AK
Two questions occur from the thread as a whole and the proposed design.
Are you still planning to implement the 'I played as' facility suggested by WWB and mentioned in one of your earlier posts?
Are you proposing to have the ratings and/or text comments against an 'overall impression/fun/ playability' category, and also to have ratings/text comments against a set of supporting criteria such as balance, map quality etc (where the author has allowed this)? If so, does this thread need to come up with proposals, input or possibly even consensus on the list of supporting criteria that can be rated?