, thanks. This is one of Pete W's first maps for the title and the scenario just jumps out of it. Valley of Ashes occurs about 48 hours before the first battle of the US Campaign as the 15th TR crashes the southern axis of advance of the 39th MRD against the 11 ACR. The 15th then goes onto continue to push south along the Fulda - Hanau route (Rte 66) but runs out of gas and has to be overtaken by elements of the 57 MRD about 96 hours into the war. This one was really tricky but we felt it was a solid US scenario - a good one to kinda get into things. VoA is really hard as the Soviets, I think I have only seen one YouTube player beat it. On balance - definitely, and we have actually taken some hits on how we approached it. In most cases we took a look at the ground, the forces in play and started with - "ok what would the sides do here". Balance with respect to "gaming" was really secondary, and we had no problem making some very tough - almost unwinnable scenarios. We would tweak slightly but an MRR attack is an MRR attack at the end of the day. How much arty and air was the main negotiation point. I am very glad you guys are getting enjoyment and challenge out of these. 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Artkin Posted July 12, 2022 Share Posted July 12, 2022 True to life is so much better than balanced imo. 0 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rinaldi Posted July 17, 2022 Author Share Posted July 17, 2022 In the Fulda Gap, that most terrible dawn came and went for the US V Corps. The 11th Cavalry had bent, but it had not broken. Exercising units that had been caught flat-footed largely made good their escape, battered but capable of reconstitution. NATO deployed, alarmed but resolute, to protect this retreat. The allied air forces made a herculean effort to create space through strikes in the enemy rear areas. The Elbe crossings were hit, hard. Much closer to home, crossings over the Werra were hit with equal violence. The cost was great, the Soviet air defence asked a high price for admission to these lucrative targets. Nevertheless, the initial Soviet supplies and follow-on forces were slowed. The powerful shock forces immediately in the battle area still had to be dealt with, but that was a more manageable battle. Anyone who knew anything, knew this: the initial move was a Soviet masterstroke and had shaped things to their advantage nicely. NATO, however, hadn’t been put in checkmate. It was a different B Team, but the situation is not all that different: once again thrust into a nightmare scenario against the best an enemy had to offer. That is the situation B Company, 2nd of the 28th Infantry, 1st Brigade, 8th Infantry Division found itself in as July 16th dawned. CPT Booth was still attempting to recover his balance. The war had come as a violent shock to everyone. His company’s war was not even 24 hours old, and yet his command had already been handled roughly. First had come hurried orders on the 15th of July to take blocking positions. They were to hold until friendly exercising units could retreat through them. The friendlies had all gotten away and clean, but the enemy forward security element that had been hot on their heels had only been stopped at egregious cost. B Team’s first ever fight started well enough: the company’s ITOWs and attached scouts had flamed several enemy BMPs and a tank. Then the sheer force of enemy fire had sent them reeling backwards to new, hasty positions. An unexpected and sudden flank from several T-80s creeping through dead ground had almost spelled disaster. They been stopped at the ten-yard line in a point-blank engagement. The effort had nearly destroyed Booth’s command. When they received the order to pull back, they left behind three burning M60s – one containing the decapitated corpse of the Tank Platoon leader (he couldn’t even remember the man’s name) – a scout track, and several ITOWs, some from the Scouts, some from his Weapons platoon. That had been the toughest moment of his life so far. Booth had learned from his first day of OCS: don’t leave your dead, never, ever, leave your wounded. The bastard that had said that had clearly never imagined what this war would look like. Booth’s FSGT, a dependable, quiet Vietnam veteran found him early that evening, weeping in the woods, a shuddering mess. Without a word the NCO clapped a hand on his shoulder, then turned around to go make sure no one would find their CO before he regained his composure. Though Booth could hardly take credit for it, things had improved after that. An ambush conducted by his 2nd Platoon, surviving scouts and ITOWs had mauled a Soviet security element in the thick forest astride the MSR. When they pulled back in their M113s, th ey had left a platoon of T-64s and almost a company’s worth BMPs burning, piled up on the asphalt and along the shoulders. Similar, less dramatic, ambushes had been pulled off by the TF’s scouts and A Company. It had bought the battalion what Booth had already learned was the most precious resources of all in war: time. More importantly, it had burgeoned their sagging morale and showed them that the enemy could be defeated. So violent were these ambushes, they had compelled the Soviets to halt for the evening and night, to deploy their main forces for a deliberate attack. TF “Dragon” had been able to dig in, lay obstacles, rest, reorganize, conduct proper terrain walks of their next intended battleground and even rehearse planned movements and retreats. Better yet, Booth had been able to sleep. The Soviets were now facing the unenviable task of regaining momentum through a set piece attack into prepared defences. Booth’s company, deployed in front of the suspected main effort, was going to stop them. Chapter 4: Equilibrium Neuhof, Forward Edge of the Battle Area. July 16th, 1100 hours. Ten Fateful Minutes A quiet stand-to. The Soviets didn’t come in the morning mist. The TF’s S-2 had estimated they were not capable, but Booth hadn’t really believed it. It had given the men a chance to have a hot breakfast, and for his rifle platoons to rehearse their drives into their pre-selected fighting positions. They had now once again returned to their hides, and Booth was going over the plan one last time with the headquarters’ team. Sitting on the ramp of the M113 with an overlay awkwardly spread out over both knees, he went over the scheme, taskings and timings once more. He had called in the unfamiliar commanders of two attachments made to his unit: 1LT Lyles, a tanker cross-attached from a neighbouring armour Battalion and 1LT Swafford, a platoon leader from the Anti-tank company. They so far had made good impressions. They had been deferential but confident in advising how their commands should be used and had had a great role in shaping the battle plan. Lyles’ M60s were equipped with Tank Thermal Sights and were referred to as TTS. They would be a key component of the plan, a potentially decisive advantage. Swafford’s TOW launchers were older M150s, and would work closely with the TTS to make up for this. “Let’s make sure we’re all clear on this. Each BP needs to position its vehicles to be able to fire into at least two EAs. We need to create a cycle of combat.” There it was again. Booth had used that phrase ad nauseum all through yesterday evening and morning. It would have made his special platoon leaders exchange wry looks if the situation wasn’t so serious, and if the plan didn’t make so much good sense. “Forward deployed units need to get their shots in and hand off the engagement quickly, falling back after the first couple of shots. No delay. The scouts, with some help from your platoon, Lyle, will handle those early engagement areas.” Nods all around. “We’re going to operate on the assumption that the other team are going to get to the goal line. We’re going to let em through but make sure they arrive in no position to cross it. Rifle platoons will clean up, Lyle’s main BP will hit anything heavy that manages to get into these final EAs.” "Alright. That’s it. Get to your positions. Expect them before the morning is through.” Booth had learned from his first encounter with the enemy. If they wanted to get through somewhere, they could do it the first time with high probability. It was better to bend rather than put up a wall early and watch the Soviets knock it down. He also remembered how his Company had almost immediately descended into chaos when trying to fall back to several successive positions. Too many successive BPs complicated things. A set of main BPs to fall back into was preferable. He moved into the cargo space of his command track. As the ramp closed behind him, he went over his scheme once more… His thoughts were interrupted by a squawk over the radio. Through light interference came the report: Dorfborn was coming under artillery fire. “The centre of town is being hit hard. No casualties so far.” Dull crumps reverberate through the hull of Booth’s M113. “Sir, Neuhof is getting hit pretty hard” the gunner informs him. In the latter case, at least, the Soviets were not at risk of hitting any of his men, who remained to the rear in hides. The locals who had remained had, he hoped, listened to his missive to remain in their basements. Here we go. Booth thinks to himself as he tightens the straps of his steel helmet. Further reports were coming in now from Dorfborn: enemy vehicles in column, fanning out into line. Nodding at the company FIST, pre-planned fires are called upon to begin laying a thick fire down in front of the enemy’s axes of advance. The battle for Neuhof had begun. For the Soviets, the fight begins disastrously. Several BMPs are destroyed trying to run the gauntlet of artillery fire. The FIST’s face betrays no satisfaction, or any other emotion, as he acknowledges the fire and attempts to keep the artillery fire shifting in line with the enemy’s advance. Despite the pounding the bulk of these lead forces push through the fire, T-64s in the lead. The first direct fire engagement then begins, as the forward deployed TOWs and armour pick up these targets. In two minutes, TOWs managed to destroy several enemy recce, anti-tank and ADA elements that had exposed themselves in the treelines lining the valley floor. They also engage several T-64s that are furtively pushing forward, with catastrophic effect. Within two minutes, a platoon of the enemy’s tanks are burning. Scattered throughout the valley are American OPs, who help Booth tightly control the battle and report these initial successes. Prompted by the reports of the continuing Soviet advance, Booth’s attached TACP requests the pre-planned interdiction sorties to begin. A-10s which had been flying a race-track pattern behind friendly lines acknowledge, drop altitude and vector themselves in. Within two minutes, the better part of an enemy company has suffered severe attrition. The start of the battle has gone almost precisely as Booth had planned. Almost. The initial exchange of fire is not one sided, and just as one of the forward ITOWs start to pull back, it is struck by a Spandrel. Its crew does not survive. In Dorfborn, the NCO leading the scout section can see another enemy company crossing the River Fleide, entering into engagement area Blue. His men take up the awkward, cross-legged firing position with their M47 Dragons and remove the covers from the thermal sights. Concentrating hard, and trying to ignore the reverberating thumps of artillery hitting the town only a few dozen meters behind their positions, they begin to engage. A T-64 is soon burning. A second soon joins it. The third shrugs off the Dragon as if it was nothing. Its turret orients towards the village, and sweeps back and forth, trying to pinpoint the firing position. “That’s it, pack up and move next door. They’re onto us!” a SGT screams at his two scouts, straining to be heard over the screaming howls of the still-intensifying artillery. The Scouts brave the streets for brief moments at a time as they dash between houses, safety, and new firing positions. As new positions are taken up, they continue to report back to Booth. The enemy are flowing like water on either side of the village, and are beginning to present their flanks. These are choice shots, and the scouts make the most of the opportunity, hitting another pair of BMPs. Then, the A-10s arrive. Two are shot down immediately by ADA, but the other pair close up and push through. Cluster bombs drop onto a buildup of enemy BMPs crossing the bottleneck at the River Fliede. Back in Booth’s command track, 2LT Bartels, the TACP officer, officer looks shaken. Despite all the artillery fire onto identified enemy ADA, the Soviets still had more out there. It had been so effective. The remaining pair of A-10s don’t try their luck for a second pass and try to burn their way out. One of the two remaining A-10s is badly damaged by an anti-air missile and comes down extremely hard on landing back at base. Three A-10s for, at best, a handful of BMPs. He reports the ineffective air attack to the CO. His part in the battle is done. He can’t help but feel he’s somehow let his comrades down. Meanwhile, the enemy continues to bypass Dorfborn on either flank. The Scouts are beginning to run low on Dragon missiles and their escape window is closing. Radioing a warning to the forward deployed TTS on their left flank of the targets coming their way, they close up shop and mount up. A harrowing cross-country dash in their M113s shortly follows, but they are all able to pull back behind Neuhof intact and in good order. The scouts never learn just how timely their retreat is, for as they are pulling back, a platoon of enemy BMPs finally breaks off from the pack and enters Dorfborn. As the scouts are preparing to pull back, Booth is able to piece together the battlefield based on the reports from them, and the forward deployed armour. The enemy, as was expected, is bypassing the village on either side. Neuhof was clearly their destination. With the covering forces displacing, it was time to put the rifle platoons into their battle positions. With a terse codeword across the company net, he orders his tracks out of their hides and into their positions around Neuhof. They had rehearsed things excellently: it will take around 5 minutes to get set up. As the tracks rumble towards BPs 1A and 1B respectively, the platoon leaders exercise the independent authority Booth has trusted them with. The first of many decisions: do the M113s remain in the BP, or out? In 1B, the platoon leader decides he will order his three M113s to pull back to their hides. His position is closest to Neuhof’s town centre and he knows enemy artillery fire can intensify on it quickly. In 1A, the platoon leader has already decided he will disperse the tracks into fighting positions. He needs as much firepower as he can get, as there are a lot more ingress routes to his position for an enemy to take. The covering battle is over, and the fight begins to shift to the main BPs. SFC MacDade, Lyles’ platoon NCO opens up the engagement. Hidden away in BP2 with a OP/LP, he is told that a better part of a MRC is fully in EA Blue now. He orders his TTS and his wingman forward, using the treeline, a cottage and its hedged garden as a attack by fire position. MacDade accounts for two T-64s in rapid succession, guiding his gunner on with alacrity with his commander’s override. The savage enfilading fire seems to sap the Soviet company in EA Blue of some impetus. They hesitate, then briefly halt. MacDade and his wingmen hit several more BMPs, despite the enemy attempting to return fire. The laser rangefinder equipped TTSs are proving as decisive as Booth had hoped. The BMPs surging to the left of Dorfborn run into the outposted TTS that had covered the scout sections’ retreat. In quick succession, the gunner knocks out two BMPs as they push past the treeline. The TC, a SSGT, is too focused on looking through the CTSD at his gunner’s handiwork. He never identifies the third BMP, skulking in the treeline, as it hits his tank with a Spandrel. The jet of chemical energy eviscerates the entire crew. The SSGT never knows why he died, indeed never has a chance to realise he is dying. The M60 shudders and burns. The surviving Soviet squad leader has no radio transmitter with which to report that the way around Dorfborn is open; and so he clambers out of the forward hatch, awkwardly fumbling to produce a green flare pistol from below. Aiming straight at the sky he fires it through the canopy of the treeline, willing it to be seen. His prayers are answered: his Battalion commander sees it, even in the bright summer morning, and immediately orders the surviving elements of this MRC to push towards it. He promises a redoubling of the artillery effort to the Major leading this thrust. There’s a gap in Booth’s armour, and he doesn’t yet realise it. MacDade, for his part, knows he’s overstayed his welcome in the firing positions. It has only been two minutes, but he knows that is a long time in this type of environment. He orders his wingman to pull back after his own tank. Just as his tank is arriving in cover behind one of the German cottages in the BP, his wingman’s tank is struck by a missile. He doesn’t see from where. Immediately, he thinks: that could’ve been me, and then, glad it wasn’t. A pang of guilt at the selfish thought when four men have just died. Then, relief: the TTS stirs. A slight move of the gun. Hatches open, cautiously, and a man clambers out of the turret. He turns around and helps lift an unconscious second crewman out, aided by the third, who unceremoniously is pushing the stricken man out by his boot soles . A fourth crewman is seen rounding the front end of the tank, arriving to help take the wounded, with almost careful reverence now, down from the engine deck of the tank. MacDade waves them into the nearby cottage. The three men, a bit shocked but otherwise alright, quickly comply, the burly driver fireman carrying the wounded, unconscious gunner. Across the battlezone, the Soviets bite back, no longer mere targets in the distance. Unbeknownst to MacDade, the T-64 that took out his wingman is itself shortly knocked out from BP 3B, as 1LT Swafford orders a pair of his TOWs to move forward and engage from the giant potash pile that looms over Neuhof. As these TOWs are pulling back from the edge of the plateau, one is struck, and it is ripped apart in a blinding flash as its missiles touch off. This gory disaster doesn’t discourage them. Swafford then orders his other pair of TOW carriers forward in BP3A. These, at the base of the potash mound, creep into hulldown positions on a forested slope. Another T-64 burns. This time they pull back safely into their hides. The direct fire engagement in EA Red and Blue slackens as MacDade and Swafford pull their vehicles back into hides. The Soviets regain their composure, close formation, and surge onwards. The battle will have to be picked up again in EAs White and Yellow, as Booth’s infantrymen bottle up the Soviets on the mine fields protecting the approaches to Neuhof. For now, the tanks and TOWs lay low, their commanders seeking new firing positions in their respective BPs, anticipating the next engagement. In BPs 1A and 1B, the infantrymen have debussed from their M113s. Booth and his command team have joined them in 1B, near the two intact bridges that help the town straddle the river Fleide. The decisive engagement was now a sure thing, as the Soviets seemed intent to press forward despite the mauling. Booth was fighting the surging adrenaline, trying to stay objective whilst monitoring the engagements on the company net. His XO was sending him SITREPs from the rest of the TF but whatever he was told was forgotten almost immediately. The rest of the Battalion could be on Mars, as far as he was concerned. His entire universe had shrunk to the small area of Neuhof and its approaches. So far, he was still master of this domain. Despite the almost non-factor combat aviation had been, the engagement had gone almost as well as he had planned it. He took mental stock of the situation, collating the many reports that had come in over the last few minutes, trying to form a cohesive image: The company team was doing alright. For the loss of two tanks and two TOWs, they had accounted for an estimated eight T-64s, nine BMP-2s and five BRDMs. The equivalent of a tank company and an MRC had been mauled across the first two EAs. So far, the enemy’s courses of action had conformed to what he had expected. They were bypassing Dorfborn, and appeared to be aiming to strike Neuhof from his left flank with one MRC, whilst another beelined for the train station to his front-right. What remained to be seen was whether they would stick to the low ground on the right, heading directly for BP1A, or try to climb the flat hill he had emplaced his surviving two M60A1s, under the command of SGT Marx, on. Another unknown, and a growing disquiet in his mind, was what was happening on his left. They had no eyes there since the scouts had pulled out, and the outpost TTS never pulled into MacDade’s position. It was tough terrain, but if the Soviets wanted to squeeze through it, they could. It was 1110 hours. It had taken only ten minutes for this carnage to develop. The Decisive Engagement Artillery once again dominates the battle on both sides. Dorfborn, despite the Soviet intrusion into it, is hit once again, hard, by their artillery. Just as they did in the start, they pummel empty air. BMPs begin to press forward again, a bit more raggedly now, behind this renewed barrage. American artillery answers, with fires coming down on TRPs that hope to close the exits from Dorfborn. 1LT Snook, the company FIST, had rode into BP 1B with Booth and had deployed forward in a rail house so to better guide the artillery. Now that his fires were under direct observation, rather than simply being from an overlay, the American artillery began to show increased agility. Fires chase the Soviets all the way and punish any halt. A brief conversation between Booth and SGT Marx about the situation, results in his tank section pulling back to an alternative position behind BP 1A. They pull back swiftly, grateful to no longer be out on a limb with what’s left of a MRC bearing down on them. A brief lull, filled only by the artillery fire from both sides, ensues. At 1116, the first Soviet BMPs erupt forward, nosing into the second and final set of EAs. A BMP enters into EA white, and is engaged from BP3, with Lyle and Swafford’s vehicle creeping forward once more. A TTS misses, but a TOW doesn’t. A second one follows, and this time it is shot up by the riflemen of 2LT LeBlanc’s platoon stationed in BP 1A. The OP/LP assigned to MacDade’s BP feeds a steady report of more enemy vehicles. “Oscar 2 send for Bravo 26. This callsign currently observing three times BMP in EA Blue and two times BMP in EA Yellow.” “Bravo 26 copies. Out.” Booth forewarns BP 1B’s platoon of the encroaching Soviets. It’s leader, 2LT Clausen, affirms and goes about ensuring his Dragon teams are deployed and ready. By 1117 they spot the enemy. Clausen wisely orders his men to hold fire, waiting for clearer shots, husbanding the limited ammunition his M47s have. Over the next three minutes, the OP/LP report more and more contacts heading for Neuhof via Dorfborn. It is the missing third Soviet MRC. At 1120, the BMPs in EA Yellow are close enough and providing good silhouettes. Clausen orders his anti-tanks to engage at will. A BMP platoon is destroyed several hundred meters away from Neuhof. Clausen, like the scouts before him, instructs his Dragon teams to displace between shots. The men dash between neighbouring suburban houses. The civilians, almost all sheltering in their basements as instructed, wince every time they hear the heavy thuds of GI’s boots thumping against their floorboards and stairwells. Their terror is borne out of a helplessness, and ignorance. “The Soviets must be at the edge of town!” “Hush! Stay quiet, lay still” A whispered exchange in German between an elderly man and his wife. They cannot know that the battle is going splendidly, that the Soviet advance, in the face of their losses, means nothing. 1LTs Lyle and Swafford continue to conduct berm drills in BP 3, nipping at the flanks and rear of the enemy surging into EA Yellow. What the infantry are unable to see or engage, they do. The dispersion of fire is excellent, and to Swafford’s particular relief, none of the finite number of TOWs are wasted firing at already destroyed enemy targets. The fight in EA Yellow reaches a crescendo as the reinforcing enemy MRC arrive in strength. Burgeoned by the reinforcements, the Soviets redouble their efforts to break into Neuhof. As the BMPs surge forward, they strike the minefield that had been laid through the middle of EA Yellow. Many strike mines and are immobilized. Several other BMPs managed to skirt the edge of the obstacle belt, moving along the rail line. That fight falls to Clausen. For the majority of the MRC, milling along the obstacle belt, their situation soon becomes incredibly hot. First, they come under crushing artillery fire. Booth, from his forward command post in BP 1B, can see that a unique opportunity has come to destroy the majority of this MRC in a very short span of time. The ITOWs that had fallen back harass the halted enemy, knocking out a few from the agricultural plots behind Neuhof. Booth thinks quickly. Then, taking the handheld from the RTO, broadcasts across the company net. Like the voice of God, his voice punches into the ears of all his mounted platoon leaders. “This is Bravo 26, all Bravo Tango callsigns to move forward and attack by fire enemy MRC in EA Yellow at 1125 hours. Repeat: H-hour is at 1125 hours.” To Booth’s grim delight, he sees more and more enemy BMPs begin to pile up in front of EA Yellow’s obstacle belt. A target rich environment. For surviving veterans of 2-28 INF, in the decades that follow, at reunions amongst themselves and in interviews for the media, much will be made of B Company’s “mad minute at Neuhof.” For the men who were there, it would become a moment of pride. Enlisted men would, during their dusty recollections, say this was the moment they believed they would win the war. At 1125 hours, SGT Marx, 1LT Lyles, and 1LT Swafford order all their vehicles forward. Booth, likewise, orders the ITOWs under his command to engage. The TTS open the wound, with Lyles’ tank striking a BMP in EA Yellow. Then, an ITOW behind BP 1A adds to the tally. The surviving TOW vehicle on the potash mound picks off a straggling BMP in EA Blue. A TOW in BP3 claims a second BMP in EA Blue. The carnage proceeds: SGT Marx’s wingman — even with the far less accurate M60A1 — manages to destroy a BMP in EA Yellow as well - an ITOW behind Neuhof hits a BMP skulking in Dorfborn. Finally, Lyle’s wingman engages a BMP just as it fires a Spandrel missile. The BMP explodes as its missile pitbulls harmlessly off into the sky, to destinations unknown. The assault is utterly devastating on the Soviets. Within 60 seconds, 7 BMPs are burning. All that make it through the gauntlet of fire are the aforementioned pair of BMPs, which snake their way into Neuhof along the low ground. Dutifully, amazingly, fanatically, they disgorge their infantry, who storm into Clausen’s positions. The 2LT cannot but admire the courage of his Soviet counterparts. Nevertheless, admiration doesn’t translate to pity. A M60 and a Dragon were already pre positioned to watch this entrance into town, and their fire forces the Soviet dismounts to duck into an alley, and right into his first squad. It’s hardly a fight. Caught in the open, the Soviet riflemen are gunned down in a violent fusillade. The only return fire the infantry receive comes from the final Soviet, caught by a M60 burst, who fires his AK in a reflexive spraying arc as he slumps over, dead. Mercifully, his steel helmet slides forward and covers his face, sparing his killer from having to humanize him in the fatal moment. By 1135 hours the enemy’s attack is clearly shattered. The only surviving enemy are seen deployed at the forward edge of Dorfborn. An eerie silence momentarily falls…but is quickly shattered by a heavy Soviet barrage on 2LT’s Leblanc’s position in BP 1A. The initial pounding kills a pair of men, but the platoon is able to crawl into shelter on the bottom floor, and wait out the barrage in relative safety, even as it ruins and rubbles the buildings they are in. Again, the American artillery responds in kind, with much more effect. Guided on by 1LT Snook, 155s expend their remaining munitions on the forces in Dorfborn. The fire, so heavily concentrated in such a small space, rips some BMPs apart, flips others, and peppers the survivors with shrapnel. Booth briefly toys with the idea of counterattacking Dorfborn, encouraged by the scout sections report that a covered, undefended route onto the flank of the shattered village is open through the trees. He ultimately declines to do so, however. Cognizant of the diminished ammunition of both his direct and indirect fire weaponry, and the importance of making sure Lyles’ and Swafford’s platoons do not suffer unnecessary losses (their parent units will need them, after all), he decides against risking a broken neck so late in the battle. It becomes a moot point: under the cover of smoke and diesel splashed on engine decks, the surviving Soviets pull out of Dorfborn, slinking back in the direction they came. The Battle for Neuhof is over. It is 1142 hours. As the pounding of artillery fades, the first thing Booth notices – strange as it seemed – was that he could hear birds chirping; had they returned that quickly, or had they simply stayed throughout the fire and fury? The next thing he noticed is that he didn’t feel tired, at all. Wasn’t he supposed to feel fatigued as the adrenaline poured out of his body? All he felt was exhilaration, and satisfaction. They had stopped the Soviets cold, and mauled (no, he corrected himself, destroyed) a MRB for functionally no loss. His XO was already taking stock of the casualties. Booth knew he would not have many more letters to write, not much more than a dozen, at best. Unlike yesterday, he did not feel a man’s life had been lost in vain. That made it easier. His dependable FSGT had already departed in the TACP’s track to go fetch ammunition from Battalion. Battalion, he thought, how had the rest of the TF done? He couldn’t hear any sounds of battle on either flank…but he could see in the distance to the right, black smoke spires wafting over the forest dividing him from A Company’s engagement areas. A good sign. He concluded. Turning to his RTO, he dictated his SITREP for TOC... 11 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Erwin Posted July 18, 2022 Share Posted July 18, 2022 Amazing AAR Rinaldi. Very entertaining. 2 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rinaldi Posted July 21, 2022 Author Share Posted July 21, 2022 On 7/18/2022 at 3:42 PM, Erwin said: Amazing AAR Rinaldi. Very entertaining. Many thanks. Some thoughts on this last chapter... Firstly, apologies for in media res. The idea to start doing the AAR only occurred to me three missions in to the campaign, when it hit me that this was probably one of the best designed campaigns to date (which is saying something, as I'm not light with praise for many others). Secondly, wow: a lot of targets serviced in a short amount of time. I'll try to unpack. If the standalone version of this mission isn't a planned demo mission, you're selling the game short. The fight for Neuhof might as well have leapt out of FM71-2. You're well rewarded for earlier successes by the time you get to this mission. Key cross-attachments that bring you up to a 'square' combat team, broad daylight (and all the forewarning of an attack that would bring), obstacle belts in place, and a battlefield where there are no discernible flanks for the enemy. What you get is a fairly doctrinal battalion level breakthrough attempt by the Soviets, which is again, high praise to the scenario designers. The enemy clearly came on in two main echelons, or more accurately, the battle begins with the second and third battle lines being deployed. The first battle line, in this case, was all the prepositioned Recon and ATGM support they had. What I think is most useful is comparing the final mission of the NTC campaign with the fight for Neuhof. If you paid attention, you could see the similarities between the two immediately. In both instances, the Soviet (or "Soviet" in the case of the NTC) battalion came in roughly 2-3 echelons, and the first companies always attempted to pry open the flanks and bypass poor terrain. So, in the first image, they tried to avoid the washboard and scrub-like terrain that is (like in reality) atrocious for any type of vehicular movement, and in Neuhof, they flowed like water around manmade obstacles, such as villages. My experience in the former helped me anticipate the latter. The enemy largely conformed to my expectations. In sum: the NTC campaign is a good investment of your time if you want to avoid later frustrations. As to what precisely was my thought process in this last chapter, obviously I provided some overlays about my defence, but I rarely give details. I'll try to do so now. My plan was based around the presumption that having multiple BPs you fall back to in succession is a recipe for disaster. CM has a bird's eye view and a lot of the natural friction that comes from falling back successively (like blue-on-blue, failure to communicate, etc) isn't necessarily modelled; and it's still complete chaos every time I have ever tried it. So I chose instead to make a fight from one main BP and ensure that I shaped what that fight looked like early on. It's easier to manage a few forward deployed units than it is to place entire platoons and companies forward and fall back with them. When you have picquets forward and you stay longer than expected, you lose a section of vehicles at most. When you mistime falling back from a BP, you lose entire platoons and companies. This, of course, is a criticism that was levelled about the tactical doctrine of active defence: (Source: https://youtu.be/QgwqT4fqU2E) Of course, it's much more difficult to capture AirLand Battle as so much of it relies on operational concerns that cannot be captured in CM. At the tactical level, it might be hard to distinguish between Active Defence and AirLand Battle. Nevertheless, I tried my best to open up the 'close' battle aggressively, with air and artillery and well forward deployed units. The idea of course was to create space and avoid a lot of the Soviet strengths (such as artillery integration). I think I did that well; notwithstanding the insane losses suffered from the A-10s in a short amount of time. As for what I chose for the forward deployment, ITOWs naturally dominate the list. In terms of situational awareness, they are king in this game; relatively common vehicles with excellent thermal sights that are essentially on an antennae-like stock. Much easier to hide, therefore, than a barn-sized TTS or an Abrams, who have similar or better sensor suites. Putting the attached scout section in Dorfborn was a massive assumption of risk but was absolutely vital to actually developing an idea of what the enemy was doing. Scouts win battles, even when they do not fire a shot. For the record, I'm currently on "The Citadel" in the campaign and I am hoping that the third time is the charm with this approach to defence against an enemy regiment. 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
The_Capt Posted July 21, 2022 Share Posted July 21, 2022 On 7/17/2022 at 9:12 AM, Rinaldi said: In the Fulda Gap, that most terrible dawn came and went for the US V Corps. The 11th Cavalry had bent, but it had not broken. Exercising units that had been caught flat-footed largely made good their escape, battered but capable of reconstitution. NATO deployed, alarmed but resolute, to protect this retreat. The allied air forces made a herculean effort to create space through strikes in the enemy rear areas. The Elbe crossings were hit, hard. Much closer to home, crossings over the Werra were hit with equal violence. The cost was great, the Soviet air defence asked a high price for admission to these lucrative targets. Nevertheless, the initial Soviet supplies and follow-on forces were slowed. The powerful shock forces immediately in the battle area still had to be dealt with, but that was a more manageable battle. Anyone who knew anything, knew this: the initial move was a Soviet masterstroke and had shaped things to their advantage nicely. NATO, however, hadn’t been put in checkmate. It was a different B Team, but the situation is not all that different: once again thrust into a nightmare scenario against the best an enemy had to offer. That is the situation B Company, 2nd of the 28th Infantry, 1st Brigade, 8th Infantry Division found itself in as July 16th dawned. CPT Booth was still attempting to recover his balance. The war had come as a violent shock to everyone. His company’s war was not even 24 hours old, and yet his command had already been handled roughly. First had come hurried orders on the 15th of July to take blocking positions. They were to hold until friendly exercising units could retreat through them. The friendlies had all gotten away and clean, but the enemy forward security element that had been hot on their heels had only been stopped at egregious cost. B Team’s first ever fight started well enough: the company’s ITOWs and attached scouts had flamed several enemy BMPs and a tank. Then the sheer force of enemy fire had sent them reeling backwards to new, hasty positions. An unexpected and sudden flank from several T-80s creeping through dead ground had almost spelled disaster. They been stopped at the ten-yard line in a point-blank engagement. The effort had nearly destroyed Booth’s command. When they received the order to pull back, they left behind three burning M60s – one containing the decapitated corpse of the Tank Platoon leader (he couldn’t even remember the man’s name) – a scout track, and several ITOWs, some from the Scouts, some from his Weapons platoon. That had been the toughest moment of his life so far. Booth had learned from his first day of OCS: don’t leave your dead, never, ever, leave your wounded. The bastard that had said that had clearly never imagined what this war would look like. Booth’s FSGT, a dependable, quiet Vietnam veteran found him early that evening, weeping in the woods, a shuddering mess. Without a word the NCO clapped a hand on his shoulder, then turned around to go make sure no one would find their CO before he regained his composure. Though Booth could hardly take credit for it, things had improved after that. An ambush conducted by his 2nd Platoon, surviving scouts and ITOWs had mauled a Soviet security element in the thick forest astride the MSR. When they pulled back in their M113s, th ey had left a platoon of T-64s and almost a company’s worth BMPs burning, piled up on the asphalt and along the shoulders. Similar, less dramatic, ambushes had been pulled off by the TF’s scouts and A Company. It had bought the battalion what Booth had already learned was the most precious resources of all in war: time. More importantly, it had burgeoned their sagging morale and showed them that the enemy could be defeated. So violent were these ambushes, they had compelled the Soviets to halt for the evening and night, to deploy their main forces for a deliberate attack. TF “Dragon” had been able to dig in, lay obstacles, rest, reorganize, conduct proper terrain walks of their next intended battleground and even rehearse planned movements and retreats. Better yet, Booth had been able to sleep. The Soviets were now facing the unenviable task of regaining momentum through a set piece attack into prepared defences. Booth’s company, deployed in front of the suspected main effort, was going to stop them. Chapter 4: Equilibrium Neuhof, Forward Edge of the Battle Area. July 16th, 1100 hours. Ten Fateful Minutes A quiet stand-to. The Soviets didn’t come in the morning mist. The TF’s S-2 had estimated they were not capable, but Booth hadn’t really believed it. It had given the men a chance to have a hot breakfast, and for his rifle platoons to rehearse their drives into their pre-selected fighting positions. They had now once again returned to their hides, and Booth was going over the plan one last time with the headquarters’ team. Sitting on the ramp of the M113 with an overlay awkwardly spread out over both knees, he went over the scheme, taskings and timings once more. He had called in the unfamiliar commanders of two attachments made to his unit: 1LT Lyles, a tanker cross-attached from a neighbouring armour Battalion and 1LT Swafford, a platoon leader from the Anti-tank company. They so far had made good impressions. They had been deferential but confident in advising how their commands should be used and had had a great role in shaping the battle plan. Lyles’ M60s were equipped with Tank Thermal Sights and were referred to as TTS. They would be a key component of the plan, a potentially decisive advantage. Swafford’s TOW launchers were older M150s, and would work closely with the TTS to make up for this. “Let’s make sure we’re all clear on this. Each BP needs to position its vehicles to be able to fire into at least two EAs. We need to create a cycle of combat.” There it was again. Booth had used that phrase ad nauseum all through yesterday evening and morning. It would have made his special platoon leaders exchange wry looks if the situation wasn’t so serious, and if the plan didn’t make so much good sense. “Forward deployed units need to get their shots in and hand off the engagement quickly, falling back after the first couple of shots. No delay. The scouts, with some help from your platoon, Lyle, will handle those early engagement areas.” Nods all around. “We’re going to operate on the assumption that the other team are going to get to the goal line. We’re going to let em through but make sure they arrive in no position to cross it. Rifle platoons will clean up, Lyle’s main BP will hit anything heavy that manages to get into these final EAs.” "Alright. That’s it. Get to your positions. Expect them before the morning is through.” Booth had learned from his first encounter with the enemy. If they wanted to get through somewhere, they could do it the first time with high probability. It was better to bend rather than put up a wall early and watch the Soviets knock it down. He also remembered how his Company had almost immediately descended into chaos when trying to fall back to several successive positions. Too many successive BPs complicated things. A set of main BPs to fall back into was preferable. He moved into the cargo space of his command track. As the ramp closed behind him, he went over his scheme once more… His thoughts were interrupted by a squawk over the radio. Through light interference came the report: Dorfborn was coming under artillery fire. “The centre of town is being hit hard. No casualties so far.” Dull crumps reverberate through the hull of Booth’s M113. “Sir, Neuhof is getting hit pretty hard” the gunner informs him. In the latter case, at least, the Soviets were not at risk of hitting any of his men, who remained to the rear in hides. The locals who had remained had, he hoped, listened to his missive to remain in their basements. Here we go. Booth thinks to himself as he tightens the straps of his steel helmet. Further reports were coming in now from Dorfborn: enemy vehicles in column, fanning out into line. Nodding at the company FIST, pre-planned fires are called upon to begin laying a thick fire down in front of the enemy’s axes of advance. The battle for Neuhof had begun. For the Soviets, the fight begins disastrously. Several BMPs are destroyed trying to run the gauntlet of artillery fire. The FIST’s face betrays no satisfaction, or any other emotion, as he acknowledges the fire and attempts to keep the artillery fire shifting in line with the enemy’s advance. Despite the pounding the bulk of these lead forces push through the fire, T-64s in the lead. The first direct fire engagement then begins, as the forward deployed TOWs and armour pick up these targets. In two minutes, TOWs managed to destroy several enemy recce, anti-tank and ADA elements that had exposed themselves in the treelines lining the valley floor. They also engage several T-64s that are furtively pushing forward, with catastrophic effect. Within two minutes, a platoon of the enemy’s tanks are burning. Scattered throughout the valley are American OPs, who help Booth tightly control the battle and report these initial successes. Prompted by the reports of the continuing Soviet advance, Booth’s attached TACP requests the pre-planned interdiction sorties to begin. A-10s which had been flying a race-track pattern behind friendly lines acknowledge, drop altitude and vector themselves in. Within two minutes, the better part of an enemy company has suffered severe attrition. The start of the battle has gone almost precisely as Booth had planned. Almost. The initial exchange of fire is not one sided, and just as one of the forward ITOWs start to pull back, it is struck by a Spandrel. Its crew does not survive. In Dorfborn, the NCO leading the scout section can see another enemy company crossing the River Fleide, entering into engagement area Blue. His men take up the awkward, cross-legged firing position with their M47 Dragons and remove the covers from the thermal sights. Concentrating hard, and trying to ignore the reverberating thumps of artillery hitting the town only a few dozen meters behind their positions, they begin to engage. A T-64 is soon burning. A second soon joins it. The third shrugs off the Dragon as if it was nothing. Its turret orients towards the village, and sweeps back and forth, trying to pinpoint the firing position. “That’s it, pack up and move next door. They’re onto us!” a SGT screams at his two scouts, straining to be heard over the screaming howls of the still-intensifying artillery. The Scouts brave the streets for brief moments at a time as they dash between houses, safety, and new firing positions. As new positions are taken up, they continue to report back to Booth. The enemy are flowing like water on either side of the village, and are beginning to present their flanks. These are choice shots, and the scouts make the most of the opportunity, hitting another pair of BMPs. Then, the A-10s arrive. Two are shot down immediately by ADA, but the other pair close up and push through. Cluster bombs drop onto a buildup of enemy BMPs crossing the bottleneck at the River Fliede. Back in Booth’s command track, 2LT Bartels, the TACP officer, officer looks shaken. Despite all the artillery fire onto identified enemy ADA, the Soviets still had more out there. It had been so effective. The remaining pair of A-10s don’t try their luck for a second pass and try to burn their way out. One of the two remaining A-10s is badly damaged by an anti-air missile and comes down extremely hard on landing back at base. Three A-10s for, at best, a handful of BMPs. He reports the ineffective air attack to the CO. His part in the battle is done. He can’t help but feel he’s somehow let his comrades down. Meanwhile, the enemy continues to bypass Dorfborn on either flank. The Scouts are beginning to run low on Dragon missiles and their escape window is closing. Radioing a warning to the forward deployed TTS on their left flank of the targets coming their way, they close up shop and mount up. A harrowing cross-country dash in their M113s shortly follows, but they are all able to pull back behind Neuhof intact and in good order. The scouts never learn just how timely their retreat is, for as they are pulling back, a platoon of enemy BMPs finally breaks off from the pack and enters Dorfborn. As the scouts are preparing to pull back, Booth is able to piece together the battlefield based on the reports from them, and the forward deployed armour. The enemy, as was expected, is bypassing the village on either side. Neuhof was clearly their destination. With the covering forces displacing, it was time to put the rifle platoons into their battle positions. With a terse codeword across the company net, he orders his tracks out of their hides and into their positions around Neuhof. They had rehearsed things excellently: it will take around 5 minutes to get set up. As the tracks rumble towards BPs 1A and 1B respectively, the platoon leaders exercise the independent authority Booth has trusted them with. The first of many decisions: do the M113s remain in the BP, or out? In 1B, the platoon leader decides he will order his three M113s to pull back to their hides. His position is closest to Neuhof’s town centre and he knows enemy artillery fire can intensify on it quickly. In 1A, the platoon leader has already decided he will disperse the tracks into fighting positions. He needs as much firepower as he can get, as there are a lot more ingress routes to his position for an enemy to take. The covering battle is over, and the fight begins to shift to the main BPs. SFC MacDade, Lyles’ platoon NCO opens up the engagement. Hidden away in BP2 with a OP/LP, he is told that a better part of a MRC is fully in EA Blue now. He orders his TTS and his wingman forward, using the treeline, a cottage and its hedged garden as a attack by fire position. MacDade accounts for two T-64s in rapid succession, guiding his gunner on with alacrity with his commander’s override. The savage enfilading fire seems to sap the Soviet company in EA Blue of some impetus. They hesitate, then briefly halt. MacDade and his wingmen hit several more BMPs, despite the enemy attempting to return fire. The laser rangefinder equipped TTSs are proving as decisive as Booth had hoped. The BMPs surging to the left of Dorfborn run into the outposted TTS that had covered the scout sections’ retreat. In quick succession, the gunner knocks out two BMPs as they push past the treeline. The TC, a SSGT, is too focused on looking through the CTSD at his gunner’s handiwork. He never identifies the third BMP, skulking in the treeline, as it hits his tank with a Spandrel. The jet of chemical energy eviscerates the entire crew. The SSGT never knows why he died, indeed never has a chance to realise he is dying. The M60 shudders and burns. The surviving Soviet squad leader has no radio transmitter with which to report that the way around Dorfborn is open; and so he clambers out of the forward hatch, awkwardly fumbling to produce a green flare pistol from below. Aiming straight at the sky he fires it through the canopy of the treeline, willing it to be seen. His prayers are answered: his Battalion commander sees it, even in the bright summer morning, and immediately orders the surviving elements of this MRC to push towards it. He promises a redoubling of the artillery effort to the Major leading this thrust. There’s a gap in Booth’s armour, and he doesn’t yet realise it. MacDade, for his part, knows he’s overstayed his welcome in the firing positions. It has only been two minutes, but he knows that is a long time in this type of environment. He orders his wingman to pull back after his own tank. Just as his tank is arriving in cover behind one of the German cottages in the BP, his wingman’s tank is struck by a missile. He doesn’t see from where. Immediately, he thinks: that could’ve been me, and then, glad it wasn’t. A pang of guilt at the selfish thought when four men have just died. Then, relief: the TTS stirs. A slight move of the gun. Hatches open, cautiously, and a man clambers out of the turret. He turns around and helps lift an unconscious second crewman out, aided by the third, who unceremoniously is pushing the stricken man out by his boot soles . A fourth crewman is seen rounding the front end of the tank, arriving to help take the wounded, with almost careful reverence now, down from the engine deck of the tank. MacDade waves them into the nearby cottage. The three men, a bit shocked but otherwise alright, quickly comply, the burly driver fireman carrying the wounded, unconscious gunner. Across the battlezone, the Soviets bite back, no longer mere targets in the distance. Unbeknownst to MacDade, the T-64 that took out his wingman is itself shortly knocked out from BP 3B, as 1LT Swafford orders a pair of his TOWs to move forward and engage from the giant potash pile that looms over Neuhof. As these TOWs are pulling back from the edge of the plateau, one is struck, and it is ripped apart in a blinding flash as its missiles touch off. This gory disaster doesn’t discourage them. Swafford then orders his other pair of TOW carriers forward in BP3A. These, at the base of the potash mound, creep into hulldown positions on a forested slope. Another T-64 burns. This time they pull back safely into their hides. The direct fire engagement in EA Red and Blue slackens as MacDade and Swafford pull their vehicles back into hides. The Soviets regain their composure, close formation, and surge onwards. The battle will have to be picked up again in EAs White and Yellow, as Booth’s infantrymen bottle up the Soviets on the mine fields protecting the approaches to Neuhof. For now, the tanks and TOWs lay low, their commanders seeking new firing positions in their respective BPs, anticipating the next engagement. In BPs 1A and 1B, the infantrymen have debussed from their M113s. Booth and his command team have joined them in 1B, near the two intact bridges that help the town straddle the river Fleide. The decisive engagement was now a sure thing, as the Soviets seemed intent to press forward despite the mauling. Booth was fighting the surging adrenaline, trying to stay objective whilst monitoring the engagements on the company net. His XO was sending him SITREPs from the rest of the TF but whatever he was told was forgotten almost immediately. The rest of the Battalion could be on Mars, as far as he was concerned. His entire universe had shrunk to the small area of Neuhof and its approaches. So far, he was still master of this domain. Despite the almost non-factor combat aviation had been, the engagement had gone almost as well as he had planned it. He took mental stock of the situation, collating the many reports that had come in over the last few minutes, trying to form a cohesive image: The company team was doing alright. For the loss of two tanks and two TOWs, they had accounted for an estimated eight T-64s, nine BMP-2s and five BRDMs. The equivalent of a tank company and an MRC had been mauled across the first two EAs. So far, the enemy’s courses of action had conformed to what he had expected. They were bypassing Dorfborn, and appeared to be aiming to strike Neuhof from his left flank with one MRC, whilst another beelined for the train station to his front-right. What remained to be seen was whether they would stick to the low ground on the right, heading directly for BP1A, or try to climb the flat hill he had emplaced his surviving two M60A1s, under the command of SGT Marx, on. Another unknown, and a growing disquiet in his mind, was what was happening on his left. They had no eyes there since the scouts had pulled out, and the outpost TTS never pulled into MacDade’s position. It was tough terrain, but if the Soviets wanted to squeeze through it, they could. It was 1110 hours. It had taken only ten minutes for this carnage to develop. The Decisive Engagement Artillery once again dominates the battle on both sides. Dorfborn, despite the Soviet intrusion into it, is hit once again, hard, by their artillery. Just as they did in the start, they pummel empty air. BMPs begin to press forward again, a bit more raggedly now, behind this renewed barrage. American artillery answers, with fires coming down on TRPs that hope to close the exits from Dorfborn. 1LT Snook, the company FIST, had rode into BP 1B with Booth and had deployed forward in a rail house so to better guide the artillery. Now that his fires were under direct observation, rather than simply being from an overlay, the American artillery began to show increased agility. Fires chase the Soviets all the way and punish any halt. A brief conversation between Booth and SGT Marx about the situation, results in his tank section pulling back to an alternative position behind BP 1A. They pull back swiftly, grateful to no longer be out on a limb with what’s left of a MRC bearing down on them. A brief lull, filled only by the artillery fire from both sides, ensues. At 1116, the first Soviet BMPs erupt forward, nosing into the second and final set of EAs. A BMP enters into EA white, and is engaged from BP3, with Lyle and Swafford’s vehicle creeping forward once more. A TTS misses, but a TOW doesn’t. A second one follows, and this time it is shot up by the riflemen of 2LT LeBlanc’s platoon stationed in BP 1A. The OP/LP assigned to MacDade’s BP feeds a steady report of more enemy vehicles. “Oscar 2 send for Bravo 26. This callsign currently observing three times BMP in EA Blue and two times BMP in EA Yellow.” “Bravo 26 copies. Out.” Booth forewarns BP 1B’s platoon of the encroaching Soviets. It’s leader, 2LT Clausen, affirms and goes about ensuring his Dragon teams are deployed and ready. By 1117 they spot the enemy. Clausen wisely orders his men to hold fire, waiting for clearer shots, husbanding the limited ammunition his M47s have. Over the next three minutes, the OP/LP report more and more contacts heading for Neuhof via Dorfborn. It is the missing third Soviet MRC. At 1120, the BMPs in EA Yellow are close enough and providing good silhouettes. Clausen orders his anti-tanks to engage at will. A BMP platoon is destroyed several hundred meters away from Neuhof. Clausen, like the scouts before him, instructs his Dragon teams to displace between shots. The men dash between neighbouring suburban houses. The civilians, almost all sheltering in their basements as instructed, wince every time they hear the heavy thuds of GI’s boots thumping against their floorboards and stairwells. Their terror is borne out of a helplessness, and ignorance. “The Soviets must be at the edge of town!” “Hush! Stay quiet, lay still” A whispered exchange in German between an elderly man and his wife. They cannot know that the battle is going splendidly, that the Soviet advance, in the face of their losses, means nothing. 1LTs Lyle and Swafford continue to conduct berm drills in BP 3, nipping at the flanks and rear of the enemy surging into EA Yellow. What the infantry are unable to see or engage, they do. The dispersion of fire is excellent, and to Swafford’s particular relief, none of the finite number of TOWs are wasted firing at already destroyed enemy targets. The fight in EA Yellow reaches a crescendo as the reinforcing enemy MRC arrive in strength. Burgeoned by the reinforcements, the Soviets redouble their efforts to break into Neuhof. As the BMPs surge forward, they strike the minefield that had been laid through the middle of EA Yellow. Many strike mines and are immobilized. Several other BMPs managed to skirt the edge of the obstacle belt, moving along the rail line. That fight falls to Clausen. For the majority of the MRC, milling along the obstacle belt, their situation soon becomes incredibly hot. First, they come under crushing artillery fire. Booth, from his forward command post in BP 1B, can see that a unique opportunity has come to destroy the majority of this MRC in a very short span of time. The ITOWs that had fallen back harass the halted enemy, knocking out a few from the agricultural plots behind Neuhof. Booth thinks quickly. Then, taking the handheld from the RTO, broadcasts across the company net. Like the voice of God, his voice punches into the ears of all his mounted platoon leaders. “This is Bravo 26, all Bravo Tango callsigns to move forward and attack by fire enemy MRC in EA Yellow at 1125 hours. Repeat: H-hour is at 1125 hours.” To Booth’s grim delight, he sees more and more enemy BMPs begin to pile up in front of EA Yellow’s obstacle belt. A target rich environment. For surviving veterans of 2-28 INF, in the decades that follow, at reunions amongst themselves and in interviews for the media, much will be made of B Company’s “mad minute at Neuhof.” For the men who were there, it would become a moment of pride. Enlisted men would, during their dusty recollections, say this was the moment they believed they would win the war. At 1125 hours, SGT Marx, 1LT Lyles, and 1LT Swafford order all their vehicles forward. Booth, likewise, orders the ITOWs under his command to engage. The TTS open the wound, with Lyles’ tank striking a BMP in EA Yellow. Then, an ITOW behind BP 1A adds to the tally. The surviving TOW vehicle on the potash mound picks off a straggling BMP in EA Blue. A TOW in BP3 claims a second BMP in EA Blue. The carnage proceeds: SGT Marx’s wingman — even with the far less accurate M60A1 — manages to destroy a BMP in EA Yellow as well - an ITOW behind Neuhof hits a BMP skulking in Dorfborn. Finally, Lyle’s wingman engages a BMP just as it fires a Spandrel missile. The BMP explodes as its missile pitbulls harmlessly off into the sky, to destinations unknown. The assault is utterly devastating on the Soviets. Within 60 seconds, 7 BMPs are burning. All that make it through the gauntlet of fire are the aforementioned pair of BMPs, which snake their way into Neuhof along the low ground. Dutifully, amazingly, fanatically, they disgorge their infantry, who storm into Clausen’s positions. The 2LT cannot but admire the courage of his Soviet counterparts. Nevertheless, admiration doesn’t translate to pity. A M60 and a Dragon were already pre positioned to watch this entrance into town, and their fire forces the Soviet dismounts to duck into an alley, and right into his first squad. It’s hardly a fight. Caught in the open, the Soviet riflemen are gunned down in a violent fusillade. The only return fire the infantry receive comes from the final Soviet, caught by a M60 burst, who fires his AK in a reflexive spraying arc as he slumps over, dead. Mercifully, his steel helmet slides forward and covers his face, sparing his killer from having to humanize him in the fatal moment. By 1135 hours the enemy’s attack is clearly shattered. The only surviving enemy are seen deployed at the forward edge of Dorfborn. An eerie silence momentarily falls…but is quickly shattered by a heavy Soviet barrage on 2LT’s Leblanc’s position in BP 1A. The initial pounding kills a pair of men, but the platoon is able to crawl into shelter on the bottom floor, and wait out the barrage in relative safety, even as it ruins and rubbles the buildings they are in. Again, the American artillery responds in kind, with much more effect. Guided on by 1LT Snook, 155s expend their remaining munitions on the forces in Dorfborn. The fire, so heavily concentrated in such a small space, rips some BMPs apart, flips others, and peppers the survivors with shrapnel. Booth briefly toys with the idea of counterattacking Dorfborn, encouraged by the scout sections report that a covered, undefended route onto the flank of the shattered village is open through the trees. He ultimately declines to do so, however. Cognizant of the diminished ammunition of both his direct and indirect fire weaponry, and the importance of making sure Lyles’ and Swafford’s platoons do not suffer unnecessary losses (their parent units will need them, after all), he decides against risking a broken neck so late in the battle. It becomes a moot point: under the cover of smoke and diesel splashed on engine decks, the surviving Soviets pull out of Dorfborn, slinking back in the direction they came. The Battle for Neuhof is over. It is 1142 hours. As the pounding of artillery fades, the first thing Booth notices – strange as it seemed – was that he could hear birds chirping; had they returned that quickly, or had they simply stayed throughout the fire and fury? The next thing he noticed is that he didn’t feel tired, at all. Wasn’t he supposed to feel fatigued as the adrenaline poured out of his body? All he felt was exhilaration, and satisfaction. They had stopped the Soviets cold, and mauled (no, he corrected himself, destroyed) a MRB for functionally no loss. His XO was already taking stock of the casualties. Booth knew he would not have many more letters to write, not much more than a dozen, at best. Unlike yesterday, he did not feel a man’s life had been lost in vain. That made it easier. His dependable FSGT had already departed in the TACP’s track to go fetch ammunition from Battalion. Battalion, he thought, how had the rest of the TF done? He couldn’t hear any sounds of battle on either flank…but he could see in the distance to the right, black smoke spires wafting over the forest dividing him from A Company’s engagement areas. A good sign. He concluded. Turning to his RTO, he dictated his SITREP for TOC... Ok, I am sold, let's do the first CM Movie - Dust in the Firestorm. 2 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
danfrodo Posted July 21, 2022 Share Posted July 21, 2022 Just noticed the latest posts on this. Absolute masterpiece. Dang, I gotta get outta this day job & house maintenence gig and pursue my true calling full time, CM. Just skimmed this so far, after work will get a bowl of ice cream and savor this. THANKS for all the effort you put into this. 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
CameronMcDonald Posted July 22, 2022 Share Posted July 22, 2022 Great read once again - thanks! 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.