Jump to content
Battlefront is now Slitherine ×

umlaut

Members
  • Posts

    1,916
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    14

Posts posted by umlaut

  1. Great idea, Kaunitz. I agree with just about everything you´ve said here. And I actually once made a extra large map myself for many of the same reasons - plus this one: Allowing scouting units to act more realistically. Often the maps are too small - and the time frame too short - for realistic scouting. So I made a very large map - and made a scenario that let the scouts have the map for themselves for the first hour. Sounds boring, perhaps - but I found it quite fun.

    One comment regarding field sizes, though: I dont think you should judge the sizes of fields too much on your personal experiences. In my country field sizes have increased a lot since the war, due to the dramatic centralization and mechanization of agriculture: Fewer, but much larger farms - with tractors and combine harvesters instead of horses. I guess that would be the case in most countries.

    I think I will try to find my old map and upload it as a quick battle map. Looking forward to seeing your work.

  2. On 6/27/2018 at 12:48 AM, MikeyD said:

    One thing that war movies taught me is if you're faced with a German machinegunner behind a sandbag wall eventually he will stand up, clutch his chest and fall forward, the sandbags collapsing beneath him. My source: SPR, The Dirty Dozen, and innumerable episodes of ''Combat' and 'Rat Patrol'. Wouldn't it be funny if the most 'factually accurate' war film turned out the be 'Catch-22'? ^_^

    'Reenactor' type movies tend to be deadly dull. The war (whichever war) is meant to be the backdrop to a proper human story, not the story itself. Technical accuracy, whether in U-boats, tanks, aircraft, or swordplay is the added spice that flavors the dish.

     

     

    Amen to that :)

  3. 21 hours ago, Sublime said:

    Ah ty I couldnt remember his name.

    His wiki is interesting. apparently he was a gunner on b29s in the PTO, flew 25 combat missions and received a purple heart.

    Unfortunately it also says he passed away in 2003 from a multitude of things that are basically the result of old age and the poor health issues that seem to multiply once a serious illness is introduced.

    When talking about movies in general - and Charles Bronson in  particular - I have to mention Once Upon a Time in the West.

    Watch it, if you havent already done so: It is a masterpiece - one of the best movies ever made, in my opinion.

  4. 5 hours ago, Badger73 said:

     I still think "Vikings" does a better job of it than most other shows.

    No doubt about that. It is in many ways very realistic and well researched. A good example is the burial scene (of the chieftain Harald, I think). That is more or less a verbatim reenactment of Ibn Fadlans eyewitness account of a burial.
    So it seems to me that the inaccuracies are not errors but deliberate, as if the crew said: "never mind that they acutally wore helmets and different clothes. This looks cooler, and most of the viewers wont know better anyway."

    5 hours ago, Badger73 said:

    I found Blood Eagles portrayed realistically enough!  😱

    Yeah, bloody bloody, that. Actually I recently read that the blood eagle is probably also just a myth, based on either a bad translation or a misunderstanding.

  5. On 6/21/2018 at 6:48 PM, Aragorn2002 said:

    I totally agree. Vikings rules!

    Being a dane - and quite knowledgeable in matters of the period - I must sadly disagree:

    Vikings is indeed a very entertaining series, but in my opinion it is far too historically incorrect for something that is produced by the History Channel.

    Generally, they have taken the old myth/saga of Regnar Lodbrog pretty much at face value. In my opinion it would have been wiser to try ot find the historical core of that myth.

    Beides the myth itself there are numerous inaccuracies. Here are a few from the top of my head:
    Regnar was a danish king/warlord. In the show he is living in a place that is definitely not Denmark, but Norway. Generally, the geography of Scandinavia is all messed up in the show. Uppsala looks nothing like the place depicted in the show - and Kattegat is not a town, but the sea between Jutland and Sweden.

    The clothing of the norsemen is completely wrong - and in the series none of the viking warriors wear helmets as they surely would have.

    In one of the first episodes Regnar and his men are part of the famous raid on Lindisfarne in 793 AD that is normally seen as the start of the viking era. Regnar lived much later. He was one of the leaders of the siege of Paris in 845 AD.

    I could go on...

  6. On 6/15/2018 at 12:35 AM, Erwin said:

    Wasn't sure if you were being humorous.   I saw it and thought it suc***...  was quite poor.

    Yes, it was a joke. I quit watching it after about half an hour. Found it an utter waste of time.

    Speaking generally about WWII movies, I find that the german ones are usually the best. I think this is because the germans (for obvious historical reasons) cannot base their stories on same old "Sergeant X saves the day and at the end we all salute the flag and shed a tear"-clichés that seems to be all Hollywood is capable of producing.

    The germans have to focus on a realistic story about real people in a real war. Stuff that is hard to press into a movie industry template filled with good vs evil stereotypes. The germans have to focus on a good script. And if the script is good, then the movies usually turns out to be too.

    In Hollywood it seems that the script is much less important than the CGI.

  7. How come he didn´t mention the war movie above them all, "White Tiger"? 😀

    Seriously, his views match my own pretty well (though he of course has much more knowledge to back them up). I especially liked the comments about The Patriot being a stinker. To me it has always just been a remake of Braveheart in a different location.

    Now I have to find 317th Platoon - which I must admit I had never even heard about.

×
×
  • Create New...