i played some CC4 recently while waiting for my CMBO to arrive.
I had previously played CC2 and 3.
CMBO is definitley a mroe accurate simulation of battle with far superior AI than CC.
Where I think CMBO needs to improve to be able to move more gamers from CC to CMBO:
- graphics, CC is much nicer looking
- UI, CC is much more polished, CMBO is pretty rough around the edges, and also breaks some conventions with other similar games (ESC key action, no CTRL-# grouping, etc)
- campaigns, while CC is pretty lame with it's campaigns they are somewhat interesting to play and CMBO could be really interesting with a campaign engine
- real time... this is debatable as the detail of CMBO would be hard to be effective with in real time, however real time is a lot of fun
just my $0.02