theforger
-
Posts
331 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
2
Posts posted by theforger
-
-
https://www.thefewgoodmen.com/cm-mod-warehouse/?s=template
I can find most modules, but not for FB... can anyone help?
-
Yep, been happening since the last update.
I started splitting squads but even in a 4 man team one sometimes stands outside. As a prevention I send squads to upper floors.
-
Thanks for that. The CM Late Panther G has that distinctive chin to prevent shells hitting the turret and being ricochetted down onto the top of the main chassis.
They were available for the Ardennes.
But the burnt out pic is the first one I've seen with the 1st SS Pzr Regiment. It's a pity there's no ID number with it. Appreciate the info.
-
https://www.ww2aerialreconstudies.com/bulge.html
Does what it says on the tin...
-
looking over pictures of Panthers in Peiper's sector it looks none were the distinctive late variant Panthers. So my KG Pieper ToE will be mainly the "mid" variant.
Duel in the Mist pg 223 mentions 8 combat ready IVs and Vs bought back from Normandy and...
pg 230 mentions Bersin, (later to be part of Spitze) delivering a speech from a Panther A.
-
Are early - mid - late production model dates defined anywhere?
I.E. Panther VG Late = Jan 1945 onwards, so none of those models would have appeared with KG Peiper?
-
I get the bridges done as early as possible in the building process because it can be tricky. This is more so for diagonal bridges.
I appreciate you've probably put in a lot of effort already but I sometimes reorientate maps to mitigate against editor limitations, bridges, road curves etc.
Underlying tiles can have a small effect, gravel versus grass for example.
The more tiles of the same elevation around the end of the bridges, and running along the track away from the bridge, the better, but not much help when linking bridges together.
Happy to email you my versions of Trois Ponts, SW Malmedy and La Gleize which may help? La Gleize has 3 bridges linked albeit east to west.
-
appreciate the swift reply!
-
Just checking if you can use the AI to "control" some troops on your own side, i.e. a group that has their own specific orders?
Tried on a scenario, and it doesn't look like its possible but I thought I'd ask
.
-
On 2/22/2021 at 2:41 PM, slippy said:
Not a photo but found this mate, not sure if its what you have already
http://www.oldhickory30th.com/120thDec21Journal.pdf
you could try asking at http://ww2talk.com/index.php, i have found that site to be extremely helpful in the past. Also Google Maps street view can be quite helpful for getting a feel for the area, although there is a lot of new development you get a good idea of the lay of the land.
regards
slipper
I found an old photo at www.jacob.be of the paper mill.
Lots of Malmedy town shots too.
You are right about the development, one of the areas that has changed significantly since the war, which was why I was looking for that 1944 post battle aerial photo.
Thanks for the reply.
-
for those budding CW Scenario Designers
https://www.amazon.co.uk/Bear-Marches-West-Scenarios-Wargames-ebook/dp/B0086V6KA4
-
-
bit of a long shot, but does anyone have access to an aerial photo taken on 24th December 1944 US 30/5198.
It's of SW Malmedy where Skorzeny's KG X tries to cross the Warche, against the Norwegians.
I have the overlay sketch but the actual photo would allow me to take map creation to another level of accuracy.
https://mikesresearch.com/2019/12/29/malmedy-1944/ gives a good account of the action.
-
recently upgraded to Big Sur 11.1. The Mac has a Radeon Pro 580X 8GB. All working with CM titles prior to software upgrade.
having an issue importing tactical maps into scenario editor.
If I flip horizontal an image, once imported the image is blank.
If I don't flip the image horizontally the image is ok apart from being the incorrect way round.
As a workaround I've used keynote.
Built map in keynote. Screenshot the map. Flip the screenshot. Dropped the inverted image back into keynote. Screenshot the inverted map in keynote.
Works ok but a tad convoluted.
If I try and short cut those steps I get the blank screen.
Also
when selecting a battle, there is no splash screen whilst the scenario loads.
-
On 12/25/2020 at 12:04 AM, Rastamon said:
@theforgerReally looking forward to your end product here. Sounds like you put a lot of time and thought into it. Historical and well researched is my preferred combination. I'm happy to playtest or review individual scenarios.
Many years ago I created a Malemedy West/Skorzeny map in CMBN and then updated it to CMFB. It includes accurate TOE including names for the main leaders, tank comanders and even Francis Currey with his zook (CMH recipient in the battle). Happy to share my map and the btt if it would help. I almost had Fuser's help with the M10/Panther conversion but never quite made it.
Also, have given your Mission to Maas a spin a couple of times and really enjoy the more operational feel and decisions. Well done! I tweeked it a bit, added 251/21s as a few of the pioneer command vehicles instead of 251/17s as they had quite a few there. Also thinking about making it tougher on the germans by adding some P47s and have McCowns battalion or a company intercept the main road as they did during the battle.
@Rastamon Would be very interested in your research, thanks for the offer!
The area of South West of Malmedy has changed a lot since the war, probably more than most of the Peiper route. I spent sometime looking for Currey's House to model in the scenario. The closest I've found is from Jay Karamales / Reynolds YouTube video taken in 1993, 1 hour 23 minutes in.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zETC2h4PqZo
Trying to look for an aerial photo I found reference to Nat Archives, Malmedy Map 3 US 30/5198 taken 24th December 1944. I found a resulting sketch map but finding the photo I think would help with map accuracy. A photo / detailed description of the PaperMill would help a lot too as the site has been redeveloped.
At the moment my map is 1.5km (width) x 2km (depth). But I've not done any testing so it may change a little.
I've rotated the map NW. This has helped with the Warche Bridge and has left me with the ability to have 2 of the most significant roads on straight sections of in game road, helping to recreate line of sight. Ave du Pont de Warche, now runs completely straight, top to bottom of my in game map to Currey's House and final section of Route de Falize to the Underpass is at 45 degrees. I used the same technique for the Stavelot map earlier in this thread.
Regarding the overall TOE of the campaign, it excludes this specific battle, I've used Duel In The Mist 2, from page 205, so the KG Grenadiers/Pioneers transport has in this campaign a different look to the Mass scenario.
I've renamed every tank in the campaign with number/commander, taken from Duel In The Mist 3, page 218 onwards. This excludes KG X which isn't documented in those books, so again taking advantage of your research would help, thank you.
-
On 12/19/2020 at 10:25 PM, Sgt.Squarehead said:
Yes please.....That would be perfect (I didn't want to mess with your scenario map, as I intend to play the battle).
That would be ideal.....My intent is to convert it to CM:BS, for my 'Fragmentistan' concept.
Blank master map of the area. Think I've removed all flavour objects.
Haven't played CMBS for awhile as I've been busy on this, but it is my favourite, so will be interesting to use the conversion, good luck.
-
Not a problem.
The master version extends 2kms (3.7 kms total) further west. Would you prefer that one?
To be clear no forces, objects, briefing info, objectives, setup zones?
-
2 hours ago, Aragorn2002 said:
Did you make the map yourself? If so, well done! Looks like an interesting battle and thorough research. Briefing is short and clear, as I like them. I've changed the uniforms from Greatcoat to Winter, since I think that's more fitting for the Leibstandarte, but that's personal taste. Looking forward to playing this!
I will give it a go in the coming weeks. Certainly makes me very curious about the campaign! And more scenarios/maps would be very welcome.
The maps my own. It features 4 times in the campaign so it takes on progressively more damage and contains more wrecks. Used a lot of pre war postcards to try and get the look of the buildings as close as possible.
was a good resource too.
I'll take a look at the uniforms not really considered that.
-
- Storming Stavelot
7 Scenarios into the Rollbahn D campaign so the Germans are a little less healthy than in this standalone version but give it a run out. Only 1x AI plan at the moment in this version.
-
I have some content but it's for my first campaign compilation, Rollbahn D.
I started building in March. It's based on KG Peiper.
The ambition is/was to produce an historical scenario for every 6 hours or so of the KG and associated units, their advance and eventual destruction, from the 16th to Xmas.
So far in the "can" I have
- Murky Merlscheid (Fallschirmjäger)
- Leaving Lanzerath (Fallshirmjager)
- Minen The Gap (Losheim/Scheid, Spitze)
- Breakthrough (Bucholz/Honsfeld)
- Bull-in-gen China Shop
- Butchers Of Baugnez (thanks for the Cafe/Hotel/Signpost mods Kohlenklau!)
- Storming Stavelot
- Trois Is A Crowd
- Jabos! (Cheneux)
- Probe At Stavelot
- Neufmoulin Rouge
- Duel In The Mist (Stoumont)
- Too Tight At Targnon
- Ster Way To Heaven (Parfondry/Stavelot)
For the remaining 15x scenarios I will be using mostly maps already created... but realistically it is still going to be next autumn.
I've made my own maps apart from Cheneux with some edits. Working on KG X and Y/Skorzeny's attack on Malmedy and the 82nd's first attempt on Cheneux (including using the captured Stummel) at the moment.
Considering releasing some or all as individual battles and maps? Open to requests. Stick with it? Release a map or 2? Release a battle or 2?
I've published 3x scenarios in the past with mixed reviews, Mission to Mass V2, CMBS Korsun 2017 and Summer In The City.
I enjoy the research/creative process, you think you know stuff, then you realise you don't quite know as much as you thought you did.
Bibliography:
The Devils Adjutant by Michael Reynolds
The Leibstandarte Map Book Part IV
The Leibstandarte IV Ralf Tiemann
Duel In The Mist Parts 1,2 and 3, Vosters, Weber, Haasler, Meyer, MacDougall
Jochen Peiper, Patrick Agte
A Time for Trumpets, Charles B MacDonald
Battle of the Bulge Then and Now, Jean Paul Pallud
Panzer Truppen 1943-45, Thomas Jentz
Tigers in the Ardennes, Walden
Ardennes the Secret War, Whiting
KG Peiper:The Race to the Meuse, Cooke, Evans
Battle of the Bulge: Thee 3rd Fallshirmjager Division in Action
The Longest Winter, Kershaw
A Tour of the Bulge Battlefields, Cavanagh
Smashing Hitlers Panzers, Zaloga
Ardennes 1944, Beevor
And last but not least Combat Mission Community Forums
-
Maybe a feature rather than bug. I did notice another incident with an Ami who had surrendered, with his arms a loft get shot, all a bit too realistic for a Peiper campaign.
I have a wide variety of troops, green to vets with a few fanatics thrown in. About 50% of the scenarios have initially poor visibility, and all the incidents have occurred in poor visibility.
Saying that I plan to reimport the units after this test run and will continue to monitor.
-
2 hours ago, Howler said:
That's working as intended as are friendly fire incidents involving ammo .50cal(?) and up.
All low calibre infantry weapons, which is why it caught my eye, thought I was seeing things.
Thanks for the interest all.
-
5 hours ago, Wicky said:
Time of day?
Fair point, early morning before first light so visibility not great.
Maybe a feature rather than bug.
But after 3 occasions in separate campaign scenarios I thought I'd call it out.
The Pioneer HQ were vets, so experience a non issue.
-
5 hours ago, Bulletpoint said:
Never saw this happen. Are you sure you did not give them an area fire order by mistake?
They had no fire orders. I let the first couple of incidents pass with the fallshirmjager but third time I thought I'd call it out.
.
Fire and Rubble. First impressions.
in Combat Mission Red Thunder
Posted
the map of Berlin...just wow